4 ms·
Sounds like a CFAA felony (unauthorized access) and I couldn't cogently be able to explain why it's not. (Because of a hidden clause in the ToS? Can you hide "
by perihelions 4y ago
Sounds like a CFAA felony (unauthorized access) and I couldn't cogently be able to explain why it's not.
(Because of a hidden clause in the ToS? Can you hide "we'll install ransomware on your PC" in a software ToS and enforce that, too? What's the very fine distinction between "we'll remotely disable your printer until you pay for exclusive, cryptographically-signed ink", and "we'll remotely encrypt your files and demand payments for the key?")
(It's not a particularly new idea, to extort someone under the pretense of selling them a useful service (exclusive ink). That's just "protection racket" — I think?)
- carlmr 4y agoAt least in German law anything "surprising" in the ToS can't be enforced. This would definitely be surprising to most. So it couldn't legally be done with ToS.
- WalterBright 4y agoFor me, when you "purchase" something, it's yours and you can do whatever the hell you want with it. If a "purchase" comes with "terms of use", it should not be classified as a purchase. It should be clearly labeled as "rent".