4 ms·
That's a lazy rationalization which doesn't even make sense — either way you're getting the exact same sandwich, it's just a question of whether you pay for it
by acdha 4y ago
That's a lazy rationalization which doesn't even make sense — either way you're getting the exact same sandwich, it's just a question of whether you pay for it directly or by watching ads.
This also doesn't make any sense from the negative way you're describing it: you're eating at Cockroach Joe's every day so clearly you don't really believe the food is bad. If you're using YouTube now, any negative which you can possibly imagine is already happening: they're tracking what you watch and where you watch it from, they're telling advertisers what kind of devices you use as a proxy for your likely spending habits, etc. There's a 0% chance they do that less when it's their only option to make money to cover your usage costs!
- Ygg2 4y ago> That's a lazy rationalization which doesn't even make sense — either way you're getting the exact same sandwich, it's just a question of whether you pay for it directly or by watching ads. It's an imperfect analogy. But point remains. Some places can offer bad and good experiences side by side, and have a long reputation of shitting up a few good products over time. > eating at Cockroach Joe's every day so clearly you don't really believe the food is bad. No. I know some X is bad, and some Y is good. It doesn't mean I hate X, I hate X that such and such makes. It's like that scene in Spaceballs. Don't order the menu special.
- acdha 4y agoIf you think it’s a bad experience, why do you keep going? The fact that you’re concerned about avoiding ads means you must find the content interesting and that means you should pay for what you use, either directly or indirectly.
- cubancigar11 4y agoBecause it is designed for addiction? Is that up for debate? YouTube is top result because it is owned by Google. This is a standard business model. People bet into slot machines. Put an entry fee into a room full of slot machines and see for yourself how many people come to play. The only way for a casino to make sure people pay to play a slot machines is to keep a free entry option that is gets annoying quickly. It is creation of a problem to justify a paid solution. Ad blockers solve that problem for free and have to be blocked. And people who are addicted to slot machines have their own favorite games that they play all day long. They might pay at a chance to play. Youtube doesn't actually want to have a competitor at the same time.
- acdha 4y agoIf you actually believe that you should be blocking YouTube, not just the ads. The excuses in this thread are like arguing that it’s okay to sneak into a casino’s free buffet because the gambling industry has plenty of money and is bad for people.
- Ygg2 4y agoProblem is, if you want videos Youtube is most likely your only option. TikTok hosts only 5min snippets, it's better (or worse) at addiction explotation. Vimeo doesn't host videos you probably want. Nebula (and other subsrcibe services) are great but what if I want a conference talks? To torture the analogy. This isn't sneaking in the free buffet. It's the option of only free buffet in casino offering stuff you aren't allergic to. But then forcing you to play some strip poker to get in. Sure you can pay to get in, but what guarantees I have they won't force gambling on paying customers or further deterioration of the free experience?
- acdha 4y agoIn other words, YouTube is giving you something you value but you don’t to follow the terms of the agreement. Just be honest and say that rather than trying to invent these weird narratives to try to make it sound more noble than freeloading.
- mike741 4y ago"In other words" why not address their actual words? Youtube is giving us something we value, but that does not justify any given demand Youtube comes up with. There's nothing noble about blindly accepting the terms of a monopoly.
- acdha 4y agoYouTube is not a monopoly and you can easily live a perfectly happy, normal life not using it if you hate ads that intensely or, since you clearly like it quite a bit and are not willing to consider alternatives, pay 1-2 coffees per month.
- Ygg2 4y agoMany things can cause you to go to same place. Lack of meaningful choice, not being able to afford anything better, etc. But YT premium on itself is bad value. I can replicate most of its value with... An ad blocker. Why should I pay Google to solve problems it creates for me? That's just incentives them making more problems. Maybe they will add a solve a captcha every 5 min if not on Premium. And lastly YT isn't above ruining it as well (see premium ads). History (see cable) teaches us, ads on premium is a matter of time.
- deafpolygon 4y agoHello my honey hello my ragtime gal.
- Ygg2 4y agoThis guy Spaceballs.
- monksy 4y agoWould you pay for a $60 steak at McDonald's? Without reviews, seeing it, etc?
- actuator 4y ago- You can try premium - It is not $60 steak equivalent. More like it is the price of McDonalds burger itself. - It is not an untested product. You are getting an option to pay for the burger and eat it, rather than watch a 30 min ad to eat it for free. People will hate Google/FB ad model and at the same time also not pay for a paid tier that removes the ads.
- DashAnimal 4y agoYouTube Premium is my most loved subscription, for what it's worth. I don't even use the Music element, but if I did that would be another reason. While all other subscriptions I pause on and off waiting for content, YouTube has always had solid stuff -- from mindless good stuff, content reviews, learning household chores, to full-on lectures/talks from Universities/Conferences. If you're getting served McDonalds at the world's largest buffet, it's because that is what you enjoy.
- acdha 4y agoWhere are you getting steak from? YouTube premium is the exact same content you like only paid for directly instead of by advertisers. You must already be watching stuff on YouTube and enjoying it because otherwise you wouldn’t care about whether it has ads.