3 ms·
The UK currently has chronic labour shortages in many areas, so I don't think your take is particularly credible in this specific case. Other cases, potentiall
by ben_w 4y ago
The UK currently has chronic labour shortages in many areas, so I don't think your take is particularly credible in this specific case.
Other cases, potentially, but not this one.
- ETH_start 4y agoA labor shortage can coincide with pools of unemployable workers, due to a mismatch between the skills and qualifications required for open positions and those possessed by a subset of workers.
- shagie 4y agoGiven the ongoing UK truck driver shortages, why is uber driver a more attractive option for driving a vehicle? Then the question is "why is the uber driver not able to command as much as a truck driver?" and "why is the uber driver not switching to being a truck driver?" The corresponding part is "if you can't work 8h today but only have 2 hours in the morning and 2h in the afternoon, that flexibility comes at a cost of reduced pay." This is from a bit ago but likely still quite relevant - https://www.epi.org/publication/part-time-pay-penalty/ https://www.epi.org/publication/part-time-pay-penalty/ and https://www.hiringlab.org/2019/05/09/moms-and-part-time-work/ https://www.hiringlab.org/2019/05/09/moms-and-part-time-work...
- ben_w 4y ago> Given the ongoing UK truck driver shortages, why is uber driver a more attractive option for driving a vehicle? Different licence, different working conditions. Sometimes the swings and the roundabouts are both rusty.
- shagie 4y agoSo this is an example of Uber employing some people who are otherwise unemployable or do not wish to be employed in that sector of the workforce. Is it reasonable to say that anyone who is currently a gig worker with Uber and wanted to could get a job as a HCV driver could do so by getting the license or taking an apprenticeship program? ( https://www.gov.uk/training-hgv/apprenticeships https://www.gov.uk/training-hgv/apprenticeships ) On the other hand, if people would rather work for Uber than a trucking company, is it fair to blame Uber for the labor shortage for truck drivers? Additionally, if people would rather work for Uber than a trucking company, is it unfair for Uber to pay less than the trucking company? (Note: I categorically against the 'disrupt the industry by ignoring regulations and miscategorize workers' that many gig based companies seek to exploit and while this does cause problems it isn't necessarily the root cause of the problems that exist from inefficiencies in current regulations and employment options) As an aside on the licensing in this situation https://www.gov.uk/guidance/use-a-driver-cpc-national-vocational-training-nvt-concession https://www.gov.uk/guidance/use-a-driver-cpc-national-vocati... : Drive an HGV or bus professionally while you're training - Apply to drive an HGV, bus or coach professionally for up to 12 months before taking all the qualifying tests if you’re doing certain training courses.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- _dain_ 4y agoThere's no labour shortage -- or rather there is, but it's not the relevant causal factor. There's a lack of housing supply in places with good jobs. People have to dump so much of their hard earned cash into rent that it discourages people from moving there in the first place. Talented people are stuck in shit jobs in the north because the higher wages in the south aren't enough to offset the insane rents. Autobiographical anecdote: due to combinations of good and bad luck I've had three different jobs in three different cities over the past 18 months. My income went from (rounded) ~30k to ~60k to ~90k, up by more than a factor of three. Yet, the rent I was paying remained about the same fraction of my post-tax income in each case, while the objective standard of housing that rent paid for went down: Sheffield: £500/month for a 2br flat in a nice neighbourhood Cardiff: £900/month for a not-as-good 2br flat in an okay neighbourhood Cambridge: £1300/month for a one bedroom flat in an okay neighbourhood. There are almost no <£1200/mo 2br flats on the market at all. Now think how hopeless it is for the other 95% of the country who are not as fortunate as me. A huge chunk of the wage premium for living in a more economically productive city is being slurped up by boomer rentiers because of the inelasticity of the housing supply curve, i.e. the "nimby tax". The price mechanism is just completely broken. Rising prices don't spur anywhere near enough construction. People just learn to make do with less: smaller houses, shittier houses, sharing rooms, or foregoing career opportunities that involve relocation. A whole generation has grown up not knowing what a functioning housing market looks like ... this is all just seen as normal. (PS: once you factor this in, the North is even more economically weak than it appears on paper, because the high house prices in the South partially counteract the brain drain. Few graduates stay there by choice. I have no trouble believing it's de facto poorer than Poland now. Still waiting for the "levelling up" to happen.)
- ben_w 4y agoRegarding rents too high: all true! Though there's also a labor shortage, something like 300k over the whole national economy. That said: > Cambridge: £1300/month for a one bedroom flat in an okay neighbourhood. There are almost no <£1200/mo 2br flats on the market at all. Try Cottenham and other similar-distance villages. Writing as a landlord of a one-bed flat in that village… well, when I saw the "cost of living crisis" headlines I told the agency not to increase the rent, but what they were suggesting as the new high was £800/mo. I used to live in that flat, and the cycle commute to the science park was fine. Now I'm living a long cycle ride or moderate train ride from the Polish border, and I can say from having lived in Sheffield (Heeley) and having briefly visited Słubice as part of a day trip, that I share your belief about the relative economic situations of the two.