4 ms·
I can't find anything online to support that. Everything I find says that to be illegal, something must be against the law, and that a contract is not law, so
by crazygringo 4y ago
I can't find anything online to support that.
Everything I find says that to be illegal, something must be against the law, and that a contract is not law, so the word "illegal" doesn't apply to breach of contract because it's private.
There is a difference between illegality and criminality however -- e.g. breaking the speed limit is illegal but it doesn't reach criminal, as one source uses as an example.
- jerry80 4y agoActually, speeding is criminal in many states.
- Osiris 4y agoAre traffic infractions criminal? Violating some traffic laws can be a misdemeanor or felony while most are infractions. I don’t know if infraction is considered “criminal”.
- wildzzz 4y agoIf all you get from the cop is a summons, it's not a crime but more akin to a civil infraction.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Are traffic infractions criminal? This is often actually an area where toubwill find conflicting info; public info provided by the California state courts says yes, they are, in California [0], while you will find other sources, including law offices, saying they aren’t. [1] The issue is largely that they are structured as crimes in state law, but the manner of punishment available does not make them “crimes” within the purview of federal Constitutional protections, or federal statutory consequences for conviction of state crimes (e.g., in the immigration system.) [0] https://www.courts.ca.gov/documents/CIP_AboutCriminalCases.pdf https://www.courts.ca.gov/documents/CIP_AboutCriminalCases.p... [1] https://www.shouselaw.com/ca/defense/infractions/ https://www.shouselaw.com/ca/defense/infractions/
- zamnos 4y agoAlmost all states have drinking and driving (DUI/DWI) as misdemeanors and it's a misdemeanor federally.
- dexterdog 4y agoName two
- jerry80 4y agoSince you're too busy to do basic research to answer your own curiosity, of course I'll let you know that speeding is a misdemeanor in Alabama, Arkansas, Delaware, Georgia, Iowa, Louisiana, Maryland, Mississippi, Montana, Nevada, Ohio, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, West Virginia, Wyoming. I'm sure I'm missing a few.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Everything I find says that to be illegal, something must be against the law. A breach of contract is against, and has remedies provided under, the law of contracts.. > A contract is not law No, but the law of contracts is law.
- crazygringo 4y agoBut this isn't a question of logic, it's a question of definition. And all the discussion I can find online say breaking a contract doesn't fall under the definition of "illegal". Do you have an authoritative source that defines it otherwise?
- nobody9999 4y ago>And all the discussion I can find online say breaking a contract doesn't fall under the definition of "illegal". IIUC, breaking a contract is a civil tort[0]: A tort is an act or omission that gives rise to injury or harm to another and amounts to a civil wrong for which courts impose liability. In the context of torts, "injury" describes the invasion of any legal right, whereas "harm" describes a loss or detriment in fact that an individual suffers.1 And torts (again, IIUC) are not the breaking of a legal code, and as such cannot be illegal, as they break no laws. Something illegal is dealt with in a criminal court (yes, there are administrative courts in various places that handle minor infractions, but those are governed under the relevant legal code and are adjudicated as such. Civil torts are not contained within any legal code, and as such cannot be illegal. That said, there are some harms that may also rise to the level of criminality (e.g., fraud), which may also have a civil tort associated with them. But breach of contract by itself is just breaking the rules[1] agreed upon by the parties to a contract. [0] https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/tort https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/tort [1] https://kids.britannica.com/kids/article/rules-and-laws/628637 https://kids.britannica.com/kids/article/rules-and-laws/6286...
- ElFitz 4y ago> Civil torts are not contained within any legal code, and as such cannot be illegal. Doesn’t that depend on the country? Would it also be true in civil law countries? Or only in common law countries?
- darreninthenet 4y agoThat depends on the country... speeding in the UK, for example, absolutely is a criminal offence. In fact, in the UK, apart from a tiny number of civil matters used in criminal law, breaking the law (ie doing something illegal) is always a criminal offence.
- judge2020 4y agodragonwriter and others here are both right. In terms of language, the terms are the same, in that you are a criminal if you violate the law. However, in many countries and regions "criminal" can be a way to discern that certain crimes come with specific punishments, like jail time or personal fines. For example, in the US there's criminal and civil cases. You can't be incarcerated for losing a civil suit, unless you don't pay whatever judgement the court discerns (which is considered criminal contempt of court). In the US the difference also comes into play in terms of who can bring certain charges against you. If you were to sue someone, you can't sue them for assault and battery or homicide, because these are considered criminal charges and only the District Attorney / the government can bring these charges against someone. In this case, there are typically parallel civil remedies you can sue for, such as "wrongful death" and "emotional distress" which is strictly to recuperate financial loss.