3 ms·
> 14th amendment makes it pretty clear as far as I can tell that America may not default. Right, but even if that means the executive can take some action that
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> 14th amendment makes it pretty clear as far as I can tell that America may not default.
Right, but even if that means the executive can take some action that otherwise would be prohibited if the Congress passes taxing and spending bills but also passes a debt limit inconsistent with the net result, that doesn’t mean that the executive can take any action in his discretion. While, say, the Biden Administration might agree that the 14th Amendment would, ultimately, allow the government to pay its debts, they probably don’t want to take the risk that the courts would determine that that means that the executive must unilaterally cut appropriated spending to minimize any overage in the debt limit, and return within it as soon as practical while paying debt service. (Both because they wouldn’t prefer spending cuts to ignoring the debt limit, and because politically they don’t want to be on the hook for the impacts of spending cuts they don’t want to make.)
Conversely, while Republicans might like that outcome, they wouldn’t like court finding that, indeed, the executive can choose to just ignore the debt limit in the case of that kind of conflict.
So no one actually wants to get the position of having the courts resolve this, especially since US courts don’t give advisory rulings, so the only way to get it before the courts is to get into a situation where the court ruling is going to be atomic bomb for one side or the other on the issue.
- mint2 4y agoFollowing the debt limit rule is clearly more illegal than following the budget. With following the debt limit, the president would essentially get sole discretion as to what programs to fund or cut. That would essentially take all power away from congress. Congress passed the budgets that got the debt, the president can’t pick and choose what to fund as some run around of all the laws and separation of power we have.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Following the debt limit rule is clearly more illegal than following the budget. Not sure where you get that. While there is case law suggesting that budget spending is generally mandatory with certain exceptions, the Constitution itself does not expressly dictate that – it prohibits spending non-appropriated funds, but does not explicitly prohibit refusing to spend appropriated funds. You could make a textual argument that spending funds in violation of laws passed by Congress is “more illegal” than not spending funds directed in those laws. > With following the debt limit, the president would essentially get sole discretion as to what programs to fund or cut. I can see why that might be undesirable from a particular set of values, but I don’t see that that makes it “clearly illegal” in the only sense that matters, which is, “indisputably what the Supreme Court would rule should a dispute come to it.” > That would essentially take all power away from congress. No, because Congress could always pass a debt limit increase (even over a Presidential veto) that eliminated the conflict and took that power away from the President. > Congress passed the budgets that got the debt, the president can’t pick and choose what to fund as some run around of all the laws and separation of power we have. By the same token, Congress passed the debt limit, and the President can’t pick and choose what limits to ignore as some end run around all the laws and separation of power we have.