2 ms·
Given that SLS works and Starship has failed pretty spectacularly so far (engines failing off the gate and in flight, launch site damage, failed to detonate on
by tsimionescu 4y ago
Given that SLS works and Starship has failed pretty spectacularly so far (engines failing off the gate and in flight, launch site damage, failed to detonate on demand), I think it's about time to stop saying SLS is just pork.
- cubefox 4y agoSLS may be further ahead in development (though the version that launched is far from the final one), but it is much worse than Starship in nearly every other aspect. This is consensus in the space community, it has been discussed to death. Edit: The most significant thing Starship is bad at is launching and landing humans. Human launch systems like Falcon 9/Dragon or SLS/Orion have both a launch abort system and a highly reliable "blunt capsule" method of landing humans back on Earth. For Starship, both launching and landing humans is much more dangerous, as it doesn't have a launch abort system and it uses a complex maneuver ("belly flop") in order to land. Starship will need to do a lot of unmanned satellite launches to prove a safety level acceptable for humans. Or people transfer to and from Starship in space, as in Artemis 3, and start/land with a different rocket.
- pfdietz 4y agoSLS basically has a single purpose: funneling money to particular contractors. There is no objective in space that couldn't be done more cheaply with F9 and FH, given propellant transfer and some in-space assembly.
- GolfPopper 4y ago>Given that SLS works A cost of $27,000,000,000 per launch, and a launch rate of 1 per 132 months is a generous definition of "works". And that's where SLS is right now.
- cubefox 4y agoI think it is "just" 4 billion per launch, though of course this doesn't include the development costs. Regardless, the costs are staggering compared to Falcon 9, Falcon Heavy, Vulcan, or Starship.