3 ms·
I'm not sure what part of Gruber's article you're responding to.
by twoodfin 15y ago
I'm not sure what part of Gruber's article you're responding to.
- huggyface 15y agoThe entire article is Gruber hand-picking Jobs quotes that serve his vision of Jobs, and discounting the quotes that Isaacson picked -- or holding them as misunderstandings/misinterpretations -- because they don't conform with Gruber's opinion. Gruber has commented on Isaacson's book numerous times with incredible disdain (because, Gruber thinks, it misrepresents Jobs), so this is just a continuation of that theme.
- reidmain 15y agoGruber makes multiple references to Jobs' faults in that article. He is simply shredding the quotes that Issacson used without actually thinking about what they meant or checking the facts. What about this article do you think is Gruber twisting Issacson's words?. Every example has a well documented reason on why Issacson is flat out wrong.
- huggyface 15y agoDid we read the same article? Where does Gruber "shred" anything? Bill Gates says that "Instead the purchase ended up bringing in Avie Tevanian, who could help the existing Apple operating system evolve so that it eventually incorporated the kernel of the NeXT technology.", and Gruber says "Mac OS X 10.0 was a hybrid of Mac and NeXT technology, but it was clearly the NeXT system with Mac technologies integrated, not the other way around." What Bill Gates said was absolutely true! Rhapsody with the NeXT Mach kernel, a pulled-in, non-NeXT BSD application layer, and then various other Mac layers (GUI, Cocoa, etc). Technically there is nothing wrong with his statement. But it doesn't sound as impressive to Steve Jobs to say that only the microkernel (which we know is a critical part of a system), so better still to simply claim Gates is the liar?
- sjwright 15y ago> and then various other Mac layers (GUI, Cocoa, etc). Incorrect. The GUI wasn't ported, it was rewritten for OS X. Cocoa's heritage is NeXT to the core. Nothing vaguely resembling Cocoa existed in the classic Mac environment. > a pulled-in, non-NeXT BSD application layer Incorrect. There is little of "BSD" in the Mac OS X environment, save for some FreeBSD userland components, most of which only matter on the command line. The application layer of Mac OS X is Cocoa. (There is also the Carbon application layer which does partially derive from classic Mac, but that existed solely to ease application porting of existing Mac apps. But even Carbon is a hybrid, and was actually back-ported to Mac OS 9.) > Technically there is nothing wrong with his statement. Any Mac OS X software developer will know enough to confidently refute the accuracy of Gates' claims.
- jonhendry 15y ago"There is little of "BSD" in the Mac OS X environment, save for some FreeBSD userland components, most of which only matter on the command line. " The same was true of NeXTStep and OpenStep/Mach. Mach kernel. BSD user land. NeXT GUI.
- reidmain 15y agoI'm curious, have you actually done any Mac or iOS development?
- huggyface 15y agoI'm curious, Have you actually done NeXTStep development?
- lurch_mojoff 15y agoYes, I have. And I can confidently say that Mac OS X, even today after a decade of evolution and sweeping changes, is clearly a direct descendant of NeXTStep and has little in common with System 7. I'll also reiterate what others said -- there is everything wrong with Gates' statement.
- twoodfin 15y agoBut it's not about the quotes at all, except insofar as the quotes that Isaacson chose leave the reader with an impression that is simply wrong. The Bill Gates quote about the NeXT acquisition stuck out for me, too. Are you disagreeing with Gruber's thesis that Isaacson really didn't understand the complementary contributions of software to "design"? Why? I'm typically not a defender of John's, but he seems to me to be on target here.