4 ms·
> Reality: McMansions are popular because they are comfortable and provide living space for an actual family. While being NOT more expensive on a per-unit basis
by lmm 4y ago
> Reality: McMansions are popular because they are comfortable and provide living space for an actual family. While being NOT more expensive on a per-unit basis than tiny condos in major urban centers.
> I get it, millenials got screwed by the unfortunate confluence of 2008 and by the economy finally transforming from manufacturing economy into a service-based one. They can't afford large houses, so the psychological defense mechanism kicks in: "Hey, these McMansions are bad anyway. It's good to downsize into a shoebox".
So they're popular because they're affordable, but they're hated because they're expensive? Which is it?
> But at this point we perhaps should start answering the question: do we want cities to continue being densified into Manhattan-style concrete canyons, or should we make sure that our children can live in nice houses that our generation was not able to afford?
Manhattan is popular, aspirational even, for a reason. Every generation before the 1950s was built by gradual densification. The wrongheaded decision to try to pickle cities in aspic via zoning laws is what creates housing unaffordability. A "nice" lifestyle is far more about being able to live somewhere you can work and socialize than about having zillions of sterile square feet to yourself.
- mikecoles 4y agoHaving acres of fertile square feet to yourself is indeed a nice lifestyle.
- klyrs 4y agoI'll be honest, that sounds like a ton of work.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- glompers 4y agoYes but to many it is a relaxing form of work, just like a better form of mental and physical workout combined with “forest bath” or “bird song bathing” — depending on the local biome and season of course
- thebradbain 4y agoAcres? Those are bona-fide mansions and estates. The definition of McMansion I’m familiar with, at least in Los Angeles, is demolishing a 2bd/2ba bungalow to build a 5bd/4ba house, usually by getting rid of all fertile backyard/frontyard in the first place. They have another pejorative name, too— “Boxy Moderns” This is super common in Santa Monica or Beverly Hills, for example. Even San Francisco! And yet, for some reason, this is completely fine to build without any zoning meetings but the second you propose a 5-unit 1bd/1ba apartment building with the same profile in a “single family neighborhood” it’s ruining the entire “character” of the place and requires 3-5 years of bureaucracy and, depending on the neighbors, litigation.
- GauntletWizard 4y agoThe number of family units to hold responsible (and to hold each other responsible) accounts for all of the resistance, and quite frankly, there should be more. You can have a house with a family with kids or you can have a box with a half dozen losers in it, and statistically one of them is a felon. Sane people choose the former.
- thebradbain 4y ago…? In these neighborhoods a 1bd condo would still sell for above $800k, minimum. More than likely $1.2-1.5m, looking at Zillow. They’d rent for at least $7k/mo. If we’re generalizing, like you are, then they’d allow the well-off professional class to live and work in their neighborhood and send their kids to the same schools as the investor-class and trust fund kids-turned-homeowners who haven’t done anything in decades other than be born to the right family. Unless you’re talking about white-collar convicted felons? Which I can guarantee you, once again, they already live in these neighborhoods and aren’t the ones trying to move into it. If that sounds like hyperbole, then sure— but so is yours.
- lmm 4y agoIt can be, for some people. Rural lifestyles work, urban lifestyles work; suburbia gets the worst of both worlds, even with the messed up economics that subsidise it it's still not a pleasant way of living (AIUI there's an established bias that people naturally underestimate how long they'll be stuck in traffic commuting and how miserable it will make them).
- anon291 4y ago> AIUI there's an established bias that people naturally underestimate how long they'll be stuck in traffic commuting and how miserable it will make them Grew up in the burbs of southern California so I had 22 years of experience with the traffic there. Turned me into an urban or rural dweller. Nothing in between. It's just not worth it.
- cyberax 4y ago> So they're popular because they're affordable, but they're hated because they're expensive? Which is it? Millenials can't afford to buy either a McMansion, or a condo in a city. They can afford to rent an apartment. > Manhattan is popular, aspirational even, for a reason. Every generation before the 1950s was built by gradual densification. Yup. And there's a reason why the US became the world leading power with unparalleled quality of life after 1950-s.
- swexbe 4y agoAmerican post-war affluence is because of McMansions? That’s certainly a novel theory.
- cyberax 4y agoYup. They just were not called "McMansions" at the time. Affluence definitely followed the conscious policy decision to build a network of freeways and highways, with a focus on suburban lifestyle. To expand a bit on that, car-oriented cities allowed US citizens to: 1. Have shorter commutes than Europeans. This _still_ holds true! 2. Be able to access more businesses within the "reasonable commute" range.
- lmm 4y ago> car-oriented cities allowed US citizens to: > 1. Have shorter commutes than Europeans. This _still_ holds true! > 2. Be able to access more businesses within the "reasonable commute" range. Citation? That's the opposite of everything I've seen here and elsewhere; Americans seem to see an hour-or-more commute as normal. Car-based cities give you great commute times until those pesky other cars start commuting and filling up the roads.
- cyberax 4y agoFor 1980 the US average commute time was 21 minutes. For Paris that was 38 minutes. For London it was 40 minutes. For the current state of affairs: Commute time in Paris: 32 minutes, commute time in Berlin: 31 minutes, commute time in London: 47 minutes. US average: 27 minutes. For reachability: https://www.nature.com/articles/s42949-021-00020-2 https://www.nature.com/articles/s42949-021-00020-2 > Car-based cities give you great commute times until those pesky other cars start commuting and filling up the roads. Even bad car-based cities are generally _better_ than the best transit-oriented cities. Even with congestion and decades of neglect, forced by anti-people pro-urbanism crowd. Just look up commute times and think. I suggest looking up Houston, TX (so-called "car hell") and comparing it with major European cities.