5 ms·
Are you selling that software in the EU or are you merely making it available? Because there an exception for free and open source software and the EU can't reg
by jeroenhd 4y ago
Are you selling that software in the EU or are you merely making it available? Because there an exception for free and open source software and the EU can't regulate the business you do outside of the EU.
If you're selling support licenses to the EU for your open source software then you're on the hook for patching them, but you'd probably already be for other reasons.
- kevincox 4y agoIn my case I am not selling, only making it available. If selling I am happy to consider their needs and my legal obligations (for the right price). But as the grandparent states we are talking about just making free software available: > it hinges on whether offering open source software on GitHub is considered a product in the sense of the law.
- jeroenhd 4y agoFrom the context of the rest of the law it seems pretty obvious to me that just making your code available doesn't turn it into a product. I don't know why people assume it does. I assume Github and friends are much more concerned with being on the hook for selling these products (i.e. through Copilot). Github does sell you software that happens to make open source code available, and that seems like a much more vague situation.
- unity1001 4y ago> Are you selling that software in the EU or are you merely making it available? What difference does it make... If small developers and software businesses risk thousands of euros of fines, decided arbitrarily by the courts based on civil minimum and maximum limits, open source and small software in the Eu will die and the only ones to benefit from this will be the larger software companies that can afford the fines - who will be scooping up all the users of these open source projects and small developers - like the German software businesses who back the current German government and the German contingent in Euparl. Note how the draft is designed to exclude the software that these major software companies are mooching off of - like Linux. Its basically exclude what you benefit from, kill who eat into your profit margins and be happy - total American corporate style legislation...