3 ms·
> “Alice is not born in Germany. Is Alice born in Hamburg?” "I don't know" is the right answer. There are over 20 towns named Hamburg around the world, many of
by kazinator 4y ago
> “Alice is not born in Germany. Is Alice born in Hamburg?”
"I don't know" is the right answer. There are over 20 towns named Hamburg around the world, many of them in the USA.
However, GPT4 is really struggling with this even if you assure it that by Hamburg, we mean the original one in Germany.
GPT4 gets it if you explain that this is a logic problem, and not a query about some actual person named Alice, and if you put all the relevant info into a single prompt.
But event then, if you use the successful prompt in a completely new chat, GPT4 is lost at sea:
Human: Assume that Hamburg is a town in Germany. Alice was not born in Germany. Was she born in Hamburg? This is a logic problem, nothing more; do not think about any famous people named Alice in connection with Hamburg.
GPT4: The answer to this question cannot be determined from the provided context. While it is clear that Hamburg is a town in Germany and that Alice was not born in Germany, there is no information given about where Alice was actually born. Therefore, it is impossible to say whether or not Alice was born in Hamburg.
Human: Please try harder. The answer can be entirely determined; this is purely a logic problem. We do not require information about where Alice was born; knowing that Alice was not born in Germany suffices.
GPT4: Based on the information provided in the context, we can answer the question. Alice was not born in Germany, which means she was not born in Hamburg. Therefore, Alice was not born in Hamburg. It is important to note that the answer to this question is purely based on logic. The context provides no additional information about Alice or any famous people named Alice.
After this, it was a real struggle to get GPT4 to identify the logically redudant sentence, "Therefore, Alice was not born in Hamburg.". Even after I narrowed it down to being one of those two sentences, it insisted that the second sentence is useful because it summarizes what was concluded in the deductive sentence before it. I brow-beat it into admitting that it's entirely redundant, like "X, therefore X".
- usaar333 4y agohmm, worked here: > No, Alice was not born in Hamburg. If Hamburg is a town in Germany, and Alice was not born in Germany, then it logically follows that Alice was not born in Hamburg.
- blazespin 4y agoGPT4 struggles with things for sure, but this isn't one of them. You're just projecting what you think should be the right answer. If it worries you that much, try adding "Provide alternative responses to this question. Each response should try to answer using a different approach to solving the problem." to your prompts. If you want an example of something GPT4 has a hard time with, try this: there is no 'e' in the color red, right? Yes, that is correct. The word "red" does not contain the letter 'e'.
- kazinator 4y agoI don't see what you're talking about. In this situation, there's exactly one correct answer. There's no projecting or other psychobabble involved.