3 ms·
There's a lot of people arguing about OSS vs FOSS. opensource.org has a specific definition but this is not universally accepted (there's a lot on this in the w
by godelski 4y ago
There's a lot of people arguing about OSS vs FOSS. opensource.org has a specific definition but this is not universally accepted (there's a lot on this in the wiki page btw). Stallman even wrote about this[0].
If you're passionately arguing and downvoting others that are claiming that ImageBind is in fact OSS then you're also actively demonstrating naivety. Definitions are not always universal and this is an easy to verify example. Instead of just posting another link to opensource.org read their about section[1] and consider why that leads to non-universality. And maybe also consider the words themselves: is the source available? Even if the only correct definition were from opensource.org, I'd expect everyone here to have some understanding why others might be confused since the words imply something different. There's some evidence to the other side's view, so it isn't obscene or idiotic. You don't have to accept the other view, just consider its existence.
Take a step back and consider that your view isn't the only possible one. Maybe we can have more constructive discussions if we do so. We don't need these holy wars, they don't accomplish anything.
[0] https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/open-source-misses-the-point.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/open-source-misses-the-point....
[1] https://opensource.org/about/ https://opensource.org/about/
- getcrunk 4y agoIt’s not about what views are possible. It’s about honesty and humility which are both things the modern world doesn’t seem to care about. The more narrow definition of oss (rms/gnu) is un ambiguous as is the meaning of source available. People choosing to use oss with the ambiguous meaning are liable for their ambiguity, and therefore worthy of op’s criticism.
- two_in_one 4y agoTerms wars. I'm glad we don't have to say 'GNU Linux' anymore.
- jlokier 4y agoTrue. We call it 'Android' now, or 'ChromeOS'. Some argue we should acknowledge the important historical contribution made by the Linux project to the most widely used operating system in the world, but others argue that Linux is only a small component in a larger system, especially when they count lines of code, so it does not merit mention. /s (Above is a paraphrase of the now old argument why GNU did or did not merit mention in names of Linux-based operating systems. Now we have reached the point where Linux doesn't get a mention either).
- godelski 4y agoStallman puts it well >> Why do people misunderstand it that way? Because that is the natural meaning of the words “open source.” But the concept for which the open source advocates sought another name was a variant of that of free software. >> Since the obvious meaning for “open source” is not the meaning that its advocates intend, the result is that most people misunderstand the term. > It’s about honesty and humility Good faith arguments recognize this obvious meaning. I would not buy it if anyone claimed that any other definition was an obvious conclusion from the term "Open Source Software." But as you're talking about the modern world, I find that this kind of terminology and reaction is quite common. I'm not sure why, but it we see it in a lot of political sayings and these just lead to arguments. You're right, we need to have a little honest and humility and recognize that if you need a paragraph to explain a 2-5 word slogan that it isn't an obvious interpretation. (I've advocated for abandoning some terms in favor of others and the pushback is not on proposed alternative terminology but rather someone giving me a lecture on the original phrasing and how I don't understand it. That's unproductive, as we see similar events in other comments below).
- getcrunk 4y agoTouche, I’m unmoved but you make good points. Notwithstanding your point about the “obvious” meaning, I think it’s clear who is doing what with their word choices.
- thrtythreeforty 4y agoI see your point. And I understand that the term is understood differently by different people. But there is a substantial fraction of people (myself included) who understands it the way OSI defines it. My criticism is not that Facebook chooses to release the software under any particular terms (they are well within their rights not to release it at all). But the ambiguity of the term remains, and my belief is that Facebook is well aware of the ambiguity and nevertheless chooses to use it in bad faith, and that is what frustrates me. A less-ambiguous press release might instead say "source released under a non-commercial research license" or more succinctly "model code available for researchers," which sounds just fine.
- 4y ago