5 ms·
Ah, a rag totally dedicated to harping the virtues of "urbanism" is unloading on actually liveable houses. Shocking. News at 11. Reality: McMansions are popula
by cyberax 4y ago
Ah, a rag totally dedicated to harping the virtues of "urbanism" is unloading on actually liveable houses. Shocking. News at 11.
Reality: McMansions are popular because they are comfortable and provide living space for an actual family. While being NOT more expensive on a per-unit basis than tiny condos in major urban centers.
I get it, millenials got screwed by the unfortunate confluence of 2008 and by the economy finally transforming from manufacturing economy into a service-based one. They can't afford large houses, so the psychological defense mechanism kicks in: "Hey, these McMansions are bad anyway. It's good to downsize into a shoebox".
But at this point we perhaps should start answering the question: do we want cities to continue being densified into Manhattan-style concrete canyons, or should we make sure that our children can live in nice houses that our generation was not able to afford?
- lmm 4y ago> Reality: McMansions are popular because they are comfortable and provide living space for an actual family. While being NOT more expensive on a per-unit basis than tiny condos in major urban centers. > I get it, millenials got screwed by the unfortunate confluence of 2008 and by the economy finally transforming from manufacturing economy into a service-based one. They can't afford large houses, so the psychological defense mechanism kicks in: "Hey, these McMansions are bad anyway. It's good to downsize into a shoebox". So they're popular because they're affordable, but they're hated because they're expensive? Which is it? > But at this point we perhaps should start answering the question: do we want cities to continue being densified into Manhattan-style concrete canyons, or should we make sure that our children can live in nice houses that our generation was not able to afford? Manhattan is popular, aspirational even, for a reason. Every generation before the 1950s was built by gradual densification. The wrongheaded decision to try to pickle cities in aspic via zoning laws is what creates housing unaffordability. A "nice" lifestyle is far more about being able to live somewhere you can work and socialize than about having zillions of sterile square feet to yourself.
- mikecoles 4y agoHaving acres of fertile square feet to yourself is indeed a nice lifestyle.
- klyrs 4y agoI'll be honest, that sounds like a ton of work.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- glompers 4y agoYes but to many it is a relaxing form of work, just like a better form of mental and physical workout combined with “forest bath” or “bird song bathing” — depending on the local biome and season of course
- thebradbain 4y agoAcres? Those are bona-fide mansions and estates. The definition of McMansion I’m familiar with, at least in Los Angeles, is demolishing a 2bd/2ba bungalow to build a 5bd/4ba house, usually by getting rid of all fertile backyard/frontyard in the first place. They have another pejorative name, too— “Boxy Moderns” This is super common in Santa Monica or Beverly Hills, for example. Even San Francisco! And yet, for some reason, this is completely fine to build without any zoning meetings but the second you propose a 5-unit 1bd/1ba apartment building with the same profile in a “single family neighborhood” it’s ruining the entire “character” of the place and requires 3-5 years of bureaucracy and, depending on the neighbors, litigation.
- GauntletWizard 4y agoThe number of family units to hold responsible (and to hold each other responsible) accounts for all of the resistance, and quite frankly, there should be more. You can have a house with a family with kids or you can have a box with a half dozen losers in it, and statistically one of them is a felon. Sane people choose the former.
- cyberax 4y ago> So they're popular because they're affordable, but they're hated because they're expensive? Which is it? Millenials can't afford to buy either a McMansion, or a condo in a city. They can afford to rent an apartment. > Manhattan is popular, aspirational even, for a reason. Every generation before the 1950s was built by gradual densification. Yup. And there's a reason why the US became the world leading power with unparalleled quality of life after 1950-s.
- swexbe 4y agoAmerican post-war affluence is because of McMansions? That’s certainly a novel theory.
- cyberax 4y agoYup. They just were not called "McMansions" at the time. Affluence definitely followed the conscious policy decision to build a network of freeways and highways, with a focus on suburban lifestyle. To expand a bit on that, car-oriented cities allowed US citizens to: 1. Have shorter commutes than Europeans. This _still_ holds true! 2. Be able to access more businesses within the "reasonable commute" range.
- lmm 4y ago> car-oriented cities allowed US citizens to: > 1. Have shorter commutes than Europeans. This _still_ holds true! > 2. Be able to access more businesses within the "reasonable commute" range. Citation? That's the opposite of everything I've seen here and elsewhere; Americans seem to see an hour-or-more commute as normal. Car-based cities give you great commute times until those pesky other cars start commuting and filling up the roads.
- cyberax 4y agoFor 1980 the US average commute time was 21 minutes. For Paris that was 38 minutes. For London it was 40 minutes. For the current state of affairs: Commute time in Paris: 32 minutes, commute time in Berlin: 31 minutes, commute time in London: 47 minutes. US average: 27 minutes. For reachability: https://www.nature.com/articles/s42949-021-00020-2 https://www.nature.com/articles/s42949-021-00020-2 > Car-based cities give you great commute times until those pesky other cars start commuting and filling up the roads. Even bad car-based cities are generally _better_ than the best transit-oriented cities. Even with congestion and decades of neglect, forced by anti-people pro-urbanism crowd. Just look up commute times and think. I suggest looking up Houston, TX (so-called "car hell") and comparing it with major European cities.
- thebradbain 4y agoSorry, but you’re creating a false dichotomy. The _vast majority_ of land in the US, urban centers included, including NYC, is zoned for low density single family homes. Manhattan is only 1 of 5 boroughs in NYC, remember. There is NO shortage of single family homes. There IS a shortage of absolute number of units in urbanized areas. This is because, contrary to what you claim, the only thing allowed to be built in many areas is exclusively single family homes. > Should we make sure that our children can live in nice houses that our generation was not able to afford I say this as a relatively fortunate homeowner in Los Angeles who is part of “this generation”: if we do not allow more homes to be built, the next generation will not be able to live in the city at all. I myself would not have been able to afford my home in the city and neighborhood I love had the recent state zoning changes (sb9) which allowed me to convert my single family home into to a duplex not occurred.
- dqv 4y agoI think people are even indifferent to single-family homes. Many people would be happy living in a duplex or any of the various structures of the missing middle. You can raise a family under those conditions. What difference does it make if your child plays soccer with their friends in the shared courtyard or your own private backyard?
- chiffre01 4y agoI think what the article is trying to say is more affordable/modest new construction is needed to improve current housing issues in many areas. Cheaply built giants, made to maximize contractor profits, only serve a small income demographic at the end of the day.
- jknoepfler 4y agoEven embracing for a second the notion that spreading municipalities out over vast tracts of land connected by cars is ethical and sustainable (which I don't)... the stereotypical midwestern suburb I grew up in had a lot of modest single family homes. The developers kept large stands of original trees. Homes backed up into forests, parks, and (natural) ponds. The houses were generously proportioned for four people. Then the wave of McMansions hit. The contrast was night and day. Same families, but the houses were twice as large, adorned with like... Fake columns and endless unnecessary fake architectural flourishes and ugly facade exteriors. The houses were jammed into tiny lots with no trees and no yards. The developers cut down all of the natural landscape and installed ridiculous fountain jets in drainage ponds. Side by side with the rest of the neighbourhood it was (and remains) ugly, excessive and soulless. That's what a McMansion means to me. It's the white collar commuter's Ford F150 of a house. And to be clear people have hated McMansions since long before the "millenials," what a weird "fuck you, got mine" take.
- cyberax 4y ago> endless unnecessary fake flourishes So... Like pretty much all art?
- paconbork 4y agoWith you until the last sentence. The high prices for small condos in urban centers are an indication that there are fewer of them in supply relative to what the market demands. There's nothing wrong with letting urban centers densify and serve as a containment zone for childless 20-somethings (in fact, this would mean more affordable single family homes for those that need them). And who knows, if there's enough dense urban housing to meet demand, then those residents could have an easier saving up money themselves, with which to later purchase some more space in which to raise a family
- robocat 4y ago> The high prices for small condos in urban centers are an indication that there are fewer of them in supply relative to what the market demands. Be careful trying to apply ECON101 micro principles when looking at property markets: property markets are neither efficient, nor rational. > those residents could have an easier saving up money themselves In desirable property markets, people bid against each other as much as they can afford to pay for a mortgage - so your cause and effect is wrong - most people don’t get to save. Same analyses if renting, because landlords and renters do much the same behaviour. You get to save if (a) you are an undesirable market or time, or (b) your wages are enough to beat the majority, or (c) you stay in a lower status home compared to your peers.
- paconbork 4y agoPeople bidding whatever they can afford is largely a lack-of-supply problem, is it not? If more housing of a given status level were available, eventually it wouldn't be necessary for everyone to spend everything they can on bidding wars. And sure, then you might say "well then the relative status of that housing has shifted and your peers still aren't saving, they're just spending their money on nicer housing", but I still see that as an absolute win. I have much more empathy for a person not saving money when saving money means "living in a dump and commuting 90 minutes each way" than when it means "living more than half an hour away from Central Park".
- robocat 4y ago
- akomtu 4y agoUrbanism is unnatural, i.e. it's an anti-nature lifestyle. Rather than squashing people into concrete hives, the gov should be promoting small minimum-footprint houses on large lots. Brutalistic master-trucks as personal commute vehicles should go away for the same reason.
- crooked-v 4y agoEverything modern humans do is "unnatural", but I'd sure prefer most of it over being a hunter-gatherer with hookworms.
- defrost 4y agoAmitermes meridionalis and many other insects build huge urban environments that house hundreds of thousands to millions of their fellows (and farmed "animals"). Hunter gathers in Australia didn't see hookworm until colonists arrived with free ranging sheep and cattle. Pre colonialism people were healthy and spent approx four hours a day gathering food from known managed resources. The (North) American South was rife with hookworm in the 1910's prompting John D. Rockefeller to fund a massive public health and education program [1]. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3800113/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3800113/
- midoridensha 4y agoGreat! Let's go back to a hunter-gatherer lifestyle then. To make it work, since the ecosystem can't support very many people living that way, we'll have to trim the global population down to about 1 million, so we'll have to set up some big death camps to eliminate billions of excess people. You're volunteering to be first in the gas chamber, right?
- defrost 4y agoOdd comment. Where I live I grew up mingled with hunter gathers and to this day a large number are still there .. so I don't see any need for death camps and slaughtering billions. This is something you often think of then?
- _v7gu 4y agoThat is a lot of words to just say “cope+seethe”. Are macMansion suburbs even sustainable (i.e can cover infrastructure cost via taxes)? Do children who have no freedom and have to be driven everywhere turn out to be better adults? How does this additional work affect women and their place in the work force? Low density suburbs have quite a lot to prove in order to justify their existence.