3 ms·
> Cool. Video evidence, written evidence, witness testimony, and essentially everything else is now off the table. Congratulations; you've gotten rid of the ent
by AnthonyMouse 4y ago
> Cool. Video evidence, written evidence, witness testimony, and essentially everything else is now off the table. Congratulations; you've gotten rid of the entire trial court system.
You're going to create a deepfake of witness testimony in front of a live jury? How does that work?
And it's not that you can't submit a video, it's that if you want to, you should have to go find the person who took the video and have them testify that what it shows is what actually happened. And have them be identified, so their credibility can be called into question, e.g. if it turns out they're a long-time antagonist of the defendant.
> Yes. If you aren't willing to argue against a piece of evidence in a convincing fashion, you have to live with that decision. The jury gets to draw inference from "huh, they didn't say anything in response to that..."
But they did have something to say in response to that: Deepfakes are cheap and easy to create. That's a general argument, not a claim about the facts of the case, so it doesn't require testimony to substantiate.
> "This is a seven year old video hosted publicly on YouTube, on the channel of a long-standing reputable organization, of a live event hosted by well-known reporters, which received contemporary news coverage. The claims in the video made by Musk are of a similar nature to others he has demonstrably made."
None of which proves that the video is real. At best it's evidence that it's a possible fake which is seven years old and was published by an established organization.
What they could do is find the reporter who did the interview and bring them in to testify that what the video depicts is what actually happened, if they have a better memory of it than Musk. Which they may very well be able to do. But the point is that they should have to.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> You're going to create a deepfake of witness testimony in front of a live jury? How does that work? Witness testimony is trivially fabricated. It happens all the time in court. The solution is to rebut it, not ban it. > But they did have something to say in response to that: Deepfakes are cheap and easy to create. That's not a reasonable response, any more than "I saw him shoot the person" can't be rebutted with a vague, hand-wavy "well sometimes people lie" by itself. > None of which proves that the video is real. At best it's evidence that it's a possible fake which is seven years old and was published by an established organization. I don't think you're arguing in good faith.
- AnthonyMouse 4y ago> Witness testimony is trivially fabricated. It happens all the time in court. The solution is to rebut it, not ban it. Witness testimony is under oath. You can lie, but then you can go to jail. And you can be cross-examined, unlike a video. The risk of punishment reduces the incentive to lie and the interactivity increases the potential for it to be discovered. Witnesses also have varying credibility. If the witness is the plaintiff, they have an obvious incentive to lie and juries know that. Whereas a video from an unauthenticated source is no more credible but fosters the intuition that you're seeing something with your own eyes. > I don't think you're arguing in good faith. I think I am. I think we can agree that a random video from a random YouTube channel has no credibility. But if you're going to stake the value of your evidence on the credibility of the source, you should at least have to establish that it can actually be authenticated by one of these credible parties and not just e.g. some syndicated clip that got published on their channel. Which, once again, you may be able to do. But you should still have the burden of actually doing it.
- ImPostingOnHN 4y agothey do have the burden of doing that, to the satisfaction of the jury if all elmu has to say in response is "well maybe it's a deepfake, but I won't say if I think it is", obviously any jury would be hard pressed to suppress their pressing giggles before rejecting such a weak excuse