3 ms·
> Industrial farming depends on oil as a chemical input, because the soil has been sterilized and turned into dirt in most places by ammonia based fertilizers.
by cyberax 4y ago
> Industrial farming depends on oil as a chemical input, because the soil has been sterilized and turned into dirt in most places by ammonia based fertilizers. The process of tilling the land resulted in most of the remaining dirt being eroded over the past century.
What a piece of nonsense bullshit.
1. Ammonia can be produced without any oil. Natural gas (not oil per se) is simply used as an easy way to produce hydrogen and the heat energy needed.
2. Nitrogen fertilizers do not "sterilize" the soil. Not even close to it. They in fact can cause bacterial overgrowth, as nitrogen is often the limiting nutrient for anything. Soil with fertilizer is extremely fertile for both agricultural plants and for microbial life.
3. Nitrogen fertilizers are _essential_ to survival. Without them, quite literally billions will starve.
4. "Soil depletion" is typically caused by the lack of micronutrients such as potassium, and can be managed by (you guessed it!) adding fertilizers. Some other causes such as salt accumulation due to irrigation are more complicated.
> Without that oil to turn into fertilizer, the only other chance is to have ruminants actively managed on a regenerative farm growing both meat and produce.
Sigh. People should REALLY learn how the nitrogen cycle works.
- colechristensen 4y agoThe future of land management is going to be cultivating, curating, and generally taking care of the living, mostly fungal, part of the soil which will displace some or all of the straight up chemical additions instead enhancing the natural symbioses between root, fungus, and bacteria on an industrial scale... but until then chemical additions are fine. The issue going forward is going to be cost not an existential threat.
- cyberax 4y agoWhat a LOAD of bull. Look, the hard truth is, nitrogen is the limiting nutrient. A square kilometer of plants can fix only so much of it on its own via symbiotic bacteria (and maaaaybe archaea), fungi can NOT fix nitrogen on their own. You can optimize, curate, cultivate, paint yourself in dog shit and chant at the full moon however long you want, but there's a hard practical limit on that amount. And that's it. Animals can concentrate nitrogen into manure, but they don't produce more of it. That's why fertilizers are absolutely essential, as long as the Earth's population is above ~2B.
- maxerickson 4y agoAbundant solar means you can just rip the nitrogen right out of the air. Sounds like the cost is in the ballpark already: https://www.pv-magazine.com/2022/01/19/pulling-fertilizer-out-of-thin-air-with-pv/ https://www.pv-magazine.com/2022/01/19/pulling-fertilizer-ou...
- colechristensen 4y agoIt all just comes out of the air. High temperature, high pressure, air, hydrogen, and a catalyst. Methane is just a cheaper source of hydrogen than water. Hard to tell if this startup is really something because all you can find is articles built from press releases. The part about transportation is mostly moot, in the Midwest the fertilizer plants are local, there was one like twenty miles away from the farm i grew up on. Decoupling from the energy markets would be nice, but it’s doubtful anybody really wants to become a pricecutting commodity here. Farm inputs have the tendency to be as expensive as farmers can afford.
- biorach 4y agoThis is speculative technology, still in early prototype phase
- maxerickson 4y agoSure. The approach is very likely to be viable (we know that electric arcs produce fixed nitrogen), the reason to point to the specific technology is that they think the pricing just about works.
- biorach 4y ago"very likely..." "they think" Until this thing is operating profitably at scale it is unproven