5 ms·
Absolutely, this is the one reason I'm not interested in passkeys yet. I want to fully own my authentication keys myself. Not trusting Google or Microsoft for t
by wkat4242 4y ago
Absolutely, this is the one reason I'm not interested in passkeys yet. I want to fully own my authentication keys myself. Not trusting Google or Microsoft for that.
I hope it comes to zx2c4 pass too <3
- eptcyka 4y agoWith the sad state of PGP on Android, I hope someone picks up development on a viable alternative or ressurrects OpenKeychain. Currently, I cannot use my PGP keys because they're too new on Android.
- wkat4242 4y agoI think OpenKeyChain is pretty great, I still use it. Unfortunately the authors went commercial (heylogin) and this is why they abandoned it. Their new products are very corporate and not interesting to me as an end user. But OKC is really necessary for my entire flow. I use it with password store, with termux (through OKCAgent) and some other things. I hope someone else picks it up too, but as long as they incorporate security fixes it's fine. I use yubikeys for the actual encryption anyway so the only risk is in the symmetric part. But what's the problem with your keys being too new?
- eptcyka 4y agoMy ed25519 keys can't decrypt my secrets due to a parsing error somewhere. I can still use okc-ssh-agent to SSH into places, but I cannot decrypt my passwords, which is kind of a big deal. It's because of this I'll probably migrate to a self-hosted bitwarden and use FIDO auth with my yubikey. I'll still use the GPG key for SSH authentication, but boy is this a mess I don't have any time for. And when I say I don't have the time for, I tried to get OpenKeychain to use a newer version of BouncyCastle, which should support my encrypted files just fine, but boy do I not have the knowledge to deal with changes in a project's gradle structure. I think the root of the issue is that newer versions of GPG have changed the format of the ciphertext in a way that the bouncy castle version OpenKeychain is using doesn't parse. Anyway, I do not feel confident in mucking about in crypto code. Maybe there's hope in just porting a front-end of pass that uses a plain ported GPG implementation instead.
- snapplebobapple 4y agocheck out psono too for self hosting (https://psono.com/ https://psono.com/) It's on my todo to do this myself but I haven't had time yet. It looks a lot more interesting to me than self hosted bitwarden/vaultwarden though, especially if you have needs to fill like encrypted file storage that are slightly above and beyond bitwarden's design.
- fn-mote 4y ago> I think the root of the issue is that newer versions of GPG have changed the format of the ciphertext in a way that the bouncy castle version OpenKeychain is using doesn't parse. It might be worth your effort to test your hypothesis with an older version of GPG. The LTS version would be especially easy to investigate.
- cyphar 4y agoI don't understand which part of FIDO/WebAuthn requires "trusting Google or Microsoft"?
- stavros 4y agoNone, it's just misinformation.
- TacticalCoder 4y agoI don't think it's misinformation. You may decide, on your own website, for your own users, to accept passkeys from everybody but others won't. Sadly enough it's a near guarantee that the less secure implementations of passkeys (the software ones, allowing cloning and backups in the cloud) are likely to be the most accepted. While actually secure implementation with the secret hidden deep down behind an HSM and never leaving it, made by smaller companies who do care about security, are likely to be rejected on the ground that it's too much of an "obscure" vendor. I already posted about it today but if you think about it it's literally insane that cloning was meant to be detectable (and detection was enforced and upon detecting a cloned key, one of the two keys would stop working) and that this feature has now been removed with the sole justification being: "Because software backups to the cloud". It is not good.
- vbezhenar 4y agoAre passkeys somehow signed by Google/Apple? I thought passkeys are like ssh keys.
- stavros 4y agoThey are, except they have a vendor ID that allows you to tell which vendor made the device you're talking to. You can get Passkeys by any number of vendors, but any authenticating website can decide to only allow a few vendors to log in with it.
- 4y ago