3 ms·
Mastodon does not currently support importing posts from your old account. Just followers/following. It's a nuisance, and there's nothing preventing it per se,
by vidarh 4y ago
Mastodon does not currently support importing posts from your old account. Just followers/following. It's a nuisance, and there's nothing preventing it per se, since the posts are signed, but that part could be better.
- jeroenhd 4y agoI know, and although I understand why (ActivityPub IDs are generally URLs and changing them would probably cause duplicates, but there are URLs that don't change). It's quite annoying that it can't be done right now, but I'll admit that I also don't care enough to come up with a patch for it.
- vidarh 4y agoThere are two ways around this: 1. They are URI's, and while ActivityPub say they should be https URL's, they don't need to be, and could e.g. point at IPFS or similar. 2. JSON-LD signatures are used by Mastodon, and included in the export, and nothing stops another instance from validating those and serving them up with the original URIs in the id from new URLs, as a means of making it clear the server didn't originate them (there'd be a trust issue if the other servers is unable to get hold of the keys because the original server is gone, but no more so than if the new server had simply republished the content, so the "worst case" is to distrust the original id's). There are some corner cases there, around trusting the identity of the old and new account represents the same user, so I do think a recovery key type scheme would be nice to allow a user to prove the old and new id is the same (if changing id; I also think we could really use decoupling the expectation that a webfinger id is inherently tied to a Mastodon account - you can sort of do that today; nothing stops you from serving up a separate webfinger result and use it as an alias, but there are usability issues to solve there).
- jeroenhd 4y agoYou're right, there's actually no reason why a second server couldn't serve up toots with the old IDs. The main problem would probably be keeping track of what server to fetch these messages from after a move (or even a second move) to a different server and keeping the metadata attached in sync.
- mkr-hn 4y agoCalckey recently gained the ability to migrate posts. Even from Mastodon. Maybe that'll motivate Mastodon and the forks to prioritize it.
- vidarh 4y agoThat's great. I'll have to take a look.