4 ms·
> The reason is that an important part of their ownership rights, i.e. the freedom to use the software of their choice, has been withheld from them. Thank you
by jgerrish 3y ago
> The reason is that an important part of their ownership rights, i.e. the freedom to use the software of their choice, has been withheld from them.
Thank you for your comment and info. But be careful, this is the wrong argument here. They are still letting you use the software you choose.
We can look at this move conceptually, keeping in mind the future. Here's one possible outcome.
You need to phone in first. Imagine the phone is just an IMEI number or a serial number, or one part of a key pair. In a future regime, phoning in marks that phone as no longer "trustworthy". It's now in the digital quarantine or isolation pile. And future network services will isolate the device appropriately.
Phoning in doesn't change what software you can install. It possibly changes who you can interact with.
I don't know if the argument can be won.
We could come up with examples where people were isolated wrongly with other technologies. But there's a subtle psychological trick there about solitary confinement and forcing a family of networks and social interactions. Using that argument reinforces the network that limited us. I don't want to hurt that network. But it also limits us.
And the alternative, hidden network lockouts, is also troubling. So, lose lose I guess?
I don't think I have the power to change the story.
- pbasista 3y ago> They are still letting you use the software you choose. At the moment, yes. My point was primarily about the fact that giving the customer an option to use Android software of their choice on recent Pixel phones is currently fully up to the manufacturer. Phoning in is merely a tool to achieve it. > possibly changes who you can interact with I am aware that identifying customers who have requested to have this option can potentially be used to mistreat them. Many mobile apps today are already trying to perform a similar form of identification. They check for non-OEM software or root access. If they detect something they do not like, they show warnings or refuse to provide some functionality. But that is, I think, another topic.