28 ms·
The discussion that has begun in this thread suggests that the Wikibooks chapter submitted here could use some more work. (Its last revision was a 9 October 201
by tokenadult 15y ago
The discussion that has begun in this thread suggests that the Wikibooks chapter submitted here could use some more work. (Its last revision was a 9 October 2011 reversion of I.P. edits to restore a version from 22 May 2011.) Evidently, not every reader of Hacker News is convinced that infinity is not a number, despite several websites by mathematically learned people who say exactly that,
http://scienceblogs.com/goodmath/2008/10/infinity_is_not_a_number.php http://scienceblogs.com/goodmath/2008/10/infinity_is_not_a_n...
http://nrich.maths.org/2756 http://nrich.maths.org/2756
so equally evidently, some readers here are not convinced that there is a rationale for drawing a distinction between infinity and numbers. Does it help to take a look at a discussion of "not a number" concepts
http://scienceblogs.com/goodmath/2006/12/nullity_the_nonsense_number_1.php http://scienceblogs.com/goodmath/2006/12/nullity_the_nonsens...
as they are implemented in computer science? What I see here, from my view as an educator in primary mathematics (in a program in which I can define "primary" to include topics like Hilbert's Hotel), is that some readers here have had educational experiences in which they "remember" seeing infinity treated as a number. The classic case, which prompts the Wikibooks chapter, is taking the limit of a rational quantity as the denominator approaches zero. This appears (based on previous HN discussion
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=728026 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=728026
from more than two years ago) to suggest that physical quantities can be divided by zero with a quotient that becomes infinity. Perhaps this is an example of how an engineering calculus course isn't always interpreted by learners quite the way it was presented by teachers. (I presume all but the tiniest number of teachers of engineering calculus would agree that infinity is not a number, and that no one can divide any number by zero.)
What would be a good way to clarify the point so that people are communicating with one another well as they speak about infinity and about what numbers are?
AFTER EDIT: impendia's kind top-level comment here
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3592101 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3592101
has sent me looking at a Wikipedia article, the talk page of which leads to a WolframMathWorld article,
http://mathworld.wolfram.com/AffinelyExtendedRealNumbers.html http://mathworld.wolfram.com/AffinelyExtendedRealNumbers.htm...
and there is a discussion of the affinely extended real numbers. Does the limit example in the submitted Wikibooks chapter fit the characteristics of that number system fully?
- yequalsx 15y agoWe have to define what is meant by "infinity". Do you mean the infinity symbol one encounters in calculus with regard to limits? Do you mean infinite cardinal number? Infinite ordinal numbers? Do you mean the symbols added to the reals in order to compactify the set (extended real numbers)? Some other concept? Once that gets settled then we have to define what is meant by a number. I suggest that the most broad, reasonable definition of this concept would be elements of a ring. There should be some algebraic structure that is broad but not too broad. If we use such a definition then the various concepts of infinity mentioned above are not numbers since they are not elements of a ring. The limit example in the Wikibooks article is merely a shorthand notation and isn't a number. It's mostly to be suggestive and make things a bit easier to comprehend. It's not intended that a person think of it as a number.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- nandemo 15y ago(Check your link to the WolframMathWorld article) > Evidently, not every reader of Hacker News is convinced that infinity is not a number, despite several websites by mathematically learned people who say exactly that Like impendia said, it depends on the context. To give a simpler example: at elementary school I was told that I couldn't write "2 - 3". Essentially my teacher was saying that numbers less than zero did not exist! She wasn't lying to me. She was telling me that we were working with natural numbers only, and that our operation "-" was supposed to be closed on the natural numbers. In the context of calculus, infinity is not a number. lim(n->c) foo = ∞ is just another way of saying that "foo does not converge as n goes to c". But in realm of surreal numbers (or combinatorial game theory), infinities are first-class numbers. You can add them and subtract them alright! Besides, in that realm ω + 1 is not the same as ω. It is greater than ω, as expected. I can even show you a children's game -- that is, we can teach kids how to play it without ever uttering the words sets and cardinals -- that has positions with such values.