5 ms·
GM Stock Sinks 30% After Analyst Sets $0 Price Target
- anthonyrubin 18y ago"Johnson cut his price target on the stock to $1 from $4." Equity value is also known as "Diluted Earnings Per Share" and is not the same as the share price.
- mixmax 18y agoThey fell behind 20 years ago and have been trying to catch up ever since. With no success. The only thing a government bailout now ensures is that there will be another bailout in a few years time. Let them die.
- sown 18y agoHow terrible. :( It's hard to imagine a foreign competitor having this same problem: running into a rough patch for a couple of years and then all of a sudden looks at bankruptcy. I just want my volt.
- uuilly 18y agoIt's really not terrible. America invented the TV and Zenith, the last American TV company, was sold to LG over a decade ago. Not many cried when IBM sold it's laptop division to Lenovo either. Americans just aren't great at manufacturing. PG wrote about this a long time ago here: http://paulgraham.com/usa.html http://paulgraham.com/usa.html It's not sad to pass the torch. The car is 100 years old. It's time to do something new. We should be focused on innovation not on some notion that it's our god given right to have American cars. As of this writing there is an interview with Elon Musk of Telsa Motors at the bottom of the news.yc page. That should be the future of American cars. I heard that the Tesla engineers had a week long sit down w/ the Volt engineers. The word was that the Volt guys were an embarrassment and that they couldn't answer simple questions about their batteries. Chevy can't build a simple gas powered car that can go over 60k miles w/o having all the buttons fall off the dashboard. There is no way they're going to build a decent Prius competitor. They had a good run, let them die.
- ssharp 18y agoI don't think Paul Graham's analysis of the US auto industry is accurate at all. Toyota is the number one manufacturer of automobiles right now and outside of the Lexus brand, none of their designs are significantly more stylish than any GM product. Where Toyota was able to flank America was on quality. That advantage is pretty much over at this point as U.S. automakers have made huge strides in initial quality over the past several years and have implemented quality procedures on par with Toyota. In terms of style, Europe is well ahead of the U.S. but that is how they differentiate themselves. European cars are more expensive across the board than Japanese & U.S. If you look at the styling of Japanese and Korean cars, you're not going to see much of anything better than what GM and Ford are doing, yet Toyota, Hyundai, etc. are not having the difficulties that GM is having. Where GM is failing is in two things: marketing (mainly positioning and products) and labor. GM workers are making a lot more than Toyota assembly workers, especially those that have been around a long time. This problem is fixable with cooperation from the UAW but it's not going to be easy and a lot of buyouts will be necessary. The next problem with GM is that they failed to forecast the markets. They largely ignored the compact market, were behind the curve on crossovers, and didn't put enough money into their sedans. They put all their eggs in one basket with trucks & SUVs. Those vehicle sales were dropping off even before gas was $4/gallon. While their sedans have caught up to the Japanese in real terms, they still have a serious image problem and are still viewed as inferior. I haven't seen much advertising that really addresses these concerns. You can't reposition yourself overnight with advertising and you definitely cannot reposition yourself overnight with new/improved products but GM is on the right track. There are a lot of other macroeconomic conditions that get involved if GM does or does not receive bailout money but if they do get it, I don't think it will be wasted.
- sown 18y agoI'd feel better about an analysis from an expert on manufacturing and so forth, which I get the impression neither you, pg or me are. I dunno about throwing "innovation" around on cars; I think people use that word without caution or really thinking about what it means. When I grew up the nearest stop light was 20 miles away; cars were the only way to get around. Even now, living in Mountain View it's a hassle living without a car. Everywhere I've lived up until now was a huge hassle without a car, partly because it was so remote. A very large segment of the US lives like this and frankly, I don't like the idea of sharing a bus seat with strangers, waiting on trains, etc. I like the idea of automated cars as public transit and so forth but we shouldn't throw stuff out because it is old. The chair is lord only knows how old and just like I need to sit, I need to get out of the house to do whatever. ;)
- mattmaroon 18y agoForeign competitors don't run into this problem because they weren't saddled with unions. When you are forced by labor laws to pay $30 to a guy who pulls a lever all day, it turns out its hard to compete in the global economy.
- nazgulnarsil 18y agomonopolies are bad, it doesn't matter whether it is a monopoly by the "evil corporations" or the "saintly workers". monopolies always hurt the economy. ALWAYS.
- sown 18y agoThere are good things and bad things about unions but painting them all as somehow bad is a bit extreme. Of course, there are Japanese auto unions as there will be in China. As the son of a man who was a APWU union man who worked himself to the bone for the family, my own personal experience can attest that the only thing that kept management's abusive treatment of their workers, like my dad, in check, was the union. While balance is a issue of most things, just blaming unions carte-blanche and saying we don't need them is...harsh.
- mattmaroon 18y agoWhat abusive treatment? The market doesnt value people who work at car factories very highly because their job is so easy that anyone even slightly more intelligent than a chimpanzee can do it. The supply of able workers is pretty near 100% of the population. The reason programmers don't unionize is because they are trained in a trade that not just anyone can do. They don't need to worry about being "exploited". Regardless of whether we need them or not, unions are why American car companies have no shot. They're saddled with ridiculous wages and pensions. They shouldn't, according to market economics, have to pay any more than Wal Mart for their labor, but they are forced to, and as such they'll never be able to compete in a global economy against those who aren't. Any good things that come from a union in the short term (such as higher paychecks and pensions) are more than destroyed by the harm caused when they run entire industries out of the country. There's a reason they call my neck of the nation the rust belt. It's price fixing pure and simple, and it's always bad for the economy in the end.
- helveticaman 18y agoGM has been in a rough patch for thirty years.
- redorb 18y agoyeah as soon as you let all your employees join unions and negotiate, they get to lock you in a negotiated price or shut you down. The better alternative is to probably give an environment where the employees feel they don't need a union.
- ssharp 18y agoOf course this is the answer but a lot of management doesn't understand this. If you take a look at Japanese manufacturers, you can see that they actually value their employees. However, in the case of the UAW, management laid down for them for decades in fear of production cuts. When the income was rolling in, the worst thing for them was a production shutdown. They weren't forward thinking enough to realize that eventually these relatively unskilled workers would be making $40/hour on an assembly line and getting ridiculous health care benefits in their pensions. It's a double-edged sword but a lot of baby boomers ended up making a lot more money then they ever should have. Now, when any group of employees wants to organize, most management immediately thinks of what the UAW has done and thinks its the worst thing in the world. They think that it's 100% employee greed and don't look at themselves for answers. In reality, most unions organize today because management is really bad in creating a good work environment. A little DAILY effort goes a long way in making your employees feel valued and as long as the compensation is somewhat close to average, you're not likely going to face a union coming in.
- hugh 18y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but isn't it perfectly possible for General Motors go go bankrupt but continue to operate? I'd sure miss GM (particularly Cadillac, Opel, Holden and even parts of Chevrolet) if it ceased to exist, but if the company can go bankrupt, discharge some of its liabilities, and have its valuable assets bought up by other car companies (Chevy goes to Tata, Cadillac goes to VW, Buick probably winds up Chinese and Pontiac vanishes altogether) then that'd be okay too. A government bailout at this point would be a favour only for the unions, not for the shareholders. (Which is why it will probably happen.)
- anthonyrubin 18y agoOf course. There are different forms or chapters of bankruptcy. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bankruptcy_in_the_United_States#Chapters_of_the_Bankruptcy_Code http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bankruptcy_in_the_United_States... Chapter 7 is liquidation and Chapter 11 is reorganization.
- mdasen 18y agoYes. In fact, most companies start by filing for Chapter 11 protection where they are sheltered from their creditors while they try to get their act together. In the meantime, GM would operate pretty normally from the perspective of anyone on the outside. If GM goes completely bankrupt, what will happen is that pieces of it will be sold off in order to take care of its debts/obligations. So, even if GM ceases to exist, it's very likely that the vehicles will find new life. The problem is that no one wants to buy GM whole because that comes with obligations like $75/hour labor costs and a pension system that was ill-conceived. Pieces of GM without those obligations (which can be voided by bankruptcy courts) are very valuable. GM is still the second largest auto manufacturer in the world. Despite the fact that many are yelling at GM management saying that they need to build cars that people want to buy, that simply isn't true. People do want to buy GM cars and they buy more GM cars than they do Hondas, Fords, Nissans, VWs, etc. Only Toyota does better. Maybe they don't make vehicles that yuppies like. That's different. I personally think GM cars are crap, but I'm not everyone and, as sales numbers for 2007 show, GM cars are equally popular to Toyota cars (http://money.cnn.com/2008/01/23/news/companies/gm_global_sales/index.htm http://money.cnn.com/2008/01/23/news/companies/gm_global_sal...). The problem is that GM is loosing money on the vehicles they produce (around $2,000 per vehicle). A large part of that is labor costs. Unionized plants under foreign manufacturers don't have the costs that GM's plants do, so it's not a pro vs. anti-union thing. For a lot of reasons, the UAW was able to get really great terms for its contracts since it started organizing at a time when GM could simply pass on higher labor costs to consumers. Now, that isn't the case and it's hurting both the union and the company. Unions are great things most of the time (in my opinion). However, in this case the market changed dramatically and the UAW didn't adjust rather expecting GM to make all the adjustments. Competition from Japan and others meant that the age of amazingly high auto-profits was over as consumers got choice. Likewise, that also meant the end of wages as high as the UAW had gotten them. At this point, a government bailout wouldn't help anyone - it would merely delay things. GM doesn't need cash for 12 months while they develop a new product. As an HN way of thinking about this, Digg has recently shown that it needs cash to keep the lights on - that its revenues cannot cover its costs. It isn't a matter of finishing a new product. It's just that advertising doesn't cover their costs. Likewise, sales don't cover GM's costs. They need to cut costs and become more efficient and one of the largest costs they have (compared to their competitors) is labor. In fact, based on GM's labor premium and the number of hours it requires them to build a vehicle and their annual vehicle sales, a reduction of the labor cost to Toyota's level of around $48/hour would likely make them safe with a savings of around $8bn per year (not profitable, but safe). GM still has other problems - they need to cut the number of hours it takes to produce a vehicle, they need to cut the costs their suppliers charge them by multi-sourcing more, and they need to better utilize their plants (all three of which would likely be opposed by the UAW since less labor required is bad for them, multi-sourcing means their suppliers can't offer as high wages, and better utilization of plants means you aren't paying workers to do nothing meaning you need less labor - GM has many idle workers). So, in conclusion, people like GM cars. GM has labor costs that are too high. GM isn't efficient enough in production. If GM becomes more efficient, it means requiring less labor. It's crappy for workers, but economies change. I totally understand why the UAW doesn't want to change. I totally understand why Microsoft, Sun, Oracle, and many tech companies continue down many of their paths. However, if they're paths that end because the landscape changed, it just isn't reasonable to believe you can continue taking them. When the economy changes, you can change with it or you can fade away slowly.
- steveplace 18y agoFinally, an analyst gets it right.