4 ms·
The article suggests that "Some suggest that these flashes could be messages from alien civilizations possessing technology far more advanced than ours." but th
by lacker 3y ago
The article suggests that "Some suggest that these flashes could be messages from alien civilizations possessing technology far more advanced than ours." but that is a pretty fringe view among astronomers. FRBs are broadband signals with an incredible amount of energy. For intentionally sending a signal, narrowband signals are far more efficient. It's hard to imagine why an alien civilization would send a signal this way.
It's like the difference between a forest fire and a laser. When you see a huge blobby irregular burst of energy from far away, it's a "forest fire", it's something natural, not an intentional signal.
In the cases we understand well, these huge bursts of unfocused energy are generally caused by large-scale astronomical events, like black holes smashing into each other or a neutron star spinning around. So even though we don't understand the specific mechanism behind these FRBs, it's much more likely to be something like that than an alien signal.
- nomel 3y ago> It's hard to imagine why an alien civilization would send a signal this way. Minimum requirements? If a civilization could only receive narrowband signals, then it's probably a bit early, and maybe even dangerous, for contact.
- hammyhavoc 3y agoYou're thinking too hard. First, always check the byline. Who wrote it? They're not actually named here. The "Author" is the site brand. The bio of the "Author" is "Study Finds sets out to find new research that speaks to mass audiences — without all the scientific jargon. Study Finds has been writing and publishing articles since 2016.". So, pop science clickbait drivel. Have you heard of Study Finds before?