7 ms·
How to survive a car crash
- antisthenes 4y agoThis hits a little too close to home. All the symptoms and thoughts racing through your head during the first 6 month recovery period. I wish her the best of luck going forward. TBI is something that changes you forever, and not necessarily for the better. If you know someone with TBI - please be patient with them and give them a little bit more leeway than you would a normal person. We're a little slow and we can't really do much about it.
- Mortiffer 4y agoInteresting writing style
- clnq 4y agoMany people are seriously afraid of driving in snow and even recommend things like never driving in it. I come from a snowy region and have never lost control of my car unintentionally for more than a second in snow. I used to drive over a hundred thousand miles in snow each year for about one decade in my life. Sometimes the car slips a bit when doing something sudden but it’s quickly resolved by not doing the thing (sudden braking, sudden turning, sudden acceleration, and so on). With proper tyres and the roads being salted, and aside from needing to be a bit less sudden about movements, I have never felt more at risk in the snow than out of it. What is there to be afraid of? Are these people driving with Summer tyres or is there some other reason they seem to find snow so problematic? Perhaps the roads are not salted in the US? Are studded tyres allowed? Is it just that some regions like the US generally do very poorly with driving safety and the “snow effect” is more visible? https://www.lifeinnorway.net/norway-has-worlds-safest-roads/ https://www.lifeinnorway.net/norway-has-worlds-safest-roads/ says, for example, that only 2 fatal crashes happen a year in Norway due to phone distractions. I think this is higher in the US? The author says there are many accidents after heavy snowfalls, but this is not observably the case in most northern European countries that have about an equal number of snow and non-snow days a year. There may be more accidents in snow, but you cannot observe the increase naturally. Genuinely hoping to understand. Never experienced anything like what some people who are mortified of driving in the snow describe.
- jorlow 4y agoEven in places that get a healthy amount of snow (e.g. in the Midwest of USA), many don't have snow tires -- it's a cost and inconvenience they try to avoid.
- clnq 4y agoWow, that is really amazing.
- razeh 4y agoI live in a walkable inner ring Chicago suburb, and commute to work by bike or the El. Snow cleanup is excellent in our suburb, and we can get to things we want to drive to in bad weather on roads where the speed limit is never over 25 mph. We just don’t need winter tires.
- clnq 4y agoVery interesting how different the approach is. Many European countries mandate Winter tyres for a period each year, even if they do not get much snow - https://www.uniroyal-tyres.com/car/tyre-guide/winter-care/winter-tyres-mandatory https://www.uniroyal-tyres.com/car/tyre-guide/winter-care/wi.... The mindset is more that if there could be snow, drivers must use Winter tyres, even when road clean-up and salting are used. Many countries here that do not mandate Winter tyres for the whole season still mandate tyres appropriate for driving conditions, which reads a lot like a requirement to use Winter, studded, or chained tyres in snow. Most countries like that also recommend Winter tyres. It's a very different approach from having many people not use Winter tyres in snow. I think this explains the fear of driving in snow to me. I would be very concerned if I had to drive in snow with Summer tyres as well.
- mrep 4y agoWhy? I have all season tires and they work fine enough when it does snow but I also don’t drive much. When I looked into getting winter tires, I saw they generally last 60,000 miles or 6 years whatever comes first and since I only drive like 5,000 miles a year, that means I’d have to replace 2 sets of tires every 6 years instead of 1. If I drove 20,000 miles a year though I’d definitely get them.
- sn41 4y agoI'm from South India, and at some point, lived in the midwest for about 10 years. I used to snigger at the big pickups and cars. Until one day, I was driving through a snowstorm. (It was not my first, but this was a beast.) Unlike my usual Honda, I was driving a rented Dodge Charger. The snow was wet, and slippery, and I was driving along a state highway in Wisconsin. The car went into a skid, years of playing racing games triggered my instinct to go into the skid rather than out of it, and avoid braking. The car smoothly came back to the middle of the lane. The highway was empty for miles around, and even state troopers were out for that storm. I am pretty sure that if it had not been a heavy low car like the Charger, I'd have been stranded and lonely in a snowstorm for hours on a cold night.
- tinco 4y agoVouched for your comment, the British spelling of the American "snicker" will get your comment marked as spam.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nobody9999 4y ago>Vouched for your comment, the British spelling of the American "snicker" will get your comment marked as spam. Is that a consequence of the Scunthorpe Problem[0][1]? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scunthorpe_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scunthorpe_problem [1] If it is, perhaps this comment will be marked as spam as well?
- NoZebra120vClip 4y agoYes. I got in trouble in a place well-known for highly literate participants when I correctly used the phrase "putative woman" to describe someone in the news. In fact, one them went as far to posit that since I knew Spanish, I should be well-aware of the derogatory nature of that adjective in English usage! I was rather shocked at the unironic chastisement I received at that time!
- 4y ago
- jbandela1 4y agoThe article left out the single most important advice: wear a seatbelt. I did my neurosurgery training at a fairly busy Level 1 Trauma Center (which treats the most severe trauma) and treated a lot of people involved in car crashes. Seatbelt use made a huge difference. There could be two people in the same car, and the person wearing the seatbelt was evaluated and released and the person not wearing the seatbelt was taken to the operating room or intensive care unit. Seatbelts keep you in position to allow the car to take the brunt of the forces instead of your body. Please, always wear a seatbelt and make sure everyone riding with you wears a seatbelt.
- NoZebra120vClip 4y agoSince the pandemic began, I've been riding a significant amount in ride-shares and taxis. One universal trait of all drivers is that they will immediately punch it as soon as you close your door. Therefore, it's incumbent on me to work on figuring out my seatbelt and attaching it before closing my door, otherwise I will be struggling with it under pressure. Of course, I'm still under pressure, because the driver is extremely eager for me to close that door already, what the hell is taking me so long? In the taxi service I use, all cars are of the same fleet, so it's not difficult to figure out the seat belt, as long as it's in working order. The ride-share drivers, since these are personal cars, often have some sort of stupid obstruction that lies across the seatbelt buckles and prevents riders from finding them. I don't know why it's so unimportant for ride services that they don't care whether riders are safely strapped in. My parents had a strict policy: "the brakes can't come off until everyone's buckled in." This, to me, is pragmatic and caring advice.
- thdespou 4y agoAnd if possible wear seatbelts in busses as well.
- jamesbfb 4y agoI live in Australia (a country where wearing a seatbelt is instilled in us pretty much since birth, with very harsh penalties for non-compliance) however seatbelts are relatively non-existent in buses, and I have this vague memory that there was a reason for this?
- californiadreem 4y agoI'll write the practical version instead of the urbane rhetorical retrospective. And before I get the metacontrarian responses, yes, these all require certain sacrifices in order to fulfill, including economic advantage or putting precariats in a more economically disadvantaged position. Not everyone can comfortably alter their life to avoid cars. But hey, live by the car, die by the car. 0. Don't have a car crash: This might seem like an obvious point but it's worth emphasizing. The first step to safe driving is the mindset of avoiding any kind of accident. Always strive to maintain awareness of your surroundings and anticipate potential hazards; when these hazards create a probable environment of accidents, don't drive. 1. Don't drive if you can avoid it: Use public transportation, bike, walk or even carpool whenever possible. The less time you and others spend on the road, the less risk there is of an accident occurring. 2. Shorten the length of your drive if you can help it: This doesn't just apply to distance, but also to time. Try to avoid peak hours when traffic is heavy, but choose routes that minimize your time on the road. 3. Increase the object-level density of your drive when you can't avoid driving: When you're out and about, complete as many tasks in the same area as possible to minimize further need to drive. 4. Leave earlier. It's not a race against the clock unless you make it one: Leaving with plenty of time to spare can help reduce the stress of driving and allow you to drive more safely. You won't feel the need to rush, which can often lead to reckless behavior. 5. Avoid thoroughfares where people act like it's a race: This includes highways, freeways, and other high-speed roads. These can be dangerous, especially for less experienced drivers. Opt for slower, less congested routes when possible. 6. Avoid bad modal neighborhoods: Don't drive in areas, times, or conditions where drivers tend to be more aggressive or careless. These can be certain parts of town, certain highways, certain times of day, or in inclement weather. 7. Double the "safe" following distance: Always maintain a safe distance from the car in front of you. This gives you more time to react if the car in front stops suddenly. The general rule is one car length for every 10 mph; doubling this adds an extra layer of safety. One car length per 10 mph is the minimum time to stop; not the actual time to stop. 8. Focus on driving and driving alone: This means no multi-tasking. Avoid using your phone, eating, or even having intense conversations while driving. Your full attention should be on the road. 9. Obey the speed limit and use all safety devices: Speeding is one of the leading causes of accidents. Always stick to the speed limit, and remember that it's the maximum speed, not the recommended one. Seat belts and airbags save lives. Make sure you're using them correctly and maintaining them. 10. Signal well-before acting: Use your blinkers to signal your intentions to other drivers. Whether you're changing lanes or turning, signaling gives others time to react and adjust their driving accordingly. It's not a formality. Signaling is not a carte blanche-- you must always ensure it's safe to make the move before you actually do so.
- carapace 4y agoI just want to take a moment to remind everybody just how insane car travel is as a mode of transportation. Sure, it's convenient, but at what cost!? Air pollution, tire particle pollution, covering the Earth with asphalt, etc. Also, and this is gruesome so brace yourself, car travel causes incredible amounts of human suffering. Car collisions cause something like 40,000 fatalities per year just in the USA. In fact, more Americans have died in car crashes than in all the wars we've fought. I call it the "Mayhem Lottery". Anyone can play, little kids, old people, pregnant women, everybody. And the tickets cost nothing, all you have to do is be near a street. (Sometimes cars will even crash into buildings. People have been killed by cars while sitting in their own homes watching TV!) Now the weird, bizarre thing about this state of affairs is that it is the result of a successful mass-marketing campaign! When cars were first introduced people complained of reckless drivers ("Speed Demons"), the car companies and the government got together and created a deliberate plan to change public attitude (about being run down in the street by car drivers), they actually coined the term "jaywalker" to describe people using the street in the traditional fashion (pedestrians.) It sounds nuts, because it is, yet it really happened: cf. "The Real Reason Jaywalking Is A Crime" (Adam Ruins Everything) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vxopfjXkArM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vxopfjXkArM - - - - Edit to add: You can see the transition period in the "a Trip down Market Street" film from San Francisco, April 14, 1906, just before the Great Earthquake. The source of the problem is clear: cars accelerate much faster than horses. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VO_1AdYRGW8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VO_1AdYRGW8
- scyclow 4y agoI like how none of the commenters here actually read the article, and they're all talking about literally surviving a car crash -- not how to emotionally survive the aftermath of one.
- soared 4y ago[flagged]
- clnq 4y agoI read it. The most I can do about this is drive safely. The perspective of the aftermath is interesting, but not very relevant to me. So I think about what’s relevant. Maybe to someone, recovering from brain injury is relevant. They will think about that. There’s nothing wrong with focusing on what’s relevant to you in a writing.
- euroderf 4y agoThe first snow in DC is always fun. All the people who have moved to DC from snowless parts of the country drive unsafely and lots of them end up in the ditch.
- carapace 4y agoIt snows once, maybe twice, in Seattle every Winter, and it's like no one's ever seen the stuff before.
- tikkun 4y agoRelated to the title, but not the content of the article - some links I've collected related to staying alive and healthy: Nice guide from Lesswrong with some car safety tips. https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/7XbcDaeigMaxW43EB/how-to-avoid-dying-in-a-car-crash https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/7XbcDaeigMaxW43EB/how-to-avo... Guide to health. https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/7nH7R9eqYWSPvF4Qm/immortality-a-practical-guide https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/7nH7R9eqYWSPvF4Qm/immortalit... Another guide to health. https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/PhXENjdXiHhsWGfQo/lifestyle-interventions-to-increase-longevity https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/PhXENjdXiHhsWGfQo/lifestyle-... Poisoning. https://news.arizona.edu/story/poisoning-the-no-1-cause-of-unintentional-death-in-the-u-s https://news.arizona.edu/story/poisoning-the-no-1-cause-of-u... Medical error. Always double check the medications you get prescribed, ask to read the name of any injections or IVs you're given before you're given them. A google doc from me related to environmental toxins. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34642916 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34642916 Incredible data exploration tool from CDC, for non-fatal injuries. https://wisqars.cdc.gov/data/non-fatal/home https://wisqars.cdc.gov/data/non-fatal/home Another incredible data exploration tool from CDC, this one is for fatal. https://wisqars.cdc.gov/data/explore-data/home https://wisqars.cdc.gov/data/explore-data/home Great summary images on causes from CDC. https://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/LeadingCauses_images.html https://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/LeadingCauses_images.html
- FredPret 4y agoDrive slow. I survived a bad one. I got out with only a scratch due to extreme luck. If I went 5 km/h faster, I'd be dead. If I went 15 slower, there would have been no accident. The whole thing wasn't even my fault. People where I'm from used to be all macho and say "speed doesn't kill, bad driving kills". Don't do it. Smart drivers drive slow, unless they're on a racetrack and everyone's going the same way.
- throwaway426079 4y agoIf I went 15 slower, there would have been no accident. The whole thing wasn't even my fault. This seems contradictory. Do you mean the other driver was more at fault?
- FredPret 4y agoI was driving the speed limit, and the other driver didn't follow the rules. If I drove slower, I could have made allowances for the errors of others. Defensive driving is the best way.
- nathannecro 4y agoProbably in the sense that at a slower speed, op would have been able to avoid the bad driving from the other driver. Assuming that OP was driving at 60kph originally, a 15kph slower speed equates to a roughly 0.75 extra seconds of reaction time (assuming braking acceleration is roughly 7.5m/s2). Given that an average humans reaction time is somewhere between 0.25-0.5 seconds, that means 15kph speed difference would have allowed OP to react and affect the situation. Even at higher initial speeds, 15kph gives your more than half a second extra time.
- 8bitsrule 4y agoThis is a fine article, full of humanity, insight, strength and high sly humor ... New Yorker-class writing. I could read Anne all day. "the small town in Ohio starts to suffocate you.... whenever you find yourself in a suburb with houses that have washers and dryers or yards or acres and acres of corn fields or a gigantic Walmart, you start to feel a gnawing helplessness in your chest, like an alien is about to rip itself out of you." Move over, Fran Lebowitz!