2 ms·
I teach (TA/Grad Researcher). We know how much you all use ChatGPT. Just like we know how much you all cheat. We also know that the level of cheating exponentia
by godelski 4y ago
I teach (TA/Grad Researcher). We know how much you all use ChatGPT. Just like we know how much you all cheat. We also know that the level of cheating exponentially increased during covid. We're not dumb.
But the truth is there's little we can do about it. Often it is difficult to prove concretely, and so there's a risk/reward function that needs to be considered. But I'll give you an example where I had clear proof. Two students uploaded code from another student. Into their github. The git logs were not removed and had the name of the original owner (who's mistake was not making their repo private). This was taken to the department head. Department head did not want to do anything about it. Why? Because every cheater we prosecute gets logged and administration determines that the number of cheaters is proportional to the number of students we persecute. If a department has a lot of cheaters then we get reduced funding and a lot of audits. I'm sure you can put together the rest of the story here.
The truth is that there's only a handful of ways around this: Small classes, in class assessments, project based homeworks. Repetitive and "doing" homework is good and necessary but these shouldn't be major parts of the grade (or even graded). Take home exams are even fine and probably worthwhile. The reason being is that when you write a takehome exam you operate under the assumption that this is open book and open internet.
We have to think about incentives here. If we're being honest, most students aren't there to learn, they are there to get their piece of paper. (How do we fix this?) Departments are not aligned to prioritize learning, they are prioritized to make money. Training for a degree is perfectly acceptable, but if the students aren't invested in it then what incentive do they have to not cheat (you're never going to win this game. Students are good at cheating and will always win). We have to consider that grades are also the main signal, but that even though this may be a decent signal when aggregated across students that it is a very noisy signal across individuals (e.g. Did you take the hard professor that never gives an A but you learn a shit ton from or did you take the professor that gives easy As and you don't get a deep understanding of the material? Why do students pick one over the other in a very predictable way?).
ChatGPT isn't anything new or a crisis. But it does put higher pressure for us to rethink how our system has changed and what incentives we created.