3 ms·
I can't find it now, but about a year ago there was an article by some professors with an extensive analysis what Starship could do for space science. Their po
by cubefox 4y ago
I can't find it now, but about a year ago there was an article by some professors with an extensive analysis what Starship could do for space science.
Their point was that Starship has a big potential to significantly reduce cost by enabling the development of devices that are less optimized for size and weight. For example, the extremely expensive JWST could have been built with a much cheaper, non-foldable mirror, since the Starship fairing has a quite large diameter.
But they also argued that there is an unfortunate tendency in science to overoptimize everything, which leads to exploding cost. So it is well possible that scientists won't use Starship to reduce the cost of their spacecrafts, but to optimize them for maximum performance like they did before, e.g. by designing complex foldable mirrors which barely fit into the Starship fairing.
So I guess if they do that, Starship would enable an even stronger cost explosion than in the past, not a cost reduction. More available mass and size means more opportunity to spend money on complex engineering. The launch costs themselves are not a significant factor here.
- vl 4y agoInteresting consideration: Starship is monolithic right now, ie it’s unclear how it can unload payload of its own size. There are no bay doors a-la shuttle. I guess they will have to do tilt-away nose section or something.
- cubefox 4y agoFrom the official Starship users guide: > The Starship payload fairing is a clamshell structure in which the payload is integrated. Once integrated, the clamshell fairing remains closed through launch up until the payload is ready to deploy. An example sequence of payload deployment is shown in Figure 3. To deploy the payload, the clamshell fairing door is opened, and the payload adapter and payload are tilted at an angle in preparation for separation. The payload is then separated using the mission-unique payload adapter. If there are multiple payloads on a single mission, a rotating mechanism can be provided to allow each satellite to separate with maximum clearance. Once separation is confirmed and the payload(s) have cleared the fairing, the payload fairing door is closed in preparation for Starship’s return to Earth. Figure 3: https://i.stack.imgur.com/D3MYv.png https://i.stack.imgur.com/D3MYv.png Full PDF: https://www.spacex.com/media/starship_users_guide_v1.pdf https://www.spacex.com/media/starship_users_guide_v1.pdf
- pfdietz 4y agoOr, it means teams and organizations that can't control cost don't make the discoveries, and are weeded out.
- simonh 4y agoCost control is largely about correctly predicting costs. So teams that correctly predict costs will select lower performing but affordable instruments. Teams that fail at that may well under predict costs, over engineer their systems and end up with super expensive but super capable systems.
- cubefox 4y agoCurrently NASA makes most space based discoveries, while not at all being able to control cost, as JWST has shown. The reason NASA isn't weeded out is that they have a quite large budget and only competition that is also bad at controlling cost: other space agencies.
- giantrobot 4y ago> they have a quite large budget That is a hilarious statement.
- cubefox 4y ago> FY 2023, the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) had $32.37 Billion distributed among its 1 sub-components. https://www.usaspending.gov/agency/national-aeronautics-and-space-administration?fy=2023 https://www.usaspending.gov/agency/national-aeronautics-and-... Pretty sure there is no space organization which comes close.