> Asking me not to give a copy to Joe after telling me I can give a copy to whomever I want is unreasonable. This is a repetition of your claim, not an argumen

> Asking me not to give a copy to Joe after telling me I can give a copy to whomever I want is unreasonable. This is a repetition of your claim, not an argument for it. Counterpoint: It's entirely reasonable to ask you not to give a copy to Joe.