I would attempt to temper my criticism because I think it's great that you're putting it out there. The short of it: this reads like a wish-list of a hardcore

I would attempt to temper my criticism because I think it's great that you're putting it out there. The short of it: this reads like a wish-list of a hardcore engine programmer that is for the most part divorced from market realities (the business side of game-dev) and what players actually want/care about. Therefor it is mostly irrelevant. Background: I've worked professionally in game development for the last ~13.5 years and am currently running a small indie studio (5 employees).