9 ms·
IBM sued for age discrimination by former global software director
- clnq 4y agoAge discrimination is all over tech. But what's the argument for age discrimination after 40? What's the mindset that someone who is for this discrimination would have, no matter how immoral or unethical? Is there a defensible view that supports discrimination at all? EDIT: Sorry for creating a downvote hole for some of you who respond. There are good responses immediately downvoted. It is important for us to understand the arguments behind these biases to effectively fight them. It is not productive to silence this discussion. Thank you for those who responded seriously and helped me understand the situation better.
- belter 4y agoGetting rid of expensive employees.
- rightbyte 4y agoNo I think it is more due to implied seniority due to age. The older the engineer the less BS he eats from management.
- seattle_spring 4y agoI dunno, my real life experience shows the most insistence on agile/scrum bullshit coming from older engineers. SDETs specifically.
- d0mine 4y agoIs it really that value/price becomes worse with age or the companies are just being short-sighted?
- yaseer 4y agoI think the way you've phrased your question will invite negative responses. Perhaps a better way would be "I'd like to understand why age discrimination exists in tech. What motivates companies to do this?"
- clnq 4y agoMy earlier words weren't liked and got downvotes fast. But, we need to look at all sides of tough topics to really understand them. This includes the best reasons people give for discrimination, even if they go against what's moral, ethical, or legal. We can only substantially argue against these views if we first understand them. Even though age discrimination is very often illegal and probably always (maybe depends on the culture) unjust, there might be some sense to it from a managers point of view. For example, people with more experience often demand higher salaries. This is something we can't overlook when we're trying to reason about the ageism bias. And we can't really combat it substantially and directly if we ignore the strongest arguments for it — steel-manning is a very powerful tool in changing minds. I probably could have phrased it better.
- xtiansimon 4y ago> “I think the way you've phrased your question will invite negative responses.” And? If you see nuance, and rephrasing the OP can help make your response on point, then please share. Otherwise I find this browbeating and condescending. You’re just telling us how you want to hear the argument framed. Geez.
- yaseer 4y agoPerhaps the tone and context were not clear. > And? A set of negative responses tends to make the quality of Internet discussions deteriorate. I thought there was an interesting discussion to be had, so suggested an alternative phrasing.
- christophilus 4y agoYeah. I’m over 40, and I expect a high salary due to my productivity and experience. You could replace me with 3 folks from around the world, and it’s arguably a reasonable business decision.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoIt's maybe only a "good" business decision if you have very short-termist thinking.
- clnq 4y agoYes, the institutional knowledge lost would cost more than the difference of that salary a year in most cases. But companies definitely do not value institutional knowledge as much as black-on-white figures on their financial statements. Short-termist, but a lot of business decisions are very short-termist, so I think the argument is good. Someone might think that.
- Mistletoe 4y agoUnfortunately most companies, shareholders, and execs care about the stock performance the next quarter and that’s about it. A neat compensation package for a CEO would be “What will the stock price be in a decade?” But you could never get a CEO to commit for a decade because they know like we all do that job hopping is how you make more money and get raises. The system is messed up all the way down. https://hbr.org/2019/11/the-ceo-life-cycle https://hbr.org/2019/11/the-ceo-life-cycle > For instance, when we asked CEOs about the ideal tenure for the role, many mentioned the widely touted seven-year average. When we surveyed directors, they said that CEOs generally should leave the job after 9.5 years—a point at which, many believe, performance typically plateaus. Why these expectations? No one has a compelling or evidence-based answer. They are simply conventional wisdom. The graph in that linked article is particularly telling as it shows performance increases all come after ten years.
- dangwhy 4y agoDo CEO's really job hop though? I am looking at top tech companies and they seem to have been there for a long time and none of them are job hoppers.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoI honestly think it's mostly a set of connected biases along the lines of: a) "Progressivism", a bias towards thinking of "good tech" as the "novel/new tech". Or believing that success rides on quick adoption of new things, along with b) A bias that believes that that the older you are the less likely that you have engaged with new novel tech. c) A bias that believes that if you're still "just" an engineer and not management, there must be something wrong with you. Younger staff will accept "grey hairs" at the executive level but sometimes be bewildered by it at the individual contributor level. d) A bias against more expensive talent generally. e) A bias (among some) against talent that cannot be easily manipulated f) A bias (among some) against people with children/families/mortgages/elderly parents, etc. that might "slow things down." (This one is maybe the trickiest because it can express itself in ways that are not at all intended to be malicious but end up with bad effects. E.g. organizing team offsites and gatherings which are hard for parents or committed spouses to engage with because of their obligations. And the older we get the more likely we are to have such obligations) Most people who hold these biases hold them unconsciously. I personally look (or sometimes act) younger than I am, and get "surprise" from people when I tell them my age. Likely because they have bias about what that age should/could imply. Age bias is mostly "correctable" in most decent human beings. Where it gets malicious is when it gets in the hands of management who have a cost focus.
- clnq 4y agoThank you for taking my question seriously. These are all illuminating points. To continue on point e... I also think that older people tend to be more difficult to manipulate with long work hours, unreasonable deadlines, or incompetent management. With enough experience, we learn to recognise these things and we set some boundaries. Someone might dislike that and say that the more experienced people don't fit into the corporate hustle culture, without examining the reasons in-depth.
- eitally 4y agoThis is the sort of statement that isn't wrong, but which illustrates the echo chamber that is HN (or tech in general). There are plenty of industries and even more companies where "hustle culture" just isn't a thing, and management don't devolve into a default of employee abuse. Also, besides growing a spine and looking out for #1 increasingly as they gain age & experience, most people also start realizing that their time is finite and they need to actively prioritize where to spend it. For many, this realization comes with relationships & children, something most white collar professionals don't experience until they've been working 7-10 years.
- op00to 4y agoOld people are more expensive. That’s it.
- gedy 4y ago[flagged]
- tyingq 4y agoThey are also less likely to cave into pressure to work long hours. Or to buy into silly kool-aid movements.
- wongarsu 4y agoThey will also push back on your plan to replace the existing system with a microservice data-lake using event sourcing with Kafka, using a service-mesh on a Kubernetes cluster on the distributed cloud. Either because they haven't kept up with the latest tech, or because they have the experience to tell beforehand that your vanity project may sound cooler but increases complexity for no real technical advantage.
- belter 4y agoThe above post should not be down voted. Although as others mentioned, it could have been phrased differently, it was clear the post was about understanding the reasons behind age discrimination, not about endorsing or justifying it.
- Dalewyn 4y agoAge is an undeniable factor when it comes to learning new things[1], whether any of us like it or not. Ultimately, the question to you as an employee is whether you can do the work demanded of you. While it would be nice for everyone to be judged on an individual basis, I can understand there needs to be some level of generalization to maintain a certain level of efficiency within an organization. [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35595846 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35595846
- belter 4y agoYou are providing a case of airline pilot training. It's hard to believe a experienced and high quality software engineer with 20 year of experiences, will not learn a new programming language faster and better, than a freshly graduated 22 year old child :-)
- HPsquared 4y agoNeuroplasticity is supposedly on a constant decline after childhood. Also processing speed, working memory, long-term memory. Offset by increased experience, of course.
- BossingAround 4y agoWhile true that neuroplasticity is probably declining after reaching age of 20-21 (?), that doesn't mean much. People can learn new things during their lifetime. It's not like when you have a 21-year old, they are learning at the speed of light, whereas a 40-year old takes ages to learn the same tech.
- nibbleshifter 4y agoThat can be somewhat fixed. Not if your employer does drug tests though...
- serial_dev 4y agoOne argument (though, very cynical) for getting rid of 40+ yo people in tech: they cannot be so easily manipulated into blindly following company directives, and they are more likely to actually push back against bs rules/guidelines, whereas young people either don't know better, or they are more agreeable.
- walterbell 4y ago1000+ comments on age discrimination in tech, https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=age%20discrimination&sort=byPopularity&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
- ncphil 4y agoThink about the level of executive stupid you're dealing with when a spinoff continues using the same literal playbook -- with identical terminology and resources (linking to former parent company servers) -- in executing a painfully obvious employment discrimination strategy. Well, either stupid or lazy. Either way, it's a situation that screams out for punitive damages. Here's hoping these cases send at least some of IBM's top management to an early retirement themselves. Going to say it again: feudal power structures are no way to organize 21st century business. Time for people (_especially_ young people) to consider alternative arrangements like worker co-ops. If you're not an owner with a real decision-making vote, you're on the menu for these guys.
- jdasdf 4y agoGood thing there is nothing stopping you from starting up such companies. If they truly are a better way of organizing businesses, they will soon become the norm. If they aren't, the only one harmed is you.
- wizzwizz4 4y ago> If they truly are a better way of organizing businesses, they will soon become the norm. What do you mean by “better”?
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoWorker-coops would be great, but at a minimum I feel like we need, as a profession, a dues-funded professional association which can do things like: Analyze and fight bad IP assignment, non-compete agreements, etc. Hire lawyers to write alternative agreements that employees can suggest as a "standard" alternatives during negotiations. Collect salary data for the profession across all regions and open it in a transparent un-biased way for members to use during negotiation. Provide legal resources for people involved in mass layoffs. Analyze the severance packages and give advice. Help connect people in our profession with good employer / position reviews. E.g. glassdoor without the bullshit, and for professional association members only. And, yeah, staying on topic with this thread: analyze for age etc. discrimination and provide resources to deal with this. (I would stop short of using the "u" word, and stop short of full collective bargaining and strike powers only because those are far more controversial.) I lack the ability to organize such a thing, but would gladly pay a monthly fee into such an organization.
- blastonico 4y agoIBM accused of age discrimination sounds like a home for elderly accused of age discrimination. Absurd.
- FredPret 4y agoSomething to keep in mind when deciding how much of yourself to invest into a corporate job. Every employee is expendable. Get the experience you want ASAP, invest as much of your salary as you can, and then job hop. Cynical? Maybe, but I don't think so. Effective? Definitely. The free market only works if all the people in it continually chase their own best interest.
- GalenErso 4y ago> Get the experience you want ASAP, invest as much of your salary as you can, and then job hop. This works in tech but not necessarily in other white collar fields like finance. In finance, there is an unwritten rule that you are supposed to settle with a firm by ~30-35 and stay there for the rest of your career. Many firms don't hire laterally unless they have no other choice. Professionals like investment bankers and CFAs are recruited straight out of university and groomed to assume leadership positions in the long term.
- FredPret 4y agoVery interesting, I didn't know that. If you're determined to stay in finance, you'll probably have to stick to this model. But for a finance professional, there are many opportunities in other lines of business.
- fakedang 4y ago> In finance, there is an unwritten rule that you are supposed to settle with a firm by ~30-35 and stay there for the rest of your career. Many firms don't hire laterally unless they have no other choice. Eh, I would say it depends... Investment banking and hedge funds, sure, you better join early and stay for the long term. But for private equity and other investment management (notably family office, fund of funds and endowment management), you can still be recruited laterally. I've even seen veteran MD level guys being regularly hired at my previous PE firm. In fact, with leadership at the top not yet retiring at the biggest and mid-tier firms, it's becoming increasingly hard to justify staying around for that promotion. In my personal experience, I have yet to see anyone make anything beyond Principal (the tier below partner/MD) at the large PE shops before their 40s. Most instead go down a notch to mid tier firms, go to an emerging market office, or start their own. Not to mention the number of seats higher up is also on the decline.
- datavirtue 4y agoTypical large American corporation.
- cde-v 4y ago64 year old believes they are the exception to aging.
- qgin 4y agoWould love to hear this line of thinking continued
- dreamcompiler 4y agoI cannot imagine why a new engineer or CS grad would want to go to work for IBM. Their reputation is that of a company that was great before you were born but forgot how to innovate long ago, except for a brief foray into AI that made them famous on a game show but was useless for everything else. Then they bought a Linux company but it's been subjected to the same capricious layoffs as the rest of the company so there's no job security. Most of their revenue seems to come from sending C-grade "consultants" to other big low-tech businesses to keep their computers running, which makes the customer's CIO happy but screws up the computers for everybody who actually works there. I don't get it.
- quadrifoliate 4y ago> I cannot imagine why a new engineer or CS grad would want to go to work for IBM. I might have submitted a resume to IBM back in the day, when you still used paper ones at college career fairs (maybe you still do?). In retrospect, I'm glad I never heard back from them; but people need money to pay off bills and loans, and so did I. It had nothing to do with me sharing IBM's vision or strategy for "innovation" in any way.
- ryandrake 4y agoYea, If you are actually choosing where you work, you are one of the lucky few. Probably 99% of us don’t get a dozen offers to choose our passion from when job hunting. We get one offer after a lot of searching and take it because we like to have a roof over our heads. Sure, we vaguely “choose” where we work by deciding where to send our resumes, but a vanishingly small number wake up and say “my passion is to work at Apple” and then walk through the front door.
- somenameforme 4y agoWhile this is somewhat dated knowledge, I expect it carries over at least somewhat. IBM recruited hyper-aggressively at my university for internships. And at the internship you had minimal obligations and a quite comfortable salary which carried over into full-time employment. Why they were grabbing every warm body just to have them sit around is probably just the left hand not knowing what the right was doing, but it created a pretty nice opportunity for people whose main motivation was freedom. Of course I expect those departments/divisions may well have eventually been "slimmed down", so everything comes full circle.
- _8j50 4y agoI hear/see this type if stuff but what are you supposed to do if you're not litiguous? Companies calculate cost and take risk aware decisions like this with no ethics or moralit y considered. It's like they corner people and expect them not to fight back or to accept what little fighting back they do. I feel like to avoid extreme measures, individuals should be sued ar least instead of companies. I wanna see a lineup of low level and executive managers alike all on the hook personally for 10s of millions of dollars with no financial assistance from the company. I want to see HR, legal and direcr manager of this lady owing her 10mil+. You can fine IBM $10B and they'll just add it to their risk calculation over time. It is individuals that make these decisions, are they really protected from a civil suit?
- theGnuMe 4y agoThis country is literally run by lawyers so litigation is basically how you move forward. All of these systems are setup by lawyers to generate income for lawyers.
- jossclimb 4y agoI don't think its right, but I understand their view of why they perhaps wanted to do it. I had contact with quite few folks from IBM when I was at Red Hat and met Distinguished Engineers and Fellows and all they seemed to do was make slides and go on meetings. Literally powerpoint would be used for everything, Architecture? do it in powerpoint? Documentation, do it in powerpoint. Do it in powerpoint, and then invite lots of people to a meeting to share your slides, get as many people on the meeting as you can. These would be endless meetings scheduled into eternity, where the goal of the meeting was 'alignment', the same people going around and around not really getting much done, apart from agreeing on some things, and disagreeing on others. I stopped turning up, as it was a waste of time, so it was 'escalated' to my boss 'why is jossclimb' not coming to our alignment meetings?!?' They were also clueless about how to deal with us. Had folks 'escalate' as we would not agree to something that first required it be accepted upstream in a community. Would have to say to them 'my word is not worth much, we need to get consensus in the community', this was read as us being difficult and not following some VPs wants to the letter. "This is very important to Arvind" I will get shit for saying this, but half of them could disappear into the ether and you would not notice anything (apart from SWEs having more time outside of perpetual meetings around powerpoint to put their heads down and build some software).
- dangwhy 4y agoso what you are saying is that i need to get really good at powerpoint presentations if i need to get anywhere in my career.
- clnq 4y agoThat might be an IBM-specific quirk, but to get C-suite roles in large tech companies, one definitely needs to re-specialise from SWE/SDE roles to sales. All deep technical knowledge is not necessary for those roles (it's a nice-to-have).
- lisasays 4y agoAll they seemed to do was make slides and go on meetings ... They were also clueless about how to deal with us ... Endless meetings scheduled into eternity ... the same people going around and around not really getting much done So you're saying that on the basis of the above, you "understand" IBM's point of view that the way to fix this was to start firing the older workers? Because that's, like, obviously the root cause of this malaise, right?
- maerF0x0 4y agoPeople reject claims of ageism in tech for lack of evidence, and when the evidence comes around they no true scotsman the evidence. Ageism is real in our space. Older people are not slow, out of touch, or overly grumpy (to counter some common cliches). Young people please wise up because I know you feel exceptionalism, but in truth you will gain a competitive advantage by leveraging the experience of older people (even if you think the experience irrelevant). And one day you will also be old, do unto others etc.
- SheinhardtWigCo 4y agoThere is no evidence of age discrimination mentioned in the article. > The complaint asserts that not only is Kyndryl using IBM terminology like "Resource Action," but it is providing affected employees with the same information resources to do so, right down to the letter. Unless I’m missing something, the argument here seems to be: IBM discriminated against older employees during layoffs, and the IBM spinoff company hasn’t changed their layoff terminology or resources, therefore they must still be discriminating against older employees. Not a lawyer, but it sounds like they have nothing substantive to work with here.
- maerF0x0 4y agoPrecedent was set that the past behavior is ageism. New company is repeating the precedented past behavior. Seems obvious to me?
- trashface 4y agoI suspect there will be a lot more attention to ageism in about 10 years when the current of cohort of tech workers starts getting replaced by younger new college grads. Right now the population affected by ageism is just not big enough. It mostly affects Gen-X, which isn't that big and didn't have that much tech presence in the first place, most went into more traditional fields. When it starts to hit the mid-millenials, it will be too big to ignore.
- YetAnotherNick 4y agoWouldn't it solved by market automatically very easily. Let's say older people are paid less or discriminated in some way for the same skill. Then the company which employs them are at financial advantage on average leading to more demand till return on investment becomes same for both old and young employees.
- petercooper 4y agoInteresting this came up around the same time as this story also about IBM getting sued for discrimination but under very different circumstances: https://www.neowin.net/news/inactive-ibm-employee-who-hasnt-worked-since-2008-sued-company-after-getting-no-pay-rise/ https://www.neowin.net/news/inactive-ibm-employee-who-hasnt-... .. he's been off sick for 14 years and is suing IBM to get similar pay increases as other employees.
- 2b3a51 4y agoUK: The employee described himself as 'medically retired' and has been on 75% pay since 2008 under the terms of an IBM health plan. The arrangement will finish when the employee reaches 65. I'm sort of wondering if his pension contributions are based on 75% or 100% of pay scale. This kind of arrangement is not by any means normal in UK, and I wonder if the plan is still available to new employees. Most companies and public sector employers have a sickness policy that pays full wages for some months then declines steadily until employment is terminated, around a year in the case of my former employer.
- nytesky 4y agoAs an executive, I wonder if she was aware of the Dinobabies policy? https://www.nytimes.com/2022/02/12/business/economy/ibm-age-discrimination.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/02/12/business/economy/ibm-age-...
- nerdyadventurer 4y agoWhile not directly related to the question, I wonder how things for universities for mature students, doing post grads? while there is non discriminator policies how they are in practice?