5 ms·
The thing that American football provides that is absent in most other sports is the strategic match up on every down between offense and defense. That strategi
by guelo 15y ago
The thing that American football provides that is absent in most other sports is the strategic match up on every down between offense and defense. That strategic part adds a whole other level to the game which adds huge depth to the analysis that fans can dig into. The game that the coaches are playing by selecting plays against each other is more involved than in any other sport. Any replacement sport that I know of would be missing this important element.
- thrill 15y agoThe thing that American football brings that is absent in other sports in immense flexibility and opportunity for advertising between every down.
- brudgers 15y agoFutbol has continuous scrolling advertising along the boards in the stadium and often advertising next to the score when broadcasting. And of course there is advertising on the player's jerseys and other apparel - something which is anathema to American football. For NFL games, there are exactly three commercial breaks per quarter by broadcast contract - college is similar. After the contractual number of breaks, the broadcasters simply do not cut away.
- brudgers 15y agoGiven that baseball does not have special teams, there is no point in the game where it is not offense v. defense, and compared to baseball, football statistics are pretty shallow. Furthermore, one issue with football from a spectator standpoint is that the coaches so often seek the limelight at the expense of the players - there's more emoting than a amateur production of A Streetcar Named Desire. It is hardly something which attracts fans. What is unique is the level of violence for a team sport - it is the rare college or professional game in which someone is not carted off with an injury that puts them out for at least several weeks.
- philwelch 15y agoSoccer has a lot of tactical sophistication too, probably even more given that there are hundreds of competing professional teams in the world and not just 32, and out of that competition and diversity there have simply been more tactics that have been developed and attempted and put in competition against each other. Certainly there's more for the fans to dig into, because most of the interesting tactical information--not just the playbooks but also the overhead footage the NFL distributes to coaching staffs but doesn't make available to fans--is a trade secret of the NFL. Also, while there are certainly plenty of fine points in the game to obsess over, it's a less open game in general so there's less room for tactical variation. There's no way to turn attack into defense, defense into attack, or possession into both at the same time, but there are plenty of ways to make the opposing middle linebacker take a misstep and leave him two seconds late to react to the play and hence win an extra few yards.