4 ms·
>Fundamentally most non-religious people are utilitarians, who see no inherent value in a life and hence are open to the idea of sacrificing a few lives for the
by krapp 4y ago
>Fundamentally most non-religious people are utilitarians, who see no inherent value in a life and hence are open to the idea of sacrificing a few lives for the "good of the many".
Non-religious people are no different than religious people in the way they view life and its inherent value. They simply don't feel that value necessitates a supernatural framework. I know this will likely be incomprehensible to you, but one does not need to believe in God at all to value human life.
- thinkingemote 4y agoNon religious people live in a culture that has been created by people including religious people. In other cultures and times in the past, for example, all human life was not valued and slavery was considered a normal part of life. We don't really understand what culture is and think that the values are fundamental constant variables baked into biology.
- dale_glass 4y ago> In other cultures and times in the past, for example, all human life was not valued and slavery was considered a normal part of life. That's funny, because in a large amount the justification for slavery was religious. The perks of religion are great if you're on the right side. The downside is that you might also find yourself on the side of the "other", and then any concerns you might have stop mattering, and how much that might suck for you doesn't matter because deontology doesn't concern itself with consequences.
- socceroos 4y agoWhat's wrong with slavery? We're no further away from outright slavery than we were in the 1800's. The idea of mechanical equality, where all are masters, is absurdism.
- dale_glass 4y ago> What's wrong with slavery? Gee, I wonder. Maybe read a history book? > The idea of mechanical equality, where all are masters, is absurdism. Because you put it in an absurd way. Dispense with the idea of "masters" and what you have is peers, which makes perfect sense.
- krapp 4y agoModern culture is more the product of secularism than religion. We understand a great deal about what culture is. We have entire fields of scientific and academic study devoted to it, and centuries of research on it. And believing that cultural values are baked into biology is often the basis for racist ideology. Regardless, the claim that only religious people value human life and everyone else is an amoral sociopath is as pernicious as it is false.
- soco 4y agoLike a famous tweet expressed, if one needs the threat of eternal damnation to do good in life, they're not really good persons.
- lynx23 4y agoThats my observation. If someone needs that threat, they are likely not fun to be around.
- MandieD 4y agoI have agnostic/atheist friends who are “better Christians” than many of the professed Christians I grew up with in Central Texas, and the country I live in, Germany, is currently more of a “Christian” country than my home region, despite (or because of?) a much lower level of personal faith, if you use “what did Jesus tell us to do” as your main metric (feeding, clothing, housing poor), but less-religious Finland is even more Christian by that measure. And I say that as someone who still considers herself to be a Christian. The Western world is a lot less authoritarian than it was 60 years ago for people like me - women, that is. In the early 60s, I could not get a bank account, a job or a driver’s license without my husband’s permission in Bavaria. And that was nothing to very Catholic Francoist Spain, where I couldn’t leave the country or study at university without my father’s (if unmarried) or husband’s permission.