3 ms·
It's not a well-written paragraph because it deals with both Eleanor and the family and it's not immediately obvious what "they" is referring to in one or two s
by ghaff 4y ago
It's not a well-written paragraph because it deals with both Eleanor and the family and it's not immediately obvious what "they" is referring to in one or two spots.
That said, singular-they is pretty much the best alternative to dealing with a number of issues that copy editors have struggled with for years.
- ghostbrainalpha 4y agoWhy can't we just make a new pronoun that is "they" but singular? Like "Theya". Theya is my friend. It's singular, non gendered, and then we can just get rid of every pronoun except "they" and "theya".
- ghaff 4y agoBecause it's much easier to get people to use an existing pronoun in a way that historically would have been considered a bit sloppy than it is to get them to adopt a new non-sex gendered but non-neutral coined pronoun. (It's actually been tried in the past.)
- dctoedt 4y agoIt worked pretty well with "Ms." back in the day. (I know, I know, it's not a pronoun.)
- klodolph 4y agoHonorifics are more of an “open class”… https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Part_of_speech#Open_and_closed_classes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Part_of_speech#Open_and_closed... This really just a way of rephrasing what the parent comment says. By some reckonings, in English, pronouns are a closed class, and verbs are an open class. Some languages have it the other way around, where you can invent new pronouns but not new verbs (you have to take a noun X and say “do X” or something like that).
- ghaff 4y agoMs. did have its own political angle but but when it did finally become mainstream in the late 60s/early 70s, I'm not sure that there were too many people ready to go to the mat for public honorifics that distinguished whether a woman--and only a woman--was married or not. (And at least some people who probably reflexively opposed the change at first, changed their mind later on.) But honorifics are tricky and some people feel very strongly about them--e.g. Dr. for someone with a PhD.
- WorldMaker 4y agoIt's easier to do what happened to "you" (also previously the plural), form entirely new plurals akin to "you all". "They all" reads pretty well to me and I'm personally very curious if "th'all" works as well as "y'all" and have been subtly experimenting with it to see who notices.