7 ms·
So imagine a scenario: 1. crime organization (or governmental org) buys / steals a bunch of phones 2. org opens boxes, tampers with boot loader in such a way
by cduzz 3y ago
So imagine a scenario:
1. crime organization (or governmental org) buys / steals a bunch of phones
2. org opens boxes, tampers with boot loader in such a way that they (and / or the original OEM and / or the original OS vendor) have a persistent remote administration account on phone
3. org then returns phones to supply chain either covertly or off the back of a truck.
4. org leverages remote access to do shady things
5. "the press" finds out that "vendor phones XYZ are trojaned!" and vendor looks like t-mobile for 5-30 hours until people find another cat video to look at.
A theoretical justification of this is that phones are stolen all the time from the supply chain. Making lots require remote activation allows the vendor to kill the stolen phones, reducing their resale market in that part of the stolen phone ecosystem. Another theoretical justification is to "protect" the average buyer who just wants a damned phone to look at cat videos on and maybe call their spouse when they're late; they don't wear boots and don't care about loaders. Just Want Cat Videos.
- thomastjeffery 3y agoThe answer to that should not be to become the shady seller.
- cduzz 3y agoIn these modern times I don't think any company actually trusts the contractors that have been hired to make a product. You (some big name company) hire some company to make 10,000 widgets; your contractors may turn around and make 300,000 widgets sell you the 10,000 widgets per the agreement and sell the other 290,000 into other channels. They may sell the ones that didn't pass QA, they may make ones with cheaper parts, etc. How do you stop this? See above - the part has to phone home and you can enable it (or not!) because you've got a registry of which things are legit and which aren't. Also, this lets the companies spy on you. Errr.. Collect telemetry to allow them to improve the product.