3 ms·
Your argument is too powerful. It proves engineering as a whole is impossible. It equally proves we should never build any sort of building, because it could fa
by jerf 15y ago
Your argument is too powerful. It proves engineering as a whole is impossible. It equally proves we should never build any sort of building, because it could fall down and kill people and we can never be 100% sure we've prevented it.
It's an irrational appeal to emotion dressed up in rational trappings.
- pash 15y ago> Your argument is too powerful. It proves engineering as a whole is impossible. No. It's an argument that we have no good way of estimating the damage caused by rare, spectacular failures in complex systems. But thanks for the down-vote. > It's an irrational appeal to emotion dressed up in rational trappings. No. It's pointing out an epistemic hole, one that is essentially the reverse of the sunrise problem [0], that has been discussed by countless philosophers of science, probability theorists, and scientists across dozens of fields. I suggest you read the article I linked and some of the papers it cites rather than make a spectacle of your downright hurr-durr ignorance of the subject. 0. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunrise_problem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunrise_problem