5 ms·
> I have no problem paying for services, even for premium tiers when free tier is available. > I don't trust YouTube Premium enough to even try it. These two
by acdha 4y ago
> I have no problem paying for services, even for premium tiers when free tier is available.
> I don't trust YouTube Premium enough to even try it.
These two statements seem to be mutually incompatible unless you're trying to argue that a premium tier doesn't really exist unless you can write the terms of service and audit the company providing it. It's also somewhat hard to follow the logic here: if you don't trust YouTube, why are you watching them at all? It's not like Google tracks you less that way and if you're under the impression that your ad blocker is helping there you can certainly subscribe to Premium while leaving the same blocker enabled.
- Ygg2 4y agoI like premium stake and would pay for it. I'm not eating premium stake at Cockroach Joe. His sandwiches are alright. How are they incompatible?
- endisneigh 4y agoPeople will make all sort of excuses to rationalize not paying for digital content that they can easily get for free.
- Ygg2 4y agoFunny part is. I actually got YT premium from family member. It's indistinguishable from using adblock.
- pulvinar 4y agoI don't make any excuses-- if the content is handed to me for free, I take it. They also hand me ads for free but I don't care for those, thanks. It's really a strange concept that we're somehow cheating someone for not looking at an ad. And yet somehow it wouldn't be cheating if we poured over every ad but never bought anything in them.
- pb7 4y agoBut you are cheating someone. The creators of the videos you're watching don't get anything when you block the ads. That means you've cheated them of money, on top of cheating the company of money. It's not handed to you for free, there's an implicit condition that you watch the content and the ads that are served with it. Too many people don't do that and that's why YouTube is now testing blocking ad-blockers. You reap what you sow.
- krapp 4y ago>It's not handed to you for free, there's an implicit condition that you watch the content and the ads that are served with it. No, there isn't. The web was designed from the beginning to allow the end user to have control over what content is and is not displayed. It isn't television, radio or magazines, the platform owner doesn't have complete control over the layout and display of the content they serve. There is no condition, implicit or otherwise, that the end user will pretend they're consuming an old media product just because web platforms can't move beyond old media models of revenue. None of which require viewing, reading or listening to the ads, either. Ads have always been a gentleman's agreement. >Too many people don't do that and that's why YouTube is now testing blocking ad-blockers. You reap what you sow. No, Youtube is going to reap what it sowed, because no one is going to turn off their ad blockers. If their platform was worth paying for, everyone would have moved to the paid tier by now. Google bought a free video service and tried and failed to monetize it to the point of nearly ruining it for content creators with their puritanical rules, arbitrary demonitization, opaque to nonexistent support and restrictive algorithm, but no matter how much they squeeze the turnip, it won't bleed enough for them. That's not our problem. We'll gladly support content creators directly through Patreon or other means, but Google can get fucked.
- pb7 4y agoWhich brings us right back to the article: don't be surprised when your ad-blocker stops working. Serving high bitrate video is not cheap and YouTube is notoriously breaking even at best. Any alternative is going to be even less efficient and more expensive due to the lack of economies of scale that Google has. If that's what you want so long as it doesn't have Google's name in the corner, so be it, that's understandable. >If their platform was worth paying for, everyone would have moved to the paid tier by now. I disagree. I think people are inherently cheap and will exhaust other options of getting the same content for free first. We shall see I guess.
- crop_rotation 4y ago> His sandwiches are alright "when I don't have to pay for them" fixed it for you.
- acdha 4y agoThat's a lazy rationalization which doesn't even make sense — either way you're getting the exact same sandwich, it's just a question of whether you pay for it directly or by watching ads. This also doesn't make any sense from the negative way you're describing it: you're eating at Cockroach Joe's every day so clearly you don't really believe the food is bad. If you're using YouTube now, any negative which you can possibly imagine is already happening: they're tracking what you watch and where you watch it from, they're telling advertisers what kind of devices you use as a proxy for your likely spending habits, etc. There's a 0% chance they do that less when it's their only option to make money to cover your usage costs!
- Ygg2 4y ago> That's a lazy rationalization which doesn't even make sense — either way you're getting the exact same sandwich, it's just a question of whether you pay for it directly or by watching ads. It's an imperfect analogy. But point remains. Some places can offer bad and good experiences side by side, and have a long reputation of shitting up a few good products over time. > eating at Cockroach Joe's every day so clearly you don't really believe the food is bad. No. I know some X is bad, and some Y is good. It doesn't mean I hate X, I hate X that such and such makes. It's like that scene in Spaceballs. Don't order the menu special.
- acdha 4y agoIf you think it’s a bad experience, why do you keep going? The fact that you’re concerned about avoiding ads means you must find the content interesting and that means you should pay for what you use, either directly or indirectly.
- cubancigar11 4y agoBecause it is designed for addiction? Is that up for debate? YouTube is top result because it is owned by Google. This is a standard business model. People bet into slot machines. Put an entry fee into a room full of slot machines and see for yourself how many people come to play. The only way for a casino to make sure people pay to play a slot machines is to keep a free entry option that is gets annoying quickly. It is creation of a problem to justify a paid solution. Ad blockers solve that problem for free and have to be blocked. And people who are addicted to slot machines have their own favorite games that they play all day long. They might pay at a chance to play. Youtube doesn't actually want to have a competitor at the same time.
- grupthink 4y ago> I'll eat at Cockroach Joe, but I won't pay. I also like to tell people I don't pay because it goes against my virtues. But I'll still go there to eat. Fixed.
- Prickle 4y agoEven if I paid for YT premium, the money wouldn't go to the YT creator people I support. It's really that simple. I can no longer trust PayPal, and Patreon doesn't accept my local credit card so that goes down the drain too. They already harvest my data. I refuse to pay them money to exploit me further.
- CydeWeys 4y agoYT premium money does partially go to creators though??
- amno 4y agoOnly to those that have a signed contract with YT, no?
- CydeWeys 4y agoIsn't that a really low bar though? If you're making any money off YouTube you've signed a contract. YT Premium just lets you make more.
- Prickle 4y agoTo my understanding, the money primarily goes to large creators first. So the smaller creators get a smaller contribution out of my YT Premium. So, if I really do want to support the creator, other external systems are better.
- lbwtaylor 4y agoNo, YTP money is paid to creators based on time YTP subscribers spend watching their content. So if you watch small channels that's who will benefit from your subscription.
- CydeWeys 4y agoThe money mostly goes to large creators simply because those large creators have way more viewing hours. The nice thing about YT Premium is that you have a single subscription to manage, and it then helps support a wide number of creators, even ones who you only see a single video of. It'll go to helping way more people in total than you would ever get around to signing up for individual Patreon subscriptions for.