3 ms·
A good test for an AI would be if we excluded all human text mentioning consciousness, experiences, emotions etc from its training data. Then, when it would sti
by cubefox 4y ago
A good test for an AI would be if we excluded all human text mentioning consciousness, experiences, emotions etc from its training data. Then, when it would still start talking about consciousness, that would be strong evidence that it has consciousness: If it did invent the concept by itself, and mere imitation can be ruled out.
- AnthonyMouse 4y agoBut then it would no longer be the same AI. You can't expect it to experience empathy or sadness if it has no knowledge of the things that cause them in humans, but any text discussing them would be mixed up with the experience of whoever wrote it. Or if you use a less selective filter then it goes the other way. Exclude philosophy texts but not Facebook posts and it would still have what it needs to emulate emotional text regardless of whether it has ever seen a formal discussion of it. And it could plausibly extrapolate from that to an analytical discussion, having seen both that and analyses of other subjects, without ever feeling anything itself.
- cubefox 4y agoSo you are saying the Turing test is not a good test for consciousness?
- AnthonyMouse 4y agoI'm saying I don't think we have a good test for consciousness, but then what do you want to do when someone tries to claim that an AI is conscious and no one can prove it one way or the other?
- PrimeMcFly 4y agoOf course it isn't, nor was it intended to be.