3 ms·
>I pirate a lot of stuff, and almost all of it I couldn't possibly have legally acquired. If pirating didn't exist, I would have never listened to weird al's so
by freehunter 15y ago
>I pirate a lot of stuff, and almost all of it I couldn't possibly have legally acquired. If pirating didn't exist, I would have never listened to weird al's songs, nor watched movies banned in my country for political reasons.
This still isn't a good argument. Justifying the means by which you acquired content still doesn't make it morally right or legal. "But I can't get it without piracy!" still doesn't give you any right to consume the product. Buying vs pirating... there's a third option. Abstinence. If you can't get Weird Al's media legally, you can always just not get it at all.
- Trufa 15y agoI think you are missing the point. You are not seeing the global issue, rather the individual one. Pirating is already a reality, that you can not change (much like drugs) and the entertainment music is the only one that is missing out by not being able to adapt. In today's reality, if the only possibility you give people to not pirate is abstain, well then you are begging for more piracy.
- kbolino 15y agoIf a man walked into a store, and the retailer refused to sell him a product because of his nationality, what would we call that? Why does it magically become acceptable--even defensible--on a larger scale?
- eurleif 15y agoThere's a difference between someone who's in your country but of a different nationality, and someone who's in a different country.
- kbolino 15y agoThat's vacuous reasoning. I know the situations are different; I'm asking why one is ethically intolerable and the other is ethically acceptable to the point of making civil disobedience unethical (in freehunter's opinion, anyway). To put it another way, what about that difference justifies the discrimination?
- eurleif 15y agoIP rights to the same work in different countries are sold separately, and can end up being owned by different companies. Also, different countries have different economies, which means it makes sense to manage distribution in separate countries separately.
- kbolino 15y agoI concur, and that's a succinct description of how this discrimination has been made possible, but it's completely orthogonal to my question.
- pyre 15y agoI thought that globalization and the 'tearing down' of national borders was a good thing? Doesn't this go against the idea that multi-national corporations can divide up the global into separate regions (e.g. dvd region codes)?
- polymatter 15y ago> IP rights to the same work in different countries are sold separately, and can end up being owned by different companies My understanding is that most licences grant permission to consume the content (listen to music, watch the film ...) irrespective of the country of your physical location (as long as its not public broadcast or rented out). Otherwise I would need to repurchase all my ipod songs and reading books when I go on holiday. > Also, different countries have different economies, which means it makes sense to manage distribution in separate countries separately. In physical distribution this makes sense. Each country has a different import/customs bureaucracy which must be followed which takes time and money. Then you need agreements with shipping, wholesalers, etc. But over the web, serving separate countries is trivial. In fact, the web server doesn't know where your customer is until you geolocate their IP address. Besides, I'm sure there were reasonable business reasons to exclude blacks from certain businesses too. Perhaps allowing blacks into a pub would irrevocably damage its brand with its standard clientele; perhaps allowing blacks to sit on a bus would mean the business would need more buses to ensure that all whites could have a seat; perhaps allowing blacks to rent a room in a hotel would mean it would be more expensive to keep track of whether the bed sheets have been used by a black couple or not. Legitimate business concerns may explain discrimination but not justify it.
- cynicalkane 15y agoI hate that this is downvoted. Content owners have the right to dictate, within the bounds of law, how their content is to be used. The only reason this is controversial is because music is usually owned and distributed by the Bad Guys. If this was a case about illegally using GPLed software, for example, there wouldn't even need to be a discussion.
- pyre 15y ago> Content owners have the right to dictate, within > the bounds of law So if he lives somewhere that didn't sign the Berne Convention, then it's ok, right? Or is that where we drop the premise of the 'good == legal' argument and start trying to debate the morality of it?
- loup-vaillant 15y ago> Buying vs pirating... there's a third option. Abstinence. If we were talking about rival goods, you'd be right. But we're talking about digital information here. You don't remove it from where you get it. So if your only alternative is (illegal) copying vs abstinence, then I see little reason to restrain yourself. Furthermore, I think it is unethical to forbid the use of, say, The Pirate Bay for copying stuff you couldn't have obtained otherwise. Because it makes you poorer for no benefit at all for the copyright holders.