5 ms·
It's a survival strategy, near as I can tell. Frankly, even really understanding the moment is impossible, let alone something as distant as the past, or the a
by lazide 4y ago
It's a survival strategy, near as I can tell.
Frankly, even really understanding the moment is impossible, let alone something as distant as the past, or the as yet not-existing future.
That's true for the individual, and the society.
Enlightenment MIGHT come close, but the first thing in traditions that have that as an option/goal is realizing that, well, knowing things objectively/without delusions is basically actually impossible and the concept of 'us' or 'I' is basically one of those delusions. We can have FEWER delusions, and with luck we can be aware of most of them, but we can't really have zero.
So we constrict our information, scope, and framing down to what we consider useful in that moment, and the narratives come from that. Sometimes it's pretty close to 'truth' (as in, matches objectively verifiable facts with a minimal amount of suspension of disbelief, fantasy, or outright delusion), and provides useful information.
sometimes... well, it does not. Often/usually, frankly.
It requires extremely rigorous approaches to get close to anything else, and frankly the forest gets lost for the trees 99.99% of the time.
True for the individual, and for the society too.
- MichaelZuo 4y ago> Frankly, even really understanding the moment is impossible, let alone something as distant as the past, or the as yet not-existing future. I thought that too before, but now I'm not so sure. Human individuals don't differ from each other that much. Sure there's a wide spectrum of physical and mental attributes such as intelligence, perseverance, confidence, etc. But the basic motivations and behavioural patterns are close to identical, bar really exceptional outliers like Napoleon or von Neumann.
- lazide 4y agoThere was a time when I would have believed that too. It’s a probabilistic type view, which in general, on average works out to be mostly correct. In the physics analogy, I imagine thinking of it like heat. But, if you pick any individual, just like if you go to an individual atom, you will find that velocity, position, etc. is still impossible to predict except as probabilities on a curve. And unlike atoms, people have strong incentives to lie (to themselves and others), and a rather impressive ability to do so. And given enough atoms/people or time, you WILL find the truly unpredictable. And you will often find the nonsensical, the self destructive, etc. The general human motivations (or at least what we perceive them as) are also statistical averages. It doesn’t take much looking to find folks with very, very different ways of acting on them than what we’d consider normal. Due to this fractal nature of the complexity of reality, it is a delusion thinking anyone can understand the moment. Truly, anyways. Everything is through a lens, it has to be, or it would be impossible to comprehend at all.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoEven someone with a large iron rod rammed through their brain (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phineas_Gage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phineas_Gage) doesn't deviate that much from the median, at least not as much as the aformentioned examples of Napoleon, von Neumann, etc... So it seems difficult to believe anyone currently alive and capable of walking around can be meaningfully even more different. Of course people can claim a limitless degree of difference, but their actual behaviour is what matters, not verbal claims.
- lazide 4y agoHuh? Phineas Gage completely switched personality, including behavior. What exactly do you consider to be ‘degree of difference’? [https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_serial_killers_by_number_of_victims https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_serial_killers_by_nu...]? [https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:American_female_serial_killers https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:American_female_ser...]? Ghenghis Khan? And that isn’t even counting the vast, unending sea of often bizarre mental illness out there. The ones you see make a list are functional enough to cause notable damage, which fundamentally restrains them within a certain band of functionality. The ones who are functional enough to stay alive long enough to make an impact on the world at all will restrain it at an even more outlying band. That means you can form probabilities and distributions - but you can’t really know individuals for sure. As anyone who’s been married to someone and had kids with them who later turned out to be gay, or cheating, or whatever can attest - good luck.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoYes I would classify Genghis Khan, Napoleon, etc., as probably even farther from the median adult human then Phineas Gage type oddities. But this is splitting hairs since the main point is that the maximal case can't possibly be that much more extreme then already well documented cases. Because only the observable actions of humans in the world is after all what we're capable of perceiving directly. And this is limited to what their body, including vocal chords, is physically capable of doing, no matter how many mental irregularities they have. Or are you confused about something else? It's unclear what the meaning of the rest of your comment is.