3 ms·
> He's trying to get out of having to make any definitive statement about if it's a real video or not. How do you propose to prove if he actually remembers or
by AnthonyMouse 4y ago
> He's trying to get out of having to make any definitive statement about if it's a real video or not.
How do you propose to prove if he actually remembers or not?
> It's doubtful Musk would be willing to claim this one was fake - there are a lot of witnesses that could be dug up.
But then the prosecution doesn't need the video because they would have all of these witness, so why should it be admissible if it can't be authenticated?
- ceejayoz 4y ago> How do you propose to prove if he actually remembers or not? He doesn't have to remember it for it to be good evidence. If he wants to say "I don't think I would've said that", go for it. > But then the prosecution doesn't need the video because they would have all of these witness, so why should it be admissible if it can't be authenticated? The video is perfectly good evidence (and its age and provenance make it pretty reputable). If the defense contests its veracity, that's when you start going to witnesses.
- AnthonyMouse 4y ago> He doesn't have to remember it for it to be good evidence. He doesn't have to remember it for it to be bad evidence either. > If he wants to say "I don't think I would've said that", go for it. But then what are you trying to hold him to? A subjective opinion? > The video is perfectly good evidence (and its age and provenance make it pretty reputable). If the defense contests its veracity, that's when you start going to witnesses. The defense will always contest its veracity if the burden is on the prosecution to prove it and they haven't. The point is that they should have to prove it. Sometimes they'll be able to.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> But then what are you trying to hold him to? A subjective opinion? He needs to make a claim about the evidence in question if he thinks it's fake. (He doesn't. He knows it's a genuine video.) Again, a vague assertion that "sometimes people make deepfakes about me" doesn't cut it. > The defense will always contest its veracity if the burden is on the prosecution to prove it and they haven't. The defense is highly unlikely to make the claim that a seven year old video on a prominent channel with top industry reporters didn't happen. Plenty of pieces of evidence get entered into the court's records without being contested.
- AnthonyMouse 4y ago> He needs to make a claim about the evidence in question if he thinks it's fake. Why? What if he thinks it could be fake, and doesn't know? Why should that reduce the other party's burden? > The defense is highly unlikely to make the claim that a seven year old video on a prominent channel with top industry reporters didn't happen. But it's not the defense claiming that it didn't happen, it's the plaintiff claiming that it did. They should have to prove their claims. And sometimes they'll be able to. > Plenty of pieces of evidence get entered into the court's records without being contested. They don't get contested when the defense doesn't want to aggravate the judge by demanding proof of something they know the other party has, even if they have a right to. That's a different question than whether the other party should have the burden of proof in the cases where they might not be able to meet it.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> What if he thinks it could be fake, and doesn't know? He will be asked to justify that belief, and that justification will be weighed against the provenance of the video. That he's not saying that is telling; claiming the video is faked would likely hurt his credibility given the number of times he's provably made statements of this kind. > They should have to prove their claims. They have submitted it as evidence. The jury weighs if it's credible. If Musk chooses not to rebut/contest it, that's on him, not the plaintiff.
- AnthonyMouse 4y ago> He will be asked to justify that belief Why? His lawyers could provide the same justification: Convincing deepfakes are easily produced at low cost by adversarial plaintiffs and internet trolls. > That he's not saying that is telling People are imperfect and if you misspeak under oath there are consequences. Testifying at all subjects you to cross-examination, which is time consuming and subjects you to lawyer tricks by the other party. Not wanting to do it is the default. > They have submitted it as evidence. The jury weighs if it's credible. First the judge decides if it's even admissible. There are some forms of evidence so weak that they only serve to prejudice the jury, and unauthenticated video is pretty much there now. Demanding that the introducing party authenticate it should be table stakes at this point.
- majormajor 4y ago> But then the prosecution doesn't need the video because they would have all of these witness, so why should it be admissible if it can't be authenticated? There's not a "prosecution." Did you read the article I linked? This is a civil lawsuit (which also means a different level of evidence required, ultimately) still in fairly early stages. The trial hasn't even started. "Judge Evette Pennypacker tentatively ordered a limited, three-hour deposition where Musk could be asked whether he actually made the statements on the recordings" - there's no ruling of fact yet about if the video is real, the Judge is just saying "this looks like a bullshit excuse to avoid having to talk about your past comments." The plaintiff is trying to get Musk to give a deposition regarding his claims about self-driving. Musk is trying to not even have to give that testimony. This is exactly that "we need to figure out if this evidence is real or not" process that you say is needed! Musk is just trying to throw that out and say "nah we don't even need it, it could be fake, ya know." The judge seems to think that a 6+ year old video from a fairly well-known publication carries enough weight compared to a lazy "IDK, sometimes people deep fake me" statement to be worth asking Musk further questions. That seems reasonable to me. > How do you propose to prove if he actually remembers or not? Obviously that's impossible, but it's also irrelevant. If he says he doesn't remember, but you have a video with an uploaded-to-Youtube-timestamp from 2016, and contemporary coverage, then you say "well, since you don't remember for sure, we're gonna go with all the evidence that suggests you did say this."