4 ms·
"Intellectuals and society" by Thomas Sowell is an interesting book on the subject. His central thesis is that intellectuals -- "people whose occupations deal p
by olalonde 15y ago
"Intellectuals and society" by Thomas Sowell is an interesting book on the subject. His central thesis is that intellectuals -- "people whose occupations deal primarily with ideas - writers, academics, and the like" - are having negative effects.
http://www.amazon.com/Intellectuals-Society-Thomas-Sowell/dp/046501948X http://www.amazon.com/Intellectuals-Society-Thomas-Sowell/dp...
- uuilly 15y agoFantastic book. He also talks a lot about how being good at one thing doesn't make you good at another. Sowell's notion of effective intelligence is rooted more in experience than in aptitude. So a scientist with no political experience is less likely to be good at politics than someone of lesser intellect with that experience.
- yardie 15y agoOne example is president Jimmy Carter. Brilliant thinker, scientist and business man. Mediocre skills in leadership and absolutely dismal in working through beauracracy. He had the one-two punch of having an oil crisis and recession, unlike Obama he just couldn't get it turned around in time for the next election.
- arethuza 15y agoI could remember that Carter was in the US Navy - turns out he had a pretty interesting career there - including being in charge of a team disassembling an onshore experimental reactor after a meltdown! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jimmy_Carter#Naval_career http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jimmy_Carter#Naval_career
- ams6110 15y agoYeah I recall him touring Three Mile Island not long after the accident. Carter is not lacking intelligence, but his political skills were certainly lacking and his presidency was pretty much a debacle.
- kleiba 15y agoNegative effects on what?
- TheCapn 15y agoWithout reading the book I assume what he's getting at is that the sciences are often the barers of bad news. Cancer this, climate that, death this, unsafety that. Eventually people get fed up with having their worldview turned around and actively choose to ignore the incoming evidence. My best example would be cellphones in cars. We did just fine without them 10 years ago but now whenever an area talks about legistlation the people get all up in arms. Numerous studies have shown that they're equal or worse to drunk driving but the inconvenience of not being able to text and drive prevents people from accepting that. Disclaimer: I obviously could be very far off base of what the posted author speaks about because, as stated, I've not read the book.
- TwoBit 15y agoOf course Sowell would criticize intellectuals. He's an unapologetic conservative Republican.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- JVirissimo 15y agoYeah, but he's an...intellectual.
- anamax 15y ago> Of course Sowell would criticize intellectuals. He's an unapologetic conservative Republican. Bravo! No need to look at whether he's correct, he's a Republican.