3 ms·
I can't believe all this dunking on basic, sensible, etiquette. Do we all just live like savages now? Yes, the HTML formatting is annoying, but I thought the c
by ryandrake 4y ago
I can't believe all this dunking on basic, sensible, etiquette. Do we all just live like savages now?
Yes, the HTML formatting is annoying, but I thought the content was pretty timeless.
> One day you’ll find yourself being asked to conform. Refusing is often justified, but consider whether it’s actually just a request to be considerate. No one is oppressing you, for example, by asking that you dress nicely for your grandfather’s funeral.
The world really needs a dose of this. We're not all being oppressed.
- lxgr 4y agoThere might be a lot of good advice in there, but the tone is insufferable. As far as etiquette is concerned: In my experience, it's equal parts (often ritualized) consideration for others and signalling group membership/social status. I'm all for the former, as long as it's not coating an effort to perpetuate the latter. That said, good advice will always stand on its own – if it can reach its audience.
- PaulRobinson 4y agoWe are social mammals. Mating, and food & shelter security (employment), often require us to signal to those within a group that we are “safe”, and that we are one of “them”. If you meant that people use etiquette to make others feel excluded and push them away, sure, that’s wrong. But I always counter that that’s just bad etiquette.
- stared 4y agoOn the contrary, I like it. This style immediately made me move from "looking for the most important pieces of advice" (if I had to right now, I would go for GPT4 anyway) to reading it for its aesthetic value.
- TeMPOraL 4y agoThere's also third part: standardization, Schelling points, whatever you call it. Basically, if people know and are expected to follow the same standards of etiquette, it eliminates for everyone a lot of small-scale worries that can be emotionally and cognitively taxing. In particular, etiquette tells you how to behave in certain situations so that you don't have to worry about offending anyone. This works, because common etiquette means that, if someone does get offended, and you actually followed the protocol, then they are in breach of etiquette and at risk of pushback from their peers. As a result, this creates a higher-level "game": an easy way to signal whether your intentions are friendly or hostile. You came to play nice? Follow the etiquette. You want to demonstrate your disrespect to someone, or start a conflict? Break etiquette in a conspicuous way. Those are strong, clear signals, which streamline interpersonal interactions, make cooperation easier, and lets people waste less time on thinking how to dance around each other. Note that for this effect, the behaviors prescribed by the etiquette can, usually are, and arguably should be arbitrary - what matters is that they are clear, conspicuous, and that everyone is using the same rulebook when expecting everyone else to follow it.
- ruszki 4y agoMorality, etiquette, “niceness”, and all of these things have been shown many times that one of the reason why they exist is to maintain class hierarchy. Why do we need those things in a positive sum game, when even math tells us that we should hold doors for the next person, and there are clear drawbacks to have etiquette involved? The advice for party is even more interesting because there are always a first and a last, so it’s not avoidable. That “advice” is not about being “nice” at all, it just creates a social stigma.
- TeMPOraL 4y agoI think people are mixing too many ideas into "class hierarchy". Does etiquette help maintain class hierarchy? Definitely - less so now than in the past, when class boundaries were much more clear cut. But does it exist for that purpose? I don't think so. I feel that the primary purpose is to help people navigate existing class hierarchy - make it less of an issue for everyone, without trying to alter the hierarchy itself. Secondly, especially in the past, it helped people within a class to avoid unnecessary inside conflicts. > Why do we need those things in a positive sum game, when even math tells us that we should hold doors for the next person, and there are clear drawbacks to have etiquette involved? What positive sum game? Etiquette is that math, distilled for normal people, packaged in a form that can be easily taught since childhood. Good luck trying to replace manners with game theory - the former may ultimately flow from the latter, but few people will find time and will to learn the latter, while packaged solutions work for everyone and help everyone. > The advice for party is even more interesting because there are always a first and a last, so it’s not avoidable. That “advice” is not about being “nice” at all, it just creates a social stigma. It's not creating social stigma, it's observing the one that exists. And it actually exists for a good reason. The "last one to leave the party" in this context doesn't mean just being the last person to leave (as there is always one) - it's about overstaying your welcome. This is how this term is used in casual conversation. "They're always the last one to leave a party" is an euphemism for the person being inconsiderate, pushy, and possibly having a substance abuse problem. Conversely, the advice is meant to remind you that, just because you're having fun and have time to stay, you should not become the solo party guest and thus overstay your welcome. Also this harks back to my mention about mixing distinct ideas in the concept of "class". Some form of "class structure" is inevitable - it's a direct consequence of natural tendency of humans to socialize and form groups, thus dividing the world into "in-group" and "out-group" categories. But that alone isn't problematic, in the same sense as having aristocracy oppressing the peasants, or an upper class that chills out and despises the capitalists, who in turn indulge themselves and oppress the working class, etc.
- ludston 4y agoThere is ample opportunity to strawman the advice in this book and invent scenarios where it does not apply. I'd say that it is something of a cultural phenomenon of our times that we get these angry criticisms of opinions rather than acceptance and tolerance of views different to our own. I think we'd all be better off if instead of looking for reasons to invalidate opinion pieces and etiquette advice, we value them as opportunities to better understand other people's thinking. There is not much use getting upset about these kinds of things because it's not going to be in our power to change them anyway.
- ryandrake 4y agoI didn't read all the way to the end, but it wouldn't surprise me if one of the quotes was: "One day you'll find yourself angry at someone's offer of unsolicited advice, imagining it an affront to your personal autonomy. Consider the intentions behind the advice and whether or not you have a choice to follow it."
- JellyBeanThief 4y agoI wonder if "One day you'll find yourself experiencing feelings from social interaction with someone you are not actually having social interaction with, and you have not evolved to cope wisely with this." or similar might be a more relevant formulation for distribution on the net.
- TeMPOraL 4y agoThe two are overlapping, but not equivalent. Both cover conversations with strangers on the web, but beyond that, yours is especially relevant to parasocial relationships (think podcasters, vloggers, influencers), and GP's applies to conversations with people you know, including in meatspace (think unsolicited advice from a family member).
- rchaud 4y agoYes, but that advice was for all these other savages who don't appreciate this etiquette manual! /s
- throwaway675309 4y agoBecause it's the same banal empty platitudes that have been bandied around for decades. Do we really need a dedicated website rehashing the same thing? One day you'll find yourself desperately wanting to create a website or write an blog article, but maybe you should ask yourself if you actually have anything original to say.
- JellyBeanThief 4y agoIt makes sense that the platitudes would change slowly at the pace of human lifetimes. If the marijuana revolution continues, in 50 years our grandchildren might be complaining about "One day you'll find yourself accepting a friend's weed for lack of your own. Take care to return the favor." or something.
- _moof 4y agoI suppose one day you'll find yourself in front of bunch of bitter pedants who are desperate to find any way not to be charitable, open-minded, or prosocial. I think a lot of folks would benefit from letting their initial reaction of kneejerk contrarianism float by un-acted upon, and practicing going "psychically limp," as a good friend of mine once put it. They might actually learn something.
- bheadmaster 4y ago> The world really needs a dose of this. We're not all being oppressed. Then why does it matter if we conform? If it does matter, then how exactly are we not being oppressed when demanded to conform? This seems like such a double-think. "You're supposed to bend over, but don't think of it as oppression". Yeah, right.