11 ms·
A myth called the Indian programmer
- Varun06 15y agoHonestly there is some truth, but if you want to be a programmer(not a coder) no company, no person can stop you. I agree that companies like TCS etc. get mainly maintenance work but nobody is forcing you to stay there only, if you don't love a job, don't do that job..
- sidcool 15y agoThis is a painfully accurate article. I can say this as an Indian Coder.
- harichinnan 15y agoMost of the Indian Software Engineers work in Software Maintenance business, production support, database administration, network maintenance etc. They are all challenging jobs. Some companies perform custom software development for large clients, and they perform on par with "in-house" software engineers in US and Europe. Google, Microsoft, Facebook, Zynga and other coll companies also have offices and they hire the best and brightest programmers in India. India does not have a startup culture like US.
- j45 15y agoFirst: The thinking and problem solving required in programming is not taught enough at universities in North America, nor overseas. Second: Being groomed to do specwork is the big problem of most institutions. Third: Many developers thinking they don't need to learn anymore. Or, that they are done learning and ready to pursue a job/career. This is as evident in NA as it is overseas. Constant self-learning and self-development as a programmer is something that simply doesn't happen enough. Overseas, and in North America. Fourth: The cultural differences. Done doesn't always mean done and it's entirely a societal/cultural thing. It's helpful have to define done as 'tested and ready to launch', etc. Fifth: Outsourcers: Paying weekly helps a lot in a land where people get paid monthly, if on time at all.. Sixth: No sense on hating on overseas developers taking jobs. IT's the people paying the bills in NA that decided to take away all those jobs. And I guess they pay the price in the long run for better, or worse. Seventh: Job, let alone career opportunities in India seem to suck. Every job posting gets hundreds, if not thousands of applications. Imagine trying to pick out the quality, let alone trying to stand out. Disclaimer: I've outsourced to India. I've hired developers newly moved to North America from the Indian Subcontinent and had good luck and bad luck, like any employee. I have been told I share some heritage in with the Indian subcontinent a in the past few generations. I'm not an apologist or out to offend. We all can do better and we should all be supporting each other to become the best we can be.
- marshallp 15y agoedit: I was replying to DarkShikari, so adjust accordingly I'd argue whether copying is a bad thing. Copying or getting others to do your work is what great businesspeople and managers do. The system of cheating you describe above might be actually creating a great stream of entrepreneurs/networkers. If they could channel that talent to pfoductive use, like getting 3d printers or robots in their hands, or selling through telephones, it could be a huge resource for everyone. On a related note, everyone disparages Nigerian scammers. Yet these are highly entrepreneurial individuals that western companies should be hiring as salespeople.
- mcl 15y agoThere are very few times I've felt the absence of a downvote button for my profile on HN but this is one. We don't need 4-year professional courses to teach people who are yet to enter the workforce how to cheat. Plagiarism doesn't require boot camps for undergrads to start practicing it as a valued skill, it needs an attitude adjustment to stop them from feeling guilty. It takes very little time to find a source and then rip it off and put your own label on it. But for those who don't derive an odd sense of accomplishment out of it, a continuous barrage of peer pressure does the trick.
- talmand 15y agoJust wow. A great manager does not get others to do their work. They lead or, let's see what's another word I know, "manage" other people doing their own work assigned to them. The system of cheating described can only create a stream of entrepreneurs/networkers who will ultimately have to cheat to attempt to succeed but the real world doesn't support that in the long run. They cannot be a good resource if they don't know how to actually work. I agree, Nigerian scammers would make great salespeople for industries that specialize in stealing from people.
- marshallp 15y agoI think part of the problem is we in the programming/engineering communities have a high notion of doing things right/ethics etc. However, in the real world, where money changes hands and fortunes are made it's the cheaters who get ahead/make things happen. Do you think most successful politicians, used car dealers, industry titans are not cheaters. Did Bill Gates or Steve Jobs ever cheat? (yes, all the time). The question is, who do you want to hire as your salesperson when you're struggling and have to pay rent. Mr. Ethical (cs nerd) or Mr. Cutthroat (nigerian scammer/used car salesman)?
- bdhe 15y agoJust a nitpick on an otherwise largely accurate article. IIT Mumbai and IIT Powai (though commonly used in media) are erroneous ways of referring to IIT Bombay which still retains the old name of the city Mumbai in which it is located. Powai is a suburb of Mumbai around the Powai lake where the IIT Bombay campus is located. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_Institute_of_Technology_Bombay http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_Institute_of_Technology_...
- bjornsing 15y agoOn that same subject, I'd say there are rather few "large programs" that "run into billions of lines" (of code, I presume). By comparison the Linux kernel, one of the largest monolithic "programs" I know of, would have to expand by almost two orders of magnitude to fit into that category. :)
- njloof 15y agoIs this still true? This article is five years old.
- giis 15y agoYes,Its still relevant.This article will be relevant for next 20 years ,unless some thing dramatically changes(like creating world class products) the Indian Software industry.
- luckydev 15y agoLAME article
- nailer 15y agoPersonally I think 'coder' conveys better engineering skill than 'programmer' (though I prefer 'guy who makes web apps' to either). Programmers are often enterprise types, who don't code in their spare time, have a degree but don't learn anymore, and love the hours XML generates. Many Indians-in-India code because their parents want them to be engineers, not because they love coding.
- eropple 15y agoI look at those definitions pretty much exactly in reverse. I cringe when somebody calls themselves a "coder" because my mental image is somebody who just throws it at the wall and stops as soon as it's good enough. (Many "enterprise types" certainly qualify.) "Programmer", to me at least, implies a greater level of methodology--not something that guarantees better code, but probably doesn't hurt. I call myself a software developer, because I don't just write code. I build (develop) software. I hate the term "software engineer", because we're not engineers.
- platz 15y agoThe distinction between developing software and writing code seems a bit weak to me.
- hack_edu 15y agoTo me, developing software defines the entire process of delivering a software product. Looking at it this way, "writing code" is the only non-nebulous aspect a developer is tasked with. Domain knowledge and managing systems are very much part of a developer's role. Anyone abstracted from this is most certainly just a "programmer" or "coder." Real developers do a whole lot more. Writing code is certainly part of it, but so is designing the overall software architecture, using the right library (when it already does a better job that your own "code"), keeping everything stable, and putting out a proper release. Each of these steps, and the dozens of others not mentioned, require one to "write code."
- bonzoesc 15y ago
- laconian 15y agoMeh. I think India makes a lot of great programmers. I've worked with too many good guys (and gals) to know that the country is capable of making talent. But, I think that it also produces a lot of mediocre ones, too, but that might be because programming is perceived as a respectable "default" profession for smart but rudderless people. In the US, those people go into law, or try out medicine, but coding is seen as deeply unsexy. This stigma is unfortunate but I believe it also acts as a filter as well. Of the people that exit CS programs with a degree in hand, perhaps a higher percentage might be of the caliber that goes on to do great impactful things.
- shantanubala 15y agoThere's also a fundamental difference in the way we (at least try) to teach our kids. We "strive" to have kids who are creative, energetic, and capable of critical thinking. We may not succeed, but that's our goal. In India, successfully raising kids is almost always a matter of income. There's just a much greater gap in socio-economic status for most Indian families that "creativity" and "critical thinking" aren't really as useful as a salary. In the US, nobody strives for a job that doesn't require some level of creativity or critical thinking. In India, it doesn't matter to many people, because food on the table is more important.
- jiggy2011 15y agoSo basically they are lower in Maslow's Hierarchy of needs. This leads me to think that the 2nd generation of Indian programmers will be better since they will grow up with a middle class lifestyle.
- geekzgalore 15y agoIt may not be really true. Indians are a "greedy" lot, always looking for ways to improve their lifestyle. So, the 2nd generation Indian programmer will be looking to work lesser than his (or her) parents and make more money.. and the software industry will always have slots for people who just understand instructions and not think.
- DarkShikari 15y agoIndia's college education system is broken, and the statistics bear it out. Comparing it to the United States' -- a system that really isn't so good either -- doesn't even begin to describe how serious the problems are in it. Industry groups complain that 90% of college graduates (75% of college engineering graduates) are completely unemployable. Not merely untrained, but not even worth training. One of the major industry training companies has recently increased their training period to a full 7 months. Plagiarism is endemic and encouraged on every level, from the Dean down, even in graduate schools. Most students write papers by copying off the internet and citing "Google". Many "programming" students assemble programs by begging for "the codez" or otherwise copying "the codez" from existing projects. Professors rarely bat an eye when the entire class turns in the same work. By comparison, in America, plagiarism is looked down upon and stigmatized from as early as the start of elementary school. It's still a major problem, but it's not socially expected in the same way that it's become in India. In this kind of environment, it's not surprising that "coders" are being trained rather than "programmers". Programming is about problem-solving, and it's hard to teach problem-solving in an educational system that revolves largely around copying other peoples' work in place of solving problems. A few of the best students manage to succeed -- after all, even a broken system can't stop some of the smartest and most motivated from succeeding. But even for them, the soul-sucking nature of such a system can hardly be encouraging, and it does no favors for their job prospects -- since being "Indian" carries the stigma of being a product of that broken system, even if you managed to become a great programmer regardless. HN often likes to demonize traditional education, but the most important role of education is not to teach skills, but to teach you to think. That is the purpose of writing a 10-page critical analysis of a theme in a Shakespeare play, or building a toy memory allocator: not because knowing Shakespeare or being able to write malloc is important, but because it teaches students to think and analyze. By plagiarizing papers and programs, students completely miss the point of the exercise -- to learn to think! Indian colleges are by and large failing this primary responsibility of education, and their students suffer as a result. In true cargo cult fashion, they have adopted the trappings of education without understanding the real purpose behind it.
- peter_l_downs 15y agoI believe you, but these are pretty fantastic claims. Source(s)?
- abc_lisper 15y agoMay be it's got something to do with this? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TlrzzeFsMXo&feature=related http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TlrzzeFsMXo&feature=relat...
- srini1234 15y agoa new disturbing trend http://us.classifieds.sulekha.com/business-analyst-proxy-interview-female_services_233995 http://us.classifieds.sulekha.com/business-analyst-proxy-int...
- scatter 15y agoI agree ! There are people exploiting lack of face to face interviews and back ground checks (particularly for contractors) to end up at jobs they aren't qualified for. I don't if this is a recent trend, or if it is already known in the software industry, though.
- goatcurious 15y agoThis is a post from 2007? Its all about the relative scale of numbers. India has a ton of programmers and a trillion ton coders. There is a place for both.
- mouly 15y agoThe projects that are offshored don't require programmer. They require people who can understand and follow instructions.
- prakashk 15y agoI might add another "myth" called "Indian blogger" too in this case. The linked article is a total copy of a news report by Times of India (http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/home/sunday-toi/A-myth-called-the-Indian-programmer/articleshow/1633868.cms http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/home/sunday-toi/A-myth-ca...). Couldn't the blogger add a measly line of attribution? Ok. Back to the topic.
- vonuebelgarten 15y agoOr, maybe the newspaper copied the blogger? If Indian plagiarism exist reached the journalism too... :)
- apu 15y agoThe dates seem to suggest otherwise: the TOI article is from February 2007, the blog post from April 2007.
- droithomme 15y agoThis really is an interesting case of plagiarism since there are multiple versions of this article by different authors, each who has slightly changed the other. February 17, 2007. Author: timesofindia staff? http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/home/sunday-toi/A-myth-called-the-Indian-programmer/articleshow/1633868.cms http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/home/sunday-toi/A-myth-ca... February 18, 2007. Author: Brajeshwar (who does attribute "an article" in Times of India as "inspired by", but without a specific link) http://brajeshwar.com/2007/are-you-a-programmer-or-a-coder/ http://brajeshwar.com/2007/are-you-a-programmer-or-a-coder/ April 5, 2007. Author: Avinash Singh http://avinashsingh.wordpress.com/2007/04/05/a-myth-called-the-indian-programmer/ http://avinashsingh.wordpress.com/2007/04/05/a-myth-called-t... 2010. Author: Mohamed Sardhar http://www.citehr.com/26128-myth-called-indian-programmer.html http://www.citehr.com/26128-myth-called-indian-programmer.ht... (exact copy of all 3 pages of the Times of India article, with no attribution to original, just a new byline added)
- dasil003 15y agoFascinating, this seems to speak directly to DarkShikari's point. It definitely reads like a mishmash of different people's thoughts.
- prtamil 15y agoWould someone Please kill Indian MBA degree(IIM (These clowns take freshers for Managing Company wtf)). These guys still live in industrial Age. And being an Indian i can tell most of them are still in colonial age (Indian Administrative Service Wannabe which is created to create clerks (now a days nobody knows what clerk is) for East India Trading Company)thinking industrial age is new century thought or something. After 40 years of software Evolution such as Internet, Social Network is creating Revolutions (Arab Spring) and OpenSource Software is running in Mars etc.. these guys still haven't got clue about what is Software and How to Create it. And M.B.A degree is killing common sense in these people and they are effectively making dinosaurs such as media company executives who's riding Titanic and thinking themselves as Titans. As per Calling Programmers Coders please don't listen to these clowns. They live in way past and accessing future with knowledge created by East India Trading company(before 1857). As per my knowledge and my experience The Best way to predict future is by creating it. So Please Get yourself openSource Unix Box. Learn PHP,JavaScript,C++,CommonLisp,Python, Bash etc.. Create Something futuristic such as TheMatrix etc... That way we can control future. Please please don't listen to These TCS/Wipro/Infosys Solution Architect's limited knowledge. And Fellow Indian Engineers please don't ask any advice from these clowns. If anybody is offering advice ask github Link before listening to them. Man is Tool Making Animal. Make Innovative Tools and make a better future. Evolution will take care Rest.. Sorry for the ranting I can't stand some MBA wannabe calling me Coder. I really want to be called as a Programmer. FYI (http://programming-motherfucker.com/ http://programming-motherfucker.com/)
- ramanujan 15y agoIndia is just an extremely high-variance country. It has produced people like Google's Amit Singhal (Search Quality), Sanjay Ghemawat (MapReduce), Vic Gundotra (Google+), Sundar Pichai (Chrome), and Krishna Bharat (Google News). And it has also produced many people who aren't worthy of the title coder, let alone engineer. Rather than wringing one's hands, just ask programming questions in interviews and let the code do the talking rather than the nationality.
- sanswork 15y agoI didn't read the article as saying that the nationality is what matters so much as the corporate system and possibly the education system pushing to develop "coders" which industry there wants instead of "programmers". All of the people you listed above(except possibly Vic Gundotra) moved to US universities to continue their studies.
- nbakshi 15y ago4 out of the 5 you mentioned are from IITs. The education quality of IITs vs other institutions matters a lot in India.
- ruchi 15y agoYou are getting it in the reverse order. People who make it to IITs are driven; they do well in every field not just IT. Most Indian coders are in it just for the money, they hardly have concept of basic business or functional concept to do better and the sad part is they don't want to learn. You need to love what you do excel.
- statictype 15y agoAs someone who went to IIT, I kind of disagree. Most of the good things I got out of college there had little to do with the quality of the education and more to do with being surrounded by other smart, hard working people who managed to get in.
- yzhengyu 15y agoActually, outside of software startups, several software houses I can think of and the established tech giants, what has been described here is pretty much the rest of the world. I guess to use something that I saw on HN the other day, it's the dichotomy of the creative film crew versus the sterile manufacturing line. Note that business people can't help themselves. After all, this is what business school has taught them in how to become managers. The keyword is "manager". Note that it does not mean leadership. We are sorely lacking in leaders. At every level.
- jgmmo 15y agoFunny that this article makes it onto the front page this week , because I just so happen to be in Bangalore India right at this moment on a business trip training malware researchers we have here. I can't speak to India's education system, but what I can say is the team I'm working with here - even though while earning a fraction of what their US companions earn - are doing a great job and have a lot of excitement and enthusiasm for their work. Bangalore India really isn't that bad. I have had a great trip here, and I've been very impressed with the professionalism and level of intelligence of everyone I've met. If anyone else gets a chance to visit - I highly recommend you do so! You will not regret! Just get your shots before coming over, and make sure to bring Cipro/Azithromyacin just in case!
- keypusher 15y agoIn my experience working with contractors from India, it was not excitement and enthusiasm which was lacking. It was the quality of the end product.
- sho_hn 15y agoI'm somewhat nervous about posting this due to its somewhat sensitive nature, but I'd like to share my own experiences with Indian programming students, and perhaps some of you who are more familiar with the education system in the country could provide some background info for me. As in, the following is definitely not meant to be any sort of judgement, because I'm relatively clueless and there is significant selection bias to the data my perspective affords. I'm involved with programming mentoring program in a large open source community, KDE. A significant percentage of the mentoring requests I receive, I'd say about half of them, are by Indian CS students, often in their second or third year of college education. On average, they share the following attributes: * They're nice and polite people, and, a sometimes significant language barrier aside, nice to work with. * Unfortunately, their education level as pertaining to the programming practice tends to be far below that of Western students who have spent a similar amount of time in CS college education. They've had, say, C++ classes, but their understanding even of OOP basics tends to be lacking, not to mention groking something like an event loop. This is not necessarily a fatal problem considering that receiving programming mentoring is the point of the mentoring program, but we don't quite have the resources to make up for it all -- the idea is more to focus on helping with KDE specifics than general programming. * Many of them seem to have been explicitly encouraged to participate in international open source projects by their institution. Some appear to do it in order to receive credit from the institution. * Most of them expect to be told what to work on, and there is a distinct edge of subservience to their communication style with us that you don't see from non-Indian mentees. Often, the first step is to explain how the nature of our community really allows them to choose to work on what they find interesting, or where they perceive a project could need their help the most after making social contact with the developer and user communities and observing the existing pain points. Unfortunately, no matter how gently this is laid out, this is also the step after which we never hear back from many of them: The agency to self-select and self-motivate seems to be lacking. Of course, for completeness' sake I should also mention that there definitely are exceptions. I've also mentored Indian CS students who are exceedingly bright and who have later become valuable contributors in the community. Our first conference in India was also a great success: http://dot.kde.org/2011/03/10/confkdein-opens-bengaluru http://dot.kde.org/2011/03/10/confkdein-opens-bengaluru and http://dot.kde.org/2011/03/12/confkdein-talks-close-kde-legend-sirtaj http://dot.kde.org/2011/03/12/confkdein-talks-close-kde-lege...
- jgw 15y agoI think this is the natural result of "programming" or "IT" being perceived as a comparatively lucrative career. I believe it happened in North America, too, just not quite to the same degree. I first had access to a computer (an Osborne 1) in 1983, at the age of 8. I think it was inevitable from that point that I'd become an electrical engineer or computer scientist. As luck would have it, it turned out to be a reasonably lucrative career choice, but monetary considerations literally never figured into my choice of university program. I had no idea how much an engineer made. I think that most of my contemporaries were similarly-minded. Entering University in 1993, I had never had an email address, and it wasn't until second year that I first saw NCSA Mosaic and this thing walled the World Wide Web. While I was in university, a revolution quietly, but incredibly rapidly, took place. By the time I graduated in 1998, I was using the web to book travel, buy stuff in online auctions, and my mum was handy at email and finding things on the web. In my department, a huge shift took place in the incoming demographics - the new frosh were there because Computer Engineering was the hot program to be in. The Faculty halved the Electrical class and doubled the Comp class, and it was noticeable, even years later, when this younger blood graduated and was now in the industry, that many were of a very different mindset to my peers. Far fewer had followed a genuine passion and fascination with computers, and had pursued it for what seemed to be far more pragmatic and material reasons. As one acolyte put it, to my barely-contained amusement, "I'm in software engineering! Bling Bling!" I mean no disrespect to younger generations. I recognize that there are many fine folks here much younger than those I describe who are as passionate about computer science and engineering as I am, if not more. And there are some gray beards laughing at this young fool who thinks he was the last of a pure breed. But to me that brief period represented a very sudden and very sharp switch in the mentality of those entering the field. Now take that sudden demographic change, time-shift it a few years to where the global network infrastructure is in place to enable this work to be outsourced just about anywhere, and scale it appropriately considering that this lucrative new field could mean the difference between fabulous (comparative) wealth and a life of poverty. Add an economic crunch that pushed companies to reduce costs, and government initiatives to promote that industry. That's what India's IT industry has developed - a massive work force that has been suddenly conjured into being and drawing an even lower common denominator than I ever saw at school. [EDIT: disclaimer- I also mean no disrespect to many very fine Indian engineers and computer scientists; I mean only that the low-end of the spectrum has lowered dramatically]
- sidcool 15y agoThat's it, I am going to break this myth.
- rehack 15y agoFirst, this article is 4/5 years old. Second, this highlights another unfortunate Indian tendency to revel in cynicism. Well, I am a programmer based in India, and know many others who also are. And although I also prefer to use the 'programmer' word, but believe you can substitute it withe 'coder' without taking away any respect (remember there is the elite topcoder.com site ) India is a land of billion people. So you can find all various kinds of people here. So certainly, you will find a lot of people who may be close to the stereotype described in the essay. But if you actually see there are lots of guys, who are doing their best to try and be world class programmers. And not just programming. They are taking full advantage of the Internet to learn the silicon valley best practices to create a similar environment within their own Startups. I know quite a few of such people, actually.
- MrKurtHaeusler 15y agoNone of this is really specific to India. The same observations can be made anywhere. The fact is, most enterprise software development doesn't require much in the way of thinking, the challenges are cultural or organisational rather than technical. But that is fine. The majority of programmers (I will avoid my thoughts on coders vs programmers vs software developers here) are quite happy to convert a spec doc into code and throw it over to QA day after day. Those that want to get more out of their work life, and enjoy some more freedom to decide not just how to do things but take part in deciding what should be done, or perhaps want to involve themselves across the wider business of delivering software solutions have a lot of options open to them. They can be leaders, or start startups, or become ScrumMasters or coaches. They can move into customer facing roles if they so desire, or take part in developing tools that other developers use. They can involve themselves in academia or open source. They can become architects or help design the frameworks that encapsulate a lot of the technical complexity so that less engaged developers can get going quickly. I think it is all good. There is enough work of the right kind for everyone. We will always need lots of people happy to just do what they are told for 8 hours per day, and we will likewise need a fewer number of people to step up and take on more advanced tasks. This is not specific to India, it is fairly universal in our profession.
- hetaoblog 15y agoone question to hackers here, how do you think of the Chinese guys in IT? coder?programmer?good engineers?
- sundar22in 15y agoThis blog post is a result of "Blame culture". The intention here is just to find faults and exaggerate, but not to do anything constructive. In the end the blog post does not state anything constructive. The post is too narrow minded and focuses only on negative aspects. Poor quality is ubiquitous, its every were. Can you name one country which has only highquality programmers? Author just assumes people are bad and things are exaggerated. Blog post creates "panic" which is unwarrented. Its true that education system needs improvement, but it does not mean that most people are useless. Also this blog post assumes that everyone must be a programmer and not coder. Its like expecting everyone to become a CEO of a company. Expecting everyone to beome CEO and bashing that most are useless is stupid. There are many great programmers and innovators from india.
- jiggy2011 15y agoI would imagine that the best Indian programmers are every bit as good as the best American or European programmers. It's just that at the low end, people who are not good programmers in first world countries will gravitate towards something else as there are plenty of other ways of a making a similar level of income whereas in India options are more limited so people will stick with a career to which they may be ill suited. From what I've seen Scandinavian countries seems to have a very good track record for creating innovative programmers. A disproportionate number of highly original languages , frameworks , software and games seem to come from there.
- sundar22in 15y agoThis blog post is a result of "Blame culture". The intention here is just to find faults and exaggerate, but not to do anything constructive. In the end the blog post does not state anything constructive. The post is too narrow minded and focuses only on negative aspects. Poor quality is ubiquitous, its every were. Can you name one country which has only highquality programmers? Author just assumes people are bad and things are exaggerated. Blog post creates "panic" which is unwarrented. Its true that education system needs improvement, but it does not mean that most people are useless. Also this blog post assumes that everyone must be a programmer and not coder. Its like expecting everyone to become a CEO of a company. Expecting everyone to beome CEO and bashing that most are useless is stupid. There are many great programmers and innovators from india.
- dasil003 15y agoThis article feels dated for sure. The body shop mentality was just a result of market forces, and yeah culture probably played a role, but this situation is not providing great ROI for international clients. The nature of programming is to automate drudgery, and Indian living standards are going up all the time, so the economics of this just weren't sustainable. What is happening and will continue to happen is that Indian firms will grow into higher and higher market segments while this body shop stuff plateaus and then starts to decrease. Increasingly Indian firms will find that the real money is serving their local markets which are HUGE, and which they have cultural knowledge to produce a superior product. Initially this is done by copying successful products from innovation leaders worldwide, but eventually the competitive advantage will come from targeting the differences of the local population. I believe this will happen regardless of culture, but I do feel bad for people who were sold on the idea that being an unthinking code monkey would provide a secure and lucrative long-term career.
- gokulj 15y ago“In the last 20 years, 13 students from China have won the International Mathematical Olympiad,”..."and India hasn't won the prize even once.” http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/article2889936.ece http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/article2889936.ece There have been occasions of scientific and intellectual glory, an Amartya Sen here or a Venkataraman there, but almost all are, as Indian media fondly tags them - 'India born'. Unless we realize and accept that we have a serious problem, of which the lack of truly great Indian programmers and product companies is just a manifestation, we are not even going to attempt a solution.
- digamber_kamat 15y agoI got my bachelor's degree from a college where in one course we were supposed to learn Java. The teacher use to write the example code from the textbook onto the board and then dictate short notes on concepts like "Inheritance" , "Encapsulation" etc. According to her Interfaces in Java existed because they enabled programmers to overcome the lack of multiple inheritance. You can implement as many interfaces as you want but you can inherit only one class. That was her argument. My college was ranked 60th best college in the country that year.