4 ms·
Looks reasonable to me; but this analysis doesn't really try to grapple with the political consequences of the coercive vaccination campaigns backed up by what
by roenxi 4y ago
Looks reasonable to me; but this analysis doesn't really try to grapple with the political consequences of the coercive vaccination campaigns backed up by what were, as far as I can tell, human rights violations:
1) Massive and public damage done to the cause of liberty. Picking a minor, I wouldn't want to imagine the looks that someone protesting the Roe v. Wade overturning got if they tried to chant "my body, my choice!". There is firm precedent now for a generation that your body, government's choice. We're more likely to regret that than a few people hurting/killing themselves out of stupidity refusing to take a vaccine as the authoritarians start making more invasive demands.
2) Forcing someone to do something against their volition, followed up by the rather obvious point that the coercers were acting without full information or particularly good intent (see: "Why did COVID become so polarizing?"), will have consequences just from the bad blood it created. There are some angry, angry people out there now. People who have a very compelling argument that it is acceptable to coerce your political opponents and punish them in disproportionate ways.
3) It still isn't obvious that the all in cost/benefits of the policies were worth it factoring in 2nd order effects and opportunity costs. We're staring at nuclear war between the two countries with the largest arsenals right now. It might have been worth just ignoring COVID, letting people make their own choices for better or worse and focusing on not finding a diplomatic peace in the northern hemisphere. The nuclear war risk is probably higher than the COVID risk, although a lot more all-or-nothing. It was almost completely ignored because of the resources spent trying to keep unwilling people inside their own homes. Also the global economy overall is in a terrible place, the damage is incalculable but large and probably comparable to losing 1% of the population. There is a famine problem out there [0].
A well-meaning analysis and noting that 1% of the population could die doesn't really capture the trade offs here. 1% of the world is going to die every year anyway; doubling that is bad. Normalising, justifying and defending mass suspensions of human rights is, amazingly, probably going to be worse.
[0] https://www.who.int/news/item/06-07-2022-un-report--global-hunger-numbers-rose-to-as-many-as-828-million-in-2021 https://www.who.int/news/item/06-07-2022-un-report--global-h...
- ramraj07 4y agoI explicitly didn’t touch the forced vaccination part in the article to avoid being misquoted tbh. As far as I can tell the United States did not make any undue coercive steps; are you talking about the period when some states required vaccination proof for entering public closed spaces? How is that different from banning smoking in closed spaces?
- iinnPP 4y agoOne difference, without picking a side of where that lands in impact(and based on Ontario, Canada's rules): Natural immunity wasn't allowed.
- ramraj07 4y agoDid natural immunity work though? Pretty much every active American I know has gotten Covid not once but twice at the least. Of course even in that statement the nuance of what strains etc was lost. I’ll actually agree that by the time vaccine mandates were made the strains didn’t diverge that much and it should have been perfectly acceptable to show iron clad proof of prior infection as an alternative for vaccine proof (if I’m not wrong that was actually the case in some scenarios).
- randomopining 4y agoI am/was pro-vax but they should've made cert of prior infection equivalent. Because it was nearly as good at one point, and then it actually became a better indicator of resistence
- amluto 4y agoThere was a period of time (around when Delta showed up IIRC) when the evidence was pretty compelling that infection plus one vaccine was substantially more protective than no infection and two vaccines. Right now the evidence that boosters are more than a little bit helpful is rather lacking.
- Auracle 4y agoFrom most of the studies I saw natural immunity was more effective than the vaccines - and both were (slightly) better yet. I say this as someone that got the original strain and then delta - and both were quite serious. I remember at the time I got delta there was supposed to be about a 1% chance of me getting reinfected, though that study might have been pre-delta as I got it quite early.
- slaw 4y ago
- dmbche 4y agoJust to clarify, were vaccines mandatory where you lived? They were not in my country other than for health professionals if I remember correctly - but I was chatting with my dentist this week that didn't get it.
- gruez 4y agoThey were never "mandatory" in the sense that if you didn't get it the government would fine you or cart you off to jail, but there were "soft" mandates in the form of "if you want to do [activity], you need to be vaccinated", where [activity] ranged from "indoor businesses" to "indoor events with more than 1,000 attendees " [1] https://ballotpedia.org/State_government_policies_about_vaccine_requirements_(vaccine_passports) https://ballotpedia.org/State_government_policies_about_vacc...
- ithkuil 4y agoA temporary limitation to your freedom vs being forced to bear a child. I think those two things can be confused only if you intentionally want to confuse them.
- Auracle 4y agoYou’re downplaying one and, uh, up-playing the other. Vaccines can technically have permanent side effects. You’d only be” forced to bear a child” if you decide to have sex without adequate birth control. There’s also another body involved. Just to be clear I’m pro-choice, though I think abortion should be done as early as possible. I just really dislike dishonest rhetoric.
- ithkuil 4y agoSorry if I wasn't clear, I was talking about the where people felt their rights were infringed because they couldn't go to a restaurant without a vaccine. Surely, forcing people to get a vaccine at gunpoint is as serious as it gets. The middle-ground is trickier: how to think about professionals who have been effectively forced to get a vaccine at the cost of losing their jobs and livelihood. In practice though I've heard way more complaining about absolute freedom from people in the former camp. As for the adequate birth control angle: sure, some people are careless, some people are just young, birth control methods do fail, etc. there are so many ways you can end up with a unwanted pregnancy, including some that are easier to sympathize with even for the most strict defender of the morals (I hope), like rape.
- Auracle 4y agoI doubt there are good stats on this, but the only people I've ever known to have an abortion it was because they weren't using birth control (or correctly). My wife used to watch that MTV show about teen pregnancy, and they all pretty much had the same story. If I were king for a day I'd make every abortion more expensive than the last, and I would also make it more expensive the further along you are - barring fetal abnormalities and other gotchas. Those fees would go towards birth control and education about it.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoYou're making a lot of assumptions, some of them almost slight-of-handish and it makes this whole thing read as not particularly trustworthy to me. For example what is "the cause of liberty?" As phrased nearly anyone would support that abstract concept, but when they find out what concrete policies other people mean by that it's a source of vicious conflict. So what do you mean by it? Another is the repeated assumption that covid mitigation steps like isolation and vaccination have no impact beyond the individual. This is a normative american mindset, maybe, but completely insufficient for addressing a public health issue like a pandemic. As witnessed by the US having something like 1/5 of the global covid deaths. Rhetorically irresponsible not to address this point, given the subject and context. And then finally you're assuming a lot of things happened because of covid, when it's possible-to-likely covid provided only the proximate trigger or justification. To address your examples: russia and ukraine were already at war & this escalation had been predicted for years; famine is well understood to be a political phenomenon and covid provided a justification to accelerate policies of austerity and inequality, but none of them were invented recently.