3 ms·
The good: a flagship Android phone that doesn't have to have a manufacturer's special sauce added to it. The bad: in the US, they still have to dicker with the
by dsr_ 15y ago
The good: a flagship Android phone that doesn't have to have a manufacturer's special sauce added to it.
The bad: in the US, they still have to dicker with the wireless carriers.
The ugly: every Android manufacturer will suspect they are being disfavored.
- AndrewDucker 15y agoI'm hoping that the ICS version of the Droid Razr doesn't have any extra stuff on it, but is just an Android phone.
- jrockway 15y agoa flagship Android phone that doesn't have to have a manufacturer's special sauce added to it Is the hardware between devices really all that different? Phones are basically giant screens attached to giant batteries. Where do you go from there? Put in CDMA and GSM radios that each do a bunch of frequencies, and you're done developing phones forever. (Even the iPhone 4 and iPhone 1 look approximately the same. Big screen. Home button. Power button / volume buttons / vibrate switch. Android devices are even simpler because they only need a power button.) The problem with phones is that they are all the same in an abstract sense, but all different with respect to drivers and hardware bugs. That means you can never write phone OSes like you can write desktop OSes, which is a huge drag on innovation. Imagine if you could choose between Ubuntu and Mint on your phone. Instead, you're stuck with whatever you get from your carrier, which is worse than nothing at all. Phones are all software these days, and the hardware manufactures cannot code their way out of a wet paper bag.
- freehunter 15y ago>you're done developing phones forever There are dozens of different form-factors. Take a look at the diversity of the Android or even the WP7 market. Landscape sliders, portrait sliders, 4.3", 3.7", 5", 3", some with dual core, some with quad core, some with AMOLED screens, some with SAMOLED screens, some LCD screens. Some with removable SD cards, various amounts of storage, various price points of the market. >Even the iPhone 4 and iPhone 1 look approximately the same That's because Apple designed them all the same. The way Apple designs their products does not have any relation to the amount of possible designs. >Android devices are even simpler because they only need a power button. Android phones are supposed to have four face buttons. This is not strictly required (allowing for variation), but the phones expect you to have four buttons. Windows has three. Apple has one. >you're stuck with whatever you get from your carrier Except there is a huge amount of variation in the custom ROM world, which many Android devices allow. >Phones are all software these days A common misconception that will at some point pave the way for true innovation in hardware like we've seen in the past when the smartphone market stagnated (then the iPhone was released and it was exciting again).
- there 15y agoThis acquisition really has nothing to do with making Google-branded Android phones, and everything to do with acquiring a huge patent portfolio to defend against Android-related lawsuits. I predict that there will not really be much change in Google's or Motorola's device offerings and that other manufacturers will actually feel better post-acquisition, because now they will be further-protected by Google's patent portfolio.
- Zirro 15y ago"The good: a flagship Android phone that doesn't have to have a manufacturer's special sauce added to it." Is the special sauce added because they believe users appreciate it, or because they have some way to earn money from it? (Actually, as someone who haven't used Android devices much, what are the common ingredients used in the special sauce?)
- wmf 15y agoThey want to get brand loyalty to their addons so that next time customers will buy the same brand phone. Also, I've heard that carriers would prefer if all the different Android phones they carry actually look different rather than all looking the same (or they could just carry fewer models).