3 ms·
IP is an artificial market rather than !market. Also, data is non rivalrous, unlike a stadium. Basically an unlimited number of people can access it. OTOH, c
by davidw 15y ago
IP is an artificial market rather than !market.
Also, data is non rivalrous, unlike a stadium. Basically an unlimited number of people can access it.
OTOH, charging something might put the onus of paying for the collection a bit closer to the users, if that group of users is small and well-defined. It wouldn't be fair for them to reap large benefits at the expense of everyone else.
That said, though, if the users are a large and not well-defined group, opening up the data is probably more beneficial.
- maxerickson 15y agoIf the data collection is not benefiting most of the people in the county, then the question quickly comes up, why is the county doing it? That doesn't completely address the county doing collection that benefits everyone by providing information to a small group of people, but I think it supports the notion that any prices should be set to mitigate the sharing costs, not the collection costs (because the county should be organizing data collection around beneficial activities, not around creating salable data sets).
- davidw 15y agoYes, I would mostly come down on the side of making the data open due also to the benefits of letting anyone have at it and create new and interesting things. GIS data is not some tiny niche.
- kd5bjo 15y agoThere's also the possibility that the most value to the people of the county comes from subsidizing the beneficial activities that need the data by collecting licensing fees from businesses that can use the data for monetary gain.