3 ms·
We need a Linux for BMCs. Oxide is working on one, but I'd like to see a contender fielded from the seL4 community, along with some other folks. For example, wh
by hinkley 4y ago
We need a Linux for BMCs. Oxide is working on one, but I'd like to see a contender fielded from the seL4 community, along with some other folks. For example, why doesn't Wind River have one already?
- NexRebular 4y agoWhy linux? Why not *BSD?
- gaius_baltar 4y ago> Why linux? Why not *BSD? GPL can force manufacturers to cooperate with users. Of course, they can still use closed source binary modules and userland programs ...
- NexRebular 4y agoGPL can also turn manufacturers away. I would rather have variation in the possible BMC operating systems instead of sticking linux everywhere and contributing to a monoculture.
- ilyt 4y ago...which you wouldn't get with BSD as they'd just close it down and ship you binary, as they would have no obligation or reason to. The BSD "freedom" is not for the user of the software, it's for corporation to take.
- NexRebular 4y agoAnd how would this affect the original open BSD-based BMC firmware which would be available? If the corporations want to maintain their own fork, it's on them. The original BSD release will stay open and free for everyone to utilize.
- IntelMiner 4y agoHow can you trust that a closed source OpenBSD fork is secure when there's no way to audit the quality (or lack thereof) in the firmware the vendor gives you? If it's GPL you can at least interrogate the code release and make an informed decision
- NexRebular 4y agoThe same way I can trust all the binary blobs vendors stick into GPL-licensed systems. How do I make an informed decision about those?
- wmf 4y agoSoftware diversity is a luxury customers won't pay for.
- taneq 4y agoThat sure sounds appealing to manufacturers.
- wmf 4y agoOnce it reaches critical mass it is appealing because the value you receive from the community is far greater than what you have to give back.
- zrm 4y agoIf the point is code diversity, what stops you producing a fork of BSD for BMCs under the GPL?
- wmf 4y agoOpenBMC is the leader at this point.