45 ms·
Just want to point out that your perception of what is offensive is going to be strongly skewed from the perspective of everyone else. That's just human psychol
by danso 15y ago
Just want to point out that your perception of what is offensive is going to be strongly skewed from the perspective of everyone else. That's just human psychology and relative experience; because you're the originator of all the humor and jokes, you know exactly where the wit stems from. Anyone who is not you (or a close friend of yours) does not, and no matter how much you say "It wasn't meant to be offensive, people who know me know it's my sense of humor," that's not a sentiment that strangers can judge. So they're likely to go with their gut and have a negative first impression. Simple as that.
People on HN are most likely more tolerant/forgiving of this as long as the hacking is good. I doubt that suits at Microsoft or any other corpopration will be. There's just not much point in risking offending someone who has the ability to ax a deal when the humor in question -- from the average outsider's perspective -- adds absolutely nothing to the enjoyment of the explanation.
- a3camero 15y agoI think I'm in that "more tolerant" crowd, but the pictures made me stop reading pretty quickly. Just doesn't look like something I'll be interested in even if the content is good.
- balloot 15y agoExactly my experience.
- phillmv 15y agoFrankly, it's quite immature and it's the sort of thing that belongs on http://programmersbeingdicks.tumblr.com/ http://programmersbeingdicks.tumblr.com/
- ctide 15y agoPeople on HN are most likely more tolerant/forgiving of this as long as the hacking is good. Really? Have you read this thread? Any time there's anything remotely immature or misogynistic posted, the comments tend to focus way more on that than the actual content. Not saying that it's bad or good, just pointing out that I'd say HN is MORE sensitive than most places to this sort of thing.
- danso 15y agoGiven the relative maturity and (geographic) diversity of the demographic here, I think we give a pass to a lot of design/taste-related faux pas, as long as the idea/discussion is great. But the content in the OP arguably crossed the line, thus the high number of complaining comments.
- TheEzEzz 15y agoHi danso, I agree it's difficult to correctly gauge how others will react to any piece. For this blog post I had my three sisters read it -- as well as about half a dozen other people from diverse backgrounds -- and no one found it offensive. Of course, that's not a guarantee that no one anywhere will find it offensive. The first picture is a bit edgy, I agree. Perhaps that colors the interpretation of the remaining pictures. But the following pictures are really not offensive at all. The next picture is of a woman molesting me (in a pretty PG way). Then there is a picture of a man kissing me. The last picture is of a monkey. That seems pretty harmless by most standards. But I can certainly see how the first picture may set people up to interpret the remaining pictures in a different light.
- glhaynes 15y agoI don't mean to overstep my bounds here (and it's not any of my concern anyway), but when people are telling you that something's offensive [1], responding with an assertion that "it's not offensive at all" and an explanation of why that's so is a HUGE RED SIGN that you're ... not getting it. Whether you're right or wrong. [1] I think the word "offensive" is overused these days — I wouldn't say I was offended by your post but I did find it very distasteful.