5 ms·
This isn't really a technical issue, per-se. It's a social one, because social means are what are used to enforce the lockdowns - and those social means exist
by lazide 4y ago
This isn't really a technical issue, per-se.
It's a social one, because social means are what are used to enforce the lockdowns - and those social means exist because of socially justified purposes in the societies.
Unless it was literally impossible to block internet access at all (some kind of unjammable starlink with undetectable receivers/transceivers?).
- Dalewyn 4y agoGenerally speaking, any kind of radio transmission is detectable. It's why radio silence is a thing when stealth is important.
- lazide 4y agoThe tricky thing is that receiving radio transmissions is also usually detectable - and a transceiver has to, by it's nature, transmit. [https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/5699393 https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/5699393]
- mlyle 4y ago> The tricky thing is that receiving radio transmissions is also usually detectable A LNB is pretty quiet to begin with... and the LO is on the same frequency whether you're watching satellite TV or tapping into Othernet. You could, of course, make it much quieter still. Just because a lot of receivers leak a lot of oscillator and mixer frequencies doesn't mean it's intrinsic. > and a transceiver has to, by it's nature, transmit. Which is why I was talking about a receive-only approach. (Well, also for reasons of scalability).
- lazide 4y agoWell, that is also fundamentally not an internet.
- mlyle 4y agoWell, I thought I made that pretty clear in what I posted. "Maybe the internet as a whole is intractable. But perhaps we can get a meaningful digest of snapshots of the important stuff that can work over slow links, intermittent links, and one-way links?"
- lazide 4y agoSince the whole point of the internet is, you know, people can request what they want and communicate with others, and they already HAVE people shoving ‘important stuff’ their way, what exactly do you think that adds to the picture?
- mlyle 4y ago> what exactly do you think that adds to the picture? - Othernet is already a system out of local control that can be received with relatively trivial equipment. - 2000bps feels perhaps a bit too slow, but with an order of magnitude more bandwidth, you could have a -lot- of textual communication. It could carry a big cross-section of what everyone is saying and allow people to choose what they see. - An ideal system would support multiple transports; Othernet, intermittent wifi connectivity, sneakernet, etc. It would do the best with what it can to get data in or out, and allocate the scarce resources to the traffic which is most likely to be useful to others (this is tricky, with sybil attacks, etc... but I don't think it's necessarily intractable). That is-- I love the interactive internet, but wouldn't it be cool if it gracefully degraded to still provide "postcards" and "broadcast radio" and a bit more as capacity went down, intermittency went up, and inability to return traffic was sometimes a factor?
- MichaelZuo 4y ago> That is-- I love the interactive internet, but wouldn't it be cool if it gracefully degraded to still provide "postcards" and "broadcast radio" and a bit more as capacity went down, intermittency went up, and inability to return traffic was sometimes a factor? This already exists, it's called ham radio. There are even large communities of folks sending 'postcards' to each other on a regular basis.
- 7373737373 4y agoSpread spectrum, and especially pseudo-random noise codes are pretty hard to detect i think https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct-sequence_spread_spectrum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct-sequence_spread_spectru...
- lazide 4y agoThe more random it is, the harder it is to have certainty, but at high enough transmission rates and powers the raised noise floor is impossible to miss and is definitely something that can be triangulated. If a normal radio transmission is a point light of a specific color, truly random spread spectrum is a grey glow. Direct sequence spread spectrum being many different color flashing lights here, I guess.
- mlyle 4y ago> Unless it was literally impossible to block internet access at all (some kind of unjammable starlink with undetectable receivers/transceivers?). Yah, these types of things would be hard to detect (just point an LNB at the southbound sky... no dish... cheap electronics...) What it's not is turnkey or filled with a good feed of information that people would want at baseline. There's no adoption model besides being a dissident, and people tend to start planning for that too late.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoStarlink dishes are trivial to detect with even 1990s military technology when active. There's no way any satellite uplink can be hidden from a motivated adversary.
- mlyle 4y agoYes, but we're not talking about Starlink. I'm talking about Othernet, which I mentioned above. It is receive only-- not an uplink. (I'm sure a tiny bit of RF leaks out of the LNB, but that could be mitigated as it is not designed for stealth).
- lazide 4y agoSounds useless for the internet (where every protocol is fundamentally two way), but great for ‘Radio America’ type broadcasts. Of course, so is shortwave. definitely not solving the same ‘problem’ at all though.
- mlyle 4y agoYou're replying to a thread where I started by saying "Maybe the internet as a whole is intractable."
- runsWphotons 4y agocould you say this seven more times?