4 ms·
This is why, I think, the future is either putting your money (or at least provable identity) where your mouth is, or not being heard (e.g. because everyone wil
by nine_k 4y ago
This is why, I think, the future is either putting your money (or at least provable identity) where your mouth is, or not being heard (e.g. because everyone will assume a petition without hard proofs of identity fake).
Yes, this is disenfranchising. But not being heard while some company pretends to speak for you is even more disenfranchising.
- lubujackson 4y agoWe don't need an ironclad identity system, we need stronger laws making individuals behind companies like this personally and criminally liable with harsh penalties. That is how scenarios like this can be avoided: destroy the cost/benefit ratio of pursuing it. Yes, fraud can still happen. But if you fake 100,000 comments eventually you will be discovered and held responsible. What this would reduce is systemic fraud at scale.
- lockhouse 4y agoCan you even function in modern society without a government issued photo ID? It’s required to drive, collect benefits, fly, purchase alcohol, purchase tobacco, or even purchase Sudafed. I just can’t fathom that there are any actual petitioners or voters that requiring photo ID would disenfranchise.
- kevviiinn 4y agoI guess the homeless and poor don't matter
- lockhouse 4y agoIs there a state where you can sign up for public assistance without proving your identity with government issued ID? I'm not aware of any. I'm pretty sure the Venn diagram of people without access to government issued ID and legal, eligible voters is two distinct circles.
- kevviiinn 4y agoI'm pretty sure all citizens are eligible voters?
- lockhouse 4y agoI’m pretty sure all citizens are able to get government issued ID
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoUK does not issue ID, but you have to have an ID to vote now :D 4D chess They have a register of random documents issued by 3rd parties that they will accept as proof of ID.
- kevviiinn 4y agoThere are areas that you have to pay for ID which disenfranchises the voters who can't afford it
- lockhouse 4y agoWhere are these places where potential voters can't afford ID and how do they do any of the other things that typically require photo ID? https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/24-things-that-require-a-photo-id https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/24-things-that-require-a-...
- kevviiinn 4y ago>how do they do any of the other things that typically require photo ID? When they are poor enough they either don't or have incredibly limited funds. I'm not sure what you don't understand about this
- lockhouse 4y agoI just have a really hard time believing there is a large group of individuals without ID when it is essentially mandatory for modern life as an adult. I also am having difficulty believing that the usually less than $25 fee for government issued ID is an obstacle to anyone. Personally I think a verified voter ID should be both required (so as to prevent voter fraud) and provided freely to everyone.
- webinvest 4y agoHow do you invent a system where the websites instituting the identity proof (KYC/ Know Your Customer) systems don’t just become honeypots for collecting the necessary data to impersonate the millions of people that used it? Others have commented on your point about money already
- demindiro 4y ago>This is why, I think, the future is either putting your money (or at least provable identity) where your mouth is That will become less effective as companies become increasingly centralized, with just a few having many, many brands.
- Thorrez 4y agoWhy would companies becoming more centralized make "putting your money where your mouth is" less effective?
- bluSCALE4 4y agoBecause it can become hard to pick a different brand since there really aren't any choices at all: it's a monopoly.
- incone123 4y agoYou seem to be addressing a related but separate matter, namely boycotting products to influence companies. The topic in hand is companies pretending to be large numbers of anonymous people. This is what would be prevented if submissions to public consultations were tied to real-world identities.
- martin-adams 4y agoBecause they will start to have a monopoly and consumer choice will be so little, that you can’t avoid them.
- Thorrez 4y agoI think this is a miscommunication. You interpret nine_k's phrase "putting your money where your mouth is" as meaning "buying only from companies you support", but I think nine_k actually meant "having public comments require payment".
- throw101010 4y agoMaybe this will come off as cynical, but aren't the customers of these 3 companies doing what you suggest here? "Putting their money where their mouth is", and since they have a lot of money their voice gets heard over the ones of individuals with no money. I don't think it's your goal. So your second intuition about proof of identity is better, but the minute you invent a foolproof identity system and it gets widly used (by fiat or even voluntarily), you give a tremendous amount of power to the issuer/manager of it, as they basically hold the power of also removing/altering your public identity at their whims. You also make it harder and harder to remain anonymous and preserve your privacy, two things that might seem useless in a functional democracy, but unfortunately democracies are not perfect and they can turn into totalitarian systems where the wet dream of dictators is exactly this: having total control over every individual, especially the ones who would dare signing petitions against them. This is by far not something humans have solved systemically, we have the technical solutions to build such systems, and governments tend to push to implement them, but as someone who cares about privacy/censorship resistance I do my best to build alternative, opt-in, systems to go around them.
- M95D 4y agoNo. Public/private keys can be under the control of the individual. You only need the public key to be signed by a trusted 3rd party. That only gives them the power to revoke it, but even the revoking can't cancel what you already signed while the key was valid.
- DougN7 4y agoImagine your “trusted third party” is or becomes a dictator, who logs all signed keys. This doesn’t solve anything I’m afraid.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoStop trying to solve everything. These complex issues are never solved but we can improve and work on them.
- withinboredom 4y ago> This is why, I think, the future is either putting your money (or at least provable identity) where your mouth is, or not being heard Oh, I assume this will be run by companies. What is stopping them from impersonating you? Or impersonating you after you're dead? How can we trust these companies not to sell access to identities? Further, why not sell/rent your access to your own identity?
- nine_k 4y agoIt's a good technical question. Partly it's audit: check some randomly chosen votes, look for anyone not remembering casting their vote. Partly it could be cryptography: you keep a private key and sign your vote with it. Your public key is stored by a trusted centralized institution, or several (see GitHub and signed commits), so anyone can verify your vote, but nobody can fake it.
- mauvehaus 4y agoVoting is anonymous to make it harder for someone to demand proof that you voted in accordance with their wishes. I wouldn't want my employer, for instance, to be able to verify that I voted for their preferred candidate for state representative and take retaliatory actions against me if I didn't.
- nine_k 4y agoI don't speak of general voting, like for President. I mean voting for various petitions, etc, the stuff outlined in the article. Better fraud protection during general elections would be great, too, but it's a different and more complex area.
- kevingadd 4y agoWhat makes you think lobbyists and large corporations can't afford the fee to speak?
- nine_k 4y agoIt's mostly not the fee to speak, even though a mere $1 per vote could be too expensive for some petition-spamming efforts: 100k payments from the same account would trigger suspicion, and creating 100k legal payment accounts (paypal, google / apple / samsung pay, venmo, etc) just to pay $1 per vote may be onerous. I mostly say about giving a ton of identifying info so that your vote can be reliably tracked back to you: not only email (with a one-time link to confirm the email works), but also a phone number, postal address, maybe even some government ID like SSN or driver license number. It removes any expectation of anonymity from the vote or signature, and this is by design. Fraud of the kind the article mentions would be easily detectable by a random check of 1-2% of the signatures (and more is suspicious patterns are noticed). As a side effect, it would make a vote or a signature a much more conscious, committed decision.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]