3 ms·
I'm skeptical of the claim that the inquiline behavior is something complex. The ant isn't literally aware of "I'm as social parasite and therefore do all these
by kazinator 4y ago
I'm skeptical of the claim that the inquiline behavior is something complex. The ant isn't literally aware of "I'm as social parasite and therefore do all these things". It's just behaving randomly.
Arguably, the complex behavior is, in fact, not laying eggs in other colonies, which the mutation breaks.
Scientists should be skeptical of a elaborate hypotheses like "a new, complex behavior has emerged via a single mutation", and look for the simplest possible interpretations of what is observed. Occam's Razor and all that. For any hypothesis, you have to look for reasons and ways it might be false.
- skadamou 4y agoThe articles explanation for the origin of this super gene seems similarly complex. Relying on their being some previous version of ant that is not clonal is a step too far into speculation for me to consider that hypothesis too seriously. Or maybe I’m missing something? Maybe an entomologist would think differently!
- matt_kantor 4y agoI'm no entomologist, but I'm sure there was some previous version of these ants that was not clonal. The last common ancestor of all ants was not clonal.
- kevviiinn 4y agoIt isn't behaving randomly, no organism does. It is reacting to stimuli. The mechanism that determine how it reacts to the stimuli have just changed with the mutation
- melagonster 4y agothis is not a new complex behaviour, it happens in many different species.