The argument boils down to "we think it's fair use". This has been explained quite a few times. Will that hold up in court? I don't know. Should that hold up in

The argument boils down to "we think it's fair use". This has been explained quite a few times. Will that hold up in court? I don't know. Should that hold up in court? Each can have their own opinion on that. But it's definitely been explained, as well as discussed at great length many times before on HN.