6 ms·
Relentless driving is one of the things I feel the software industry has really done themselves a disservice in the long run. I know of several engineers who w
by freedomben 4y ago
Relentless driving is one of the things I feel the software industry has really done themselves a disservice in the long run. I know of several engineers who went on Adderall because their performance (relative to their peers) wasn't high enough. With the help of Adderall they were able to get to a similar level. Then that raises the "average" which leads to more people having to turn to heavy stimulants just to keep their jobs.
PMs and other management may feel like this is a win in the short term, but it isn't sustainable long term. The sheer number of software engineers who face burnout and/or have to take long multi-month sabbaticals to recover is shocking when compared to other industries where it's largely unheard of. Of course income is a factor (most other industries people don't make enough to allow them to take months off) but I don't think that explains all of it. I don't have any data to back this up beyond my own experience working in different industries, so take with a heap of salt.
After so many years of this, it catches up to you. The difficulty performing is (sometimes, not always) a natural sign that your mind is overworked and needs a break. Regularly pushing through that and even using medication to help you is not consequence free. It's not just your mind that breaks down but also your body (especially adrenals). You can't handle unhealthy levels of drive and stress in perpetuity.
Take care of your self and remember that long after the company has forgotten you, you're still tied to your mind and body. Take care of those things as IMHO they are the most valuable possessions you have.
- gtop3 4y agoThis is largely the same argument for why performance enhancing drugs are banned in sports.
- lisasays 4y agoPMs and other management may feel like this is a win in the short term, but it isn't sustainable long term. You're saying they were aware of the Adderall abuse as it was happening? Or just that they saw all these stellar high performers around them and thought, "What's not to like?"
- radlad 4y agoI think it's more like... employee is put on a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP), employee goes to doctor and gets an Adderall script, employee is taken off PIP and management considers this a job well done.
- wiml 4y ago> employee is taken off PIP Waittasec. That happens?
- echlebek 4y agoI was also under the impression that PIP was a way to slow-roast firing someone, not something that would be temporary.
- lisasays 4y agoIt is basically, and you're supposed to get the "hint". But the way it's structured - at least on paper, there's supposed to be some way in which you can pass the "test" and endure an extra run of gaslighting and ostracization until they figure out another way to get rid of you.
- lazide 4y ago50%ish of employees get off PIPs successfully (or used to anyways).
- iamevn 4y agoI got off one at Google but ended up burning out and quitting anyways so not really a success.
- lisasays 4y agoActually it is, and very substantially so -- in the sense that you left on your own terms rather than getting fired or laid off. Except for the burning out part. Which unfortunately seems to be the natural cost of spending any amount of time in this industry.
- badpun 4y ago> The sheer number of software engineers who face burnout and/or have to take long multi-month sabbaticals to recover is shocking when compared to other industries where it's largely unheard of. According to studies, there's tons of burnout in most industries - we're just the ones who can actually afford to take the sabbaticals.
- bazmattaz 4y agoYep this. The rest of us have to take sick leave
- yamtaddle 4y ago... or just suffer for years then eventually have your your life fall apart, because you've only got five sick days a year and you already used four of those taking care of sick kids who had to stay home from school, and it's only May. You could take your annual ten days of vacation, but you'll have trouble scheduling it as two full weeks in a row, and also that's not nearly enough to make much difference even if you could.
- lazide 4y agoYup. Lawyers and finance folks cried themselves to sleep at the parent comment.
- iLoveOncall 4y ago> but it isn't sustainable long term Why would they care? Long gone are the times where the majority of workers stayed at a company for a lifetime, so getting the most out of them for the few years that they will anyway stay is worth it in the eyes of their manager.
- juujian 4y agoInteresting. I had always though that Adderall might at a cost, I did not think it would be burnout. Was more curious how that would affect your sense of judgement etc. I am not primarily a coding person, and it always seemed more important to me to have well thought out ideas than how many lines I can write in an hour. So an environment where Adderall use is rampant, what does that even look like?
- edgyquant 4y agoMost code is boilerplate and adderall makes churning that out a breeze. It also allows you to quickly redo large amounts of code etc. I went through this myself at a former place and I moved so fast that I was managements favorite person- even though looking back a lot of the design decisions were short sighted. I eventually got better, so I have no idea how long a person can last before failing completely but it’s at least a year or two.
- juujian 4y agoThanks for the insight, that's really interesting, not just because it feeds into my bias. Those short-sighted design decisions are what I was vaguely thinking of, It is what often happens to me when I knock out a lot of work in a short period of time.
- jazzyjackson 4y agoI don't think it affects sense of judgement, it just allows you to stay on task and grind where you might otherwise give up / spin your wheels. The downside I see in the people around me is that the drug makes you feel physically fine even without proper eating or sleep, as long as you keep doing the drug. But of course eventually it catches up with you and I see people getting increasingly unreasonable, but its from not sleeping, not from the drug itself.
- penjelly 4y agoamphetamines definitely affect both impulse control and judgement
- idopmstuff 4y ago> The sheer number of software engineers who face burnout and/or have to take long multi-month sabbaticals to recover is shocking when compared to other industries where it's largely unheard of. Is there data to back this up? Also, if engineers do take sabbaticals at a significantly above-average rate, is that because others don't need them as much or because they don't have the financial resources and relatively easy ability to get a job post-sabbatical (speaking more historically than for the current hiring environment) that software engineers do? For context, I'm a PM who sometimes uses substances to help with work and has also taken a couple of sabbaticals, though I would not say the two are related. My sabbaticals aren't out of a deep need to recover from burnout, but because I'm very employable with plenty of savings. It's really nice to have a few months off, and interviewing is much more pleasant when it's your only job.
- sibeliuss 4y agoMy experience working with folks who claim ADD and treat it with Adderall is more akin to working with someone who has a drug problem. Sleeplessness, suddenly missing work, constantly forgetting to eat day after day, breakdowns, MIA in meetings, really poor code, and more. This has happened > 3 times in the past handful of years. My totally uninformed take is that these individuals emphatically do not suffer from ADD, but are victims of the "ADD software engineer industrial complex" that basically preys on folks who need a lot of focus to do their job. They get on powerful amphetamines, like it, go deeper, and then suddenly there's a _real_ health problem. It is a fact that these drugs are over-prescribed; it's basically a crisis. And there isn't nearly enough awareness of the dangers or the long-term impact on mental health. *Writing this as someone who has been down the addiction rabbit hole in the past, and knows the ropes.
- hirvi74 4y agoMy issue with the matter is that I have ADHD, and I didn't seek treatment because of wanting to perform better a my job. It's literally the difference between me keeping my job or not, not crashing my car into another person's vehicle, etc.. I still vastly under-perform compared to my peers despite being medicated. Any person that was taking stimulant medications without ADHD would absolutely blow me out of the water -- it's the main issue I have in regards to stimulants. It's be like a professional athlete taking steroids or other PEDs when competing against a high school aged sports team. When other people use stimulant medication for non-medical purposes then it causes me to be measured against an echelon of performance that is basically unobtainable i.e. the best I can function at is no longer "good enough." I mean, sure, there are probably a few other factors that also contribute to my issues other than just medication (lack of organization skills, past traumas, etc.), but it has been something I noticed even back when I was in college a decade ago. I knew plenty of people that faked symptoms to get a prescription. Meanwhile, I had to go through all kinds of testing, interviews, etc. to get legitimately diagnosed. However, I do not fault the individuals who take any substance medicinally or otherwise. We are all trying to make in this world, and I think a lot of our culture has created a demand that leaves many with no other options -- sink or swim.
- 4y ago
- prepend 4y agoI don’t think this is unique to programmers and is a “secret” to successful professionals for as long as drugs have been around. I was really surprised in business school how many students, guest lecturers, and pretty much everyone was on adderral, beta blockers (without medical necessity), or even cocaine and illegal stimulants. And part of many peoples “stacks” involved visits to specific doctors who would write scripts with combinations that let them focus and work very long hours. I agree with you on taking care of yourself but it was really illuminating the habits that people sustained for 30-50 years without any spectacular blowouts. Of course not everyone is so lucky, but I never imagined that people would sustain pharmaceutical benefits for so many decades as just part of their routine. Makes me wonder how many people maintaining 4am daily workouts are doing so without chemical assistance. Although I’ve known many people with really rigorous daily routines (running 8-12 miles) that claimed to abstain from everything, even caffeine and headphones.
- marviel 4y ago"Moloch"