6 ms·
The US would finally pay attention to soccer, like the rest of the world? That's practically the only other thing we can use the stadiums for, and since we've c
by philwelch 15y ago
The US would finally pay attention to soccer, like the rest of the world? That's practically the only other thing we can use the stadiums for, and since we've collectively invested billions of dollars in public funds to build the damn things it wouldn't make much sense to just demolish them.
Maybe without football, we'd be closer to finally decoupling youth sports from the education system.
- peteretep 15y agoOr they could change the rules a bit to be like Aussie-Rules or Rugby, which doesn't have this problem...
- jinushaun 15y agoThe addition of helmets, shoulder pads and downs which evolved rugby into American football meant harder hits and higher likelihood of concussions. Rugby doesn't have these problems because the fast non-stop fluid nature of the game means you can't tackle someone hard enough to cause the same level of damage because you have to be able to get up and run again right away. The stop-start nature of American football promotes tackling someone as hard as they can because you can always recover between plays.
- raganwald 15y agoOr you can be replaced on the field by another player while you wait for the blurry vision to go away. I have always wondered what football would be like if you changed just one thing: Limit substitutions to one per half like Soccer and thus, obviously, force all players to play offence, defence, and special team plays.
- peteretep 15y agoI also thought this, but it's not true! American Football was always this violent, even before the pads. They managed to kill 19 (NINETEEN) people playing it in 1905, well before the helmets came in (1939ish, although: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_football_helmet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_football_helmet).
- patrickk 15y ago"Rugby doesn't have these problems because the fast non-stop fluid nature of the game means you can't tackle someone hard enough to cause the same level of damage because you have to be able to get up and run again right away." Rugby doesn't have these problems because there are very specific rules about what constitutes a legal tackle and what doesn't. You can't: - Tackle a player without the ball - Tackle a player in the air (e.g. a full-back going up to catch a high ball) - "Lifting a player from the ground and dropping or driving that player into the ground whilst that player’s feet are still off the ground such that the player’s head and/or upper body come into contact with the ground is dangerous play."[1] - Many more [1] Full list here - http://www.irblaws.com/downloads/EN/Law_10_EN.pdf http://www.irblaws.com/downloads/EN/Law_10_EN.pdf
- huggyface 15y agoMaybe without football, we'd be closer to finally decoupling youth sports from the education system. Going off track, but by finally are you saying that's a positive thing? I'm a nerd. I've always been a nerd. I had the absolute minimum mandatory participation in sports during school. That is one of my biggest regrets. Sports have incredible importance in so many ways.
- freehunter 15y agoPhysical and team activities are important. Sports and sport stars are less so. It's nice to have the "team" to look up to in school, since we are social creatures and demand to belong to something greater than ourselves (and alpha males demand attention from the lessers), but there aren't many people who participate in the high school football team. It'd be nice to transition those funds into a more well-rounded physical/team activities department.
- huggyface 15y agoThe post I replied to opined that "Maybe without football, we'd be closer to finally decoupling youth sports from the education system.": Their issue wasn't just with football, and instead football was the beachhead to try to excise physical activity. In my high school there were a large number of prominent sports, with participation covering a hefty percentage of the student base. Wrestling, basketball, football, swimming, badminton, track and field, volleyball, among others. There was something for almost anyone, and it was a fundamental part of the social, learning, and physical wellness recipe. The school heavily promoted and celebrated academic excellence as well (and, contrary to the common bigotry, many of the academic leaders -- the ones who I competed with -- excelled at sports as well). If a particular school focused only on football, then of course that would be a problem.
- freehunter 15y agoI think you and I read that sentence differently. I don't believe the author of that post meant that physical exercise is a bad thing in schools, but rather sports stars should not be "better" or "different" from any other student. At my school (and a lot of schools judging from people I met in college), we had dozens of sports but only football and basketball players were routinely excused from class for practice, drills, and travel to games. Only football had their travel expenses paid for by the school. You were at a severe disadvantage if you decided to play any other sport. What I read that post as saying is "sports should be extracurricular activities that do not interfere with or take the place of education". This doesn't necessarily preclude your normal PE classes.